A Museum in Progress: The Practice of White Accompliceship with African Exhibitions (original) (raw)
Related papers
Cross-Cultural Museum Bias: Undoing Legacies of Whiteness in Art Histories
Asian Diasporic Visual Cultures and the Americas
When museums are used as sites of knowledge production and research, what are their responsibilities for anti-racist public education? Examining the racial logics that govern, organize, and fund museums, this essay focuses on institutional bias within knowledge production and argues that locating racial logics within museums can be an act of radical pedagogy. Museums are being challenged to become sites of social change, making it vital to study their power structures and the ways in which they organize and study other cultures, illuminating imperial and colonial biases existing at their foundations. The Canadian Museum of Civilization’s exhibition The Lands within Me: Expressions by Canadian Artists of Arab Origin, is a relevant case study as it opened within weeks of September 11, 2001. The moral panic surrounding the show provides a powerful glimpse of the ways in which certain narratives are excluded from Canadian national projects and how these racial projects exist within muse...
Decolonizing African-american Museums: a Case Study on Two African-american Museums in the South
2016
DECOLONIZING AFRICAN-AMERICAN MUSEUMS: A CASE STUDY ON TWO AFRICAN-AMERICAN MUSEUMS IN THE SOUTH by Anastacia Scott The University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, 2016 Under the Supervision of Professor Doreatha Mbalia This dissertation seeks to understand how African-American museums’ exhibits help individuals gain their sense of racial identity through public memory. In an era where the United States is supposedly “post-racial” African-American museums are flourishing. As institutions serving an important role in preserving the collective memory of AfricanAmerican people in the US, African-American museums evoke questions of representation within the larger US narrative that confirm the persistent saliency of race in society, and therefore continue to have a public function in maintaining and developing a racial AfricanAmerican identity (Jackson 2012; Eichstedt and Small 2002; Wilson 2012; Golding 2009). My research is focused on the following question: What impacts do African-American mu...
Decolonizing the Colony: Challenges to Systemic Change in the American Art Museum
Journal of Curatorial Studies, 2021
This article seeks to identify impediments to, as well as opportunities for, change in American art museums in the face of demands for social justice and greater inclusivity. Focusing specifically on the representation of American art in wellestablished encyclopaedic museums, I argue that inherited collections and taxonomies, mapped onto the physical spaces of museums, limit the speed and degree to which aesthetic priorities, values and narratives may adapt in order to meet shifting demographics and visitor expectations. In effect, the challenge for many museums is to confront and navigate an institutionalized form of white supremacy baked into their intellectual and material foundations. I end by analysing several recent strategies that have aimed at dismantling conventions and complicating the canon. Across the museum world in the United States, the year 2020 will be remembered for the deleterious impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and the emancipatory force of the Black Lives Matter movement (BLM), forcing an overdue reckoning with how pre-eminent cultural institutions can foster a more diverse and inclusive workforce, environment, public face and message. On the far side of the pandemic, museums-those that survive the economic impact of COVID-will no doubt have issues of social justice, equity, diversity and
Coming Together to Address Systemic Racism in Museums
Curator: The Museum Journal, 2017
A group of 25 multi-generational, multi-racial museum professionals met in January 2016 for a 3-day dialogue about museums and race. They concurred that forming alliances among museum practitioners of all races and ethnic backgrounds is a critical step in dismantling the persistent and pervasive presence of structural racism in museums. This article asserts that there are both demographic and ethical imperatives for close examination of all aspects of museums' programs, their staffs and boards, the publics they serve, and the organizations that exist because of them. It provides an introduction to the vocabulary and attendant systems of white privilege, oppression, and intersectionality, offers concrete suggestions for people of all backgrounds to join forces, and ends with a call to action to bring racial awareness and action to the forefront in our institutions, our communities, and our nation.
