Triple Culture of Primary Human Osteoblasts, Osteoclasts and Osteocytes as an In Vitro Bone Model (original) (raw)
Related papers
Methods and Protocols
New biomaterials and scaffolds for bone tissue engineering (BTE) applications require to be tested in a bone microenvironment reliable model. On this assumption, the in vitro laboratory protocols with bone cells represent worthy experimental systems improving our knowledge about bone homeostasis, reducing the costs of experimentation. To this day, several models of the bone microenvironment are reported in the literature, but few delineate a protocol for testing new biomaterials using bone cells. Herein we propose a clear protocol to set up an indirect co-culture system of human-derived osteoblasts and osteoclast precursors, providing well-defined criteria such as the cell seeding density, cell:cell ratio, the culture medium, and the proofs of differentiation. The material to be tested may be easily introduced in the system and the cell response analyzed. The physical separation of osteoblasts and osteoclasts allows distinguishing the effects of the material onto the two cell types ...
Journal of Biomedical Materials Research Part A, 2007
In vitro studies about the growth behavior of osteoblasts onto biomaterials is a basic knowledge and a screening method for the development and application of scaffolds in vivo. In this in vitro study human osteoblast-like (HOB) cells were cultured on seven different biomaterials used in dental and craniomaxillofacial surgery, respectively. The tested biomaterials were synthetic biodegradable (MacroPore®, Ethisorb®, PDS®, Beriplast® P) and nonbiodegradable polymers (Palacos®) as well as calcium phosphate cement (BoneSource®) and titanium. The cell proliferation and cell colonization were analyzed by scanning electron microscopy and EZ4U-test. Statistical analysis were performed. HOB-like cells cultivated on Ethisorb showed the highest proliferation rate. The proliferation rate was statistically significant compared with Palacos, MacroPore, and BoneSource. Whereas, Beriplast, PDS, and titanium yielded lower proliferation rates. However, there was no statistically significant difference compared with Palacos, MacroPore, and BoneSource. SEM analysis showed no significant difference in individual cell features and cell colonization. But an infiltration and a growth of HOB-like cells throughout the porous structure of Ethisorb, which is formed by crossing fibers, is a striking different feature (macrotopography). This feature can explain the highest proliferation rate of Ethisorb. The results showed that HOB-like cells appear to be sensitive to substrate composition and topography. Moreover, the basis for further studies with such biomaterial/osteoblast constructs in vivo are provided. Further focusing points are developing techniques to fabricate three-dimensional porous biomaterial/cell constructs, studying the tissue reaction and the bone regeneration of such constructs compared with the use of autologous bone. © 2007 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Biomed Mater Res, 2007
Biomaterials, 2004
A sufficient amount of easily obtained and well-characterized osteoblastic cells is a useful tool to study biomaterial/cell interactions essential for bone tissue engineering. Osteoblastic cells were derived from adult and fetal rat via different isolation techniques. The isolation and in vitro proliferation of primary cultures were compared. The osteogenic potential of subcultures was studied by culturing them in osteogenic medium and compared with respect to alkaline phosphatase activity, nodule formation and mineralization potential. Calvaria cells were easier to obtain and the amount of cells released by enzymatic isolation was higher than for the long bone cells. The expansion of the cells in primary culture was highest for fetal calvaria cells compared to fetal and adult long bone cells. All cultures expressed high alkaline phosphatase activity except for calvaria cells obtained by spontaneous outgrowth. Enzymatic isolation of fetal calvaria and long bone cells favoured the osteogenic differentiation. Enzymatically isolated calvaria cells formed well-defined three-dimensional nodules which mineralized restricted to this area. On the contrary, cultures derived from fetal as well as adult long bones mineralized in ill-defined deposits throughout the culture and only formed occasionally nodular-like structures. The mineral phase of all osteoblastic cultures was identified as a carbonate-containing apatite. The present study demonstrates that considering the isolation method, proliferation capacity and the osteogenic potential, the enzymatically released fetal calvaria cells are most satisfactory to study cell/biomaterial interactions. r
An essential requirement for osteoclasts in refined bone-like tissue reconstruction in vitro
Medical hypotheses, 2006
One crucial but often disregarded problem in tissue-engineered bone is that osteoblasts in culture significantly differ in function and behavior from their counterparts in vivo. This difference is represented as an inability of cultured osteoblasts to form lamellar bone-like structures and deposit the characteristic mineral of native bone, as well as their loss of polarity of matrix secretion, marked by tissue growth bridging the pore interconnections of scaffolds. These abnormalities of in vitro bone formation are a major cause of the current failure to yield functional and mechanically competent bone. Recent studies with osteoclast deficient animal models have definitely revealed that the regulatory effect of osteoclasts is essential for normal bone formation. The abnormalities of bone formation present in osteoclast deficient animals are largely reflected in current tissue-engineered bone. Reasonably, the abnormalities of in vitro bone formation most likely result from the absenc...