White sanctuaries: race and place in art museums
International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 2019
Purpose This paper examines the Art Institute of Chicago – a nationally recognized museum – as a white sanctuary, i.e., a white institutional space within a racialized social system that serves to reassure whites of their dominant position in society. The purpose of this paper is to highlight how museums create and maintain white spaces within the greater context of being an institution for the general public. Design/methodology/approach The empirical analysis of this study is based on collaborative ethnographic data collected over a three-year period of time conducted by the first two authors, and consists of hundreds of photos and hundreds of hours of participant observations and field notes. The data are analyzed using descriptive methods and content analyses. Findings The findings highlight three specific racial mechanisms that speak to how white spaces are created, recreated and maintained within nationally and internationally elite museums: spatiality, the policing of space, a...
Exploring Manifestations of White Supremacy Culture in Art Museum Education and Interpretation
Journal of Cultural Research in Art Education, 2019
This paper looks specifically at Afro-Caribbean art and culture and explores White and Afro-Caribbean experiences and the impact of Whiteness on the ways that knowledge and practice of the arts in museums have been considered, interpreted, and characterized. Written by co-authors offering an Afro-Caribbean and White perspective, this paper offers various examples from our experiences as art museum educators of the ways Whiteness impacts our work.
The return of the AAM annual meeting to Baltimore was an opportunity to reflect on "Mining the Museum" and how the museum field has since evolved in its treatment of provenance and race. The annual meeting session “Talking About Race: ‘Mining the Museum’ After 20 Years” brought together the original players with other museum professionals who continue to grapple with these issues in their work.
Learning at the museum frontiers: identity, race and power
International Journal of Heritage Studies, 2011
Viv Golding's Learning at the Museum Frontiers: Identity, Race and Power presents varied ways to understand the importance and possibility of learning from what she defines throughout the book as 'the museum frontiers'. These she defines as: 'a spatio-temporal site for acting in collaborative effort with other institutions, which provides a space of respectful dialogical exchange for promoting critical thought, for questioning taken-for-granted ideas in general and for challenging racist and sexist mindsets in particular' (p. 2). The theoretical framework that is woven throughout the book is described as feminist hermeneutics: a fusion of the 'politically mindful' (p. 2) black feminist thought of writers such as Patricia Hill-Collins, Audre Lorde and bell hooks; the creative writing of Toni Morrison; the philosophical writing of Hans Georg Gadamer and Franz Fanon; and the liberation pedagogy of Paulo Freire, among others. Golding draws on her experience of working as a museum educator, primarily in the UK, but she also uses examples from institutions trans-nationally. The institutions she examines include the Horniman Museum in London, England; the Museum of World Culture in Göteborg, Sweden; Colonial Williamsburg, USA; and the District Six Museum in Cape Town, South Africa. The exhibitions she focuses on all attemptwith varying levels of successto provide educational encounters that can enhance inter-cultural understanding. Golding's wide selection of museums from across the globe is complemented by her in-depth analysis of the strengths and weaknesses of the exhibitions they present. Combined, these varied engagements present different examples of how learning at the museum frontiers can be an effective framework for a working practice 'which lights a different pathway, a new collaborative museum practice, which is interdisciplinary, heterogeneous and multiple' (p. 21). The first chapter, 'Race: Repositioning and Revaluing Cultural Heritage', takes as a starting point the reactionary ways in which race continues to be represented in contemporary museums. The chapter 'address[es] the pernicious effects that takenfor-granted ideas of race and racism continue to play in the museum and in the wider world today' (p. 23) as a result of the persisting legacies of imperialism, colonialism, humanism and the Enlightenment. The chapter goes on to explore the 'Art/ artefact debate' (p. 27) in the context of a number of museums that present collections of African art. Golding demonstrates how African art has often only been housed in Ethnographic museums (whereas the art of the West and certain Asian cultures are decreed the status of 'fine art'). She also demonstrates how western aestheticswhich often distinguish things through binary pairings such as