In search of an osteoblast cell model for in vitro research
European cells & materials, 2012
The process of bone formation, remodelling and healing involves a coordinated action of various cell types. Advances in understanding the biology of osteoblast cells during these processes have been enabled through the use of various in vitro culture models from different origins. In an era of intensive bone tissue engineering research, these cell models are more and more often applied due to limited availability of primary human osteoblast cells. While they are a helpful tool in developing novel therapies or biomaterials; concerns arise regarding their phenotypic state and differences in relation to primary human osteoblast cells. In this review we discuss the osteoblastic development of some of the available cell models; such as primary human, rat, mouse, bovine, ovine and rabbit osteoblast cells; as well as MC3T3-E1, MG-63 and SaOs-2 cell lines, together with their advantages and disadvantages. Through this, we provide suggestions on the selection of the appropriate and most rele...
In vivo osteogenic activity of isolated human bone cells
Journal of Bone and Mineral Research, 2009
Human bone cells were obtained as the outgrowth from cancellous bone fragments pretreated with collagenase and DNase. The osteogenic potential of cells in primary culture was assessed upon intramuscular transplantation into young mice pretreated with cortisone. Transplants were recovered after 2 weeks and examined by light microscopy. Of 34 transplants, 6 showed evidence of osteogenesis and 12 the production of unmineralized matrix. Only cells were observed in the other transplants. In an attempt to find a biochemical marker for osteogenic cells we have assayed medium osteocalcin and alkaline phosphatase activity levels in cultures before transplantation. N o correlation was found between !he level of expression of the two osleoblast markers and the osteogenic potential of the cells.
Comparative in vitro study of four commercial biomaterials used for bone grafting
Journal of Applied Biomaterials & Functional Materials, 2013
Even if autogenous bone still remains the gold standard to augment or bridge osseous defects, bone substitute materials of natural (natural-derived materials and biological materials) or of synthetic origin are becoming increasingly used to avoid the risks associated with autogenous bone graft (peri-operative risks, specific operative complications and post-operative morbidity).
Journal of Biomedical Materials Research Part A, 2013
Immortalized cell lines are used more frequently in basic and applied biology research than primary bonederived cells because of their ease of access and repeatability of results in experiments. It is clear that these cell models do not fully resemble the behavior of primary osteoblast cells. Although the differences will affect the results of biomaterials testing, they are not clearly defined. Here, we focused on comparing proliferation and maturation potential of three osteoblast cell lines, SaOs2, MG-63, and MC3T3-E1 with primary human osteoblast (HOb) cells to assess their suitability as in vitro models for biomaterials testing. We report similarities in cell proliferation and mineralization between primary cells and MC3T3-E1. Both, SaOs2 and MG-63 cells demonstrated a higher proliferation rate than HOb cells. In addition, SaOs2, but not MG-63, cells demonstrated similar ALP activity, mineralization potential and gene regulation to HOb's. Our results demonstrate that despite SaOs-2, MG63, and MC3T3 cells being popular choices for emulating osteoblast behavior, none can be considered appropriate replacements for HOb's. Nevertheless, these cell lines all demonstrated some distinct similarities with HOb's, thus when applied in the correct context are a valuable in vitro pilot model of osteoblast functionality, but should not be used to replace primary cell studies. V C 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Biomed Mater Res Part A: 00A:000-000, 2013. How to cite this article: Czekanska EM, Stoddart MJ, Ralphs JR, Richards RG, Hayes JS. 2013. A phenotypic comparison of osteoblast cell lines versus human primary osteoblasts for biomaterials testing. J Biomed Mater Res Part A 2013: 00A: 000-000.
Journal of Biomedical Materials Research, 2000
ABSTRACT Being very useful in the analysis of bone cell differentiation and activity, osteoblast cultures are also used in the in vitro biocompatibility study of new materials. The aim of this work was to evaluate sheep osteoblast cultures derived from normal and ovariectomized animals, and then to assess the in vitro biomaterial behavior on these cultures, taking into account the quality of bone where orthopedic devices are clinically used. For this purpose, we characterized sheep osteoblast cultures, isolated from iliac crest bone of normal (NB osteoblast culture) and osteopenic after ovariectomy (OB osteoblast culture) sheep. Moreover, we studied cell behavior when cultured on different biomaterials (titanium and two biological glasses, RKKP and AP40). Cell characterization at baseline demonstrated that both cultures (NB and OB) showed normal osteoblastic behavior. On the contrary, osteoblasts derived from osteopenic bone and cultivated on AP40 for 6 days revealed a different behavior in terms of both cell morphology and metabolic activity. Statistical analysis (one-way analysis of variance and Scheffé's post hoc multiple-comparison tests) revealed significant differences in Ca level (p<0.0005), MTT test (p<0.0005) and OC production (p<0.05). These in vitro tests demonstrated that sheep osteoblast cultures can be useful when determining biocompatibility and osteointegration of orthopedic materials, and also when evaluating for the presence of osteoporosis.