The Role of Contemporary Islamic Movement towards Social and Political Changes of Modernity (original) (raw)
Related papers
The End of the Traditional Islamic Movement’s Era
The Islamic Movement (IM) proved that it is a crucial element in the local political equations in many Arab countries such as Egypt, Jordan, Yemen, Syria, Tunisia, Palestine, Iraq and others. It became a cornerstone in the revolutions of the Arab spring where the Muslim Brotherhood specifically arrived in power through fair and legitimate elections in Egypt, Tunisia, and before that in Palestine. Since the election victory of the IM, there has been violence aimed at the IM and their supporters to exclude them from the political scene resulting in turbulence and volatility in the Middle East as a whole. The article tries to examine the life cycle of the IM under the current circumstances and to discuss the need for a holistic renewal in the IM intellectual, strategic, structural, ethical and practical construction to cope with the radical political and societal changes in the region as a result of the Arab Spring. This article suggests five key fundamental changes that must be addressed.
Reform and Resurgence: The Transformation of Islamic Movements in the 21st Century
Philosophy and Society, 2024
This paper studies the development in the thought and praxis of Islamic movements that aim to revive a political system governed by Islamic law. Post-Caliphate Islamic movements-the subject of the current study have undergone recent reforms in thought, approach, and even branding since the Arab Spring. Notwithstanding the movements' legal and theological diversity, the author argues that they share common features of reform characterized by (a) appeal to public opinion and grassroots work; and (b) willingness to work with groups outside their movement. These reforms were shaped in tandem with and in reaction to the War on Terror, the Arab Spring, and the Taliban's victory in Afghanistan. The author argues that these changes gave rise to dynamic reform in the latest generation of Islamic movements, leading to substantive revisions in their approach (manhaj) to achieving Islamic change. Despite tightening proscription and censorship, the author argues that the fruit of these reforms has been a resurgence in the form of highly efficient and creative collaboration between movements. Examples studied include collaboration between the Muslim Brothers (MB) and Hizb ut Tahrir in the West, and between former-al-Qaeda and MB affiliates in Syria. The author estimates these strategies -following a period of political failure and internal skepticism- have precipitated a resurgence that makes the future of Islamic movements highly potent, despite resulting in a dilution of each group's identity and possible decline in membership. As a result of this trajectory, this study argues for the need to theorize contemporary Islamic movements beyond historical categories that have fossilized in Western academia, and often do not capture the dynamic, fluidity and comprehensiveness of Islamic struggle. This study utilizes a mixed methodology, including archival analysis and intellectual genealogy.
Muslim society on the border of traditionality and reforming
Skhid, 2019
This article is devoted to the consideration of the state of Muslim society on the border of adherence to the traditional system and the need to reform religious and socio-legal doctrines. Comparative philosophy as a branch of research, dealing with a comparative analysis of various philosophical traditions, cultures, and particular concepts of categorical apparatus helps to find out the differences and common principles of social being. Within philosophical comparative studies we can consider the peculiarities of the reforming process of Muslim society from ancient times to the nowadays. Turning to the example of Islamic culture, we see the complexity in not only the collision of cultures and the integration of Islamic traditions to the Western world, but also in internal processes that are determined by the necessity to preserve the traditions of culture and religion in the conditions of the strict need for reforming Islam. The globalization processes of the modern world make Muslim countries accept the reformist movement, which is a precondition for the progressive development of society. Understanding the concept of tradition considered by the Iranian thinker Nasr as an existential entity that crosses the history of all humanity, explains some of the points in the Muslim worldview. Tradition in the Islamic world is not only a tribute to the religious component, but also a trait of self-identification. Researchers at the West-East Dialogue do not give a clear guide and answer for reforming Islamic society, but it is worth noting that multiculturalism and globalization of the 21 st century lead to gradual reforms and recognition of the Other to be included in the dialogue.
Dynamics of Islam in the Modern World. Essays in Honor of Jamal Malik
2022
Dynamics of Islam in the Modern World scrutinizes and analyzes Islam in context. It posits Muslims not as independent and autonomous, but as relational and interactive agents of change and continuity who interplay with Islamic(ate) sources of self and society as well as with resources from other traditions. Representing multiple disciplinary approaches, the contributors to this volume discuss a broad range of issues, such as secularization, colonialism, globalization, radicalism, human rights, migration, hermeneutics, mysticism, religious normativity and pluralism, while paying special attention to three geographical settings of South Asia, the Middle East and Euro-America.
Reform, Radicalism, and the Role of Islam in Modern Societies
Reform, Radicalism, and the Role of Islam in Modern Societies, 2012
These three books cover the common themes of the last century and a half of Muslim activism -reform, radicalism, and the role of Islam in modern societies. Each book covers a different phase in the history of Islamic revivals and their interactions with modernity. John Calvert's book is a study of Sayyid Qutb's work during the phase of the heightened Cold War ideological contestations in the postcolonial period, both in the Muslim lands as well as globally. Kai Hafez's book focuses largely on the last several decades when the study of democracy and democratization came to the forefront of the academic/policy scene in the West -but also among the Muslim activists. Finally, John Esposito's book spotlights the Muslim present and its possible futures. Combined, the books provide an overview of the important issues surrounding Muslim activism and possibilities for political and religious reform among the Muslims.
Observing Variants of POST-ISLAMISM: Intellectual Discourses and Social Movements (3rd edition)
Observing Variants of POST-ISLAMISM: Intellectual Discourses and Social Movements , 2019
In Muslim societies, the 1990s mark the beginning of a new wave of intellectual and social-political responses to issues of contemporary concern. Scholars of Islamic revivalism have already indicated these dispersed voices of reform. These reformist voices are supported by institutional arrangements and popular sentiments at some places; and at other places, these exist only in intellectual discourses and may be potent for “silent revolution.” Although, Pakistan is no exception to this general trend prevalent in the Muslim world. However, intellectual trajectories and their liberatory ideas are still far from becoming a popular social movement in this Sunni-Majority country. The argument threading through these scholarly studies conducted on contemporary Islam is that a new trend has emerged in Muslim societies of accommodating rights of women, youth and non-Muslim minorities, aspects of pluralism, democratization and civil society, and yearnings for socio-economic development. The surfacing new voices and changing trends within and without Islamic social forces are an outcome of multiple historical, ideological and institutional factors. Post-colonial Muslim states mostly ruled by secular elites, monarchs and military dictators and their capitalist and socialist theories of development have failed to satisfy the most essential needs of Muslim masses. Equally, conservative Islamist regimes in Sudan, Iran and Afghanistan have also contributed less to accommodate the growing dissent within their own ardent rank and file. The result is an endless process of fracturization that inculcated the seeds of new articulations in intellectual discourses. These discourses have taken up by a vibrant civil society and mass media. Whereas, the backdrop shaped by state’s repressive policies, neo-liberal economic agenda and modern lifestyle has also contributed to further radicalization of identities of splintering groups; the significance of growing voices and trends of moderation can hardly be overemphasized. A number of Middle Eastern societies, for instance, have been witnessing this trend since long. In Egypt, the emergence of Hizb-al- Wasat with a counter-worldview to militant and authoritarian shades of Muslim Brotherhood; in Iran, the coming of a “silent revolution” through secular-reformist and Islamic reformist discourses and pioneered by activist-intellectuals; in Turkey, the rise and proliferation of numerous societal forces in politics, civil society and Sufi brotherhoods; in India, the political and conceptual-ideological transformation of the Jamaat-e- Islami (JI); and in Pakistan, the emergence of a new thought-movement led by Ghamidi, as well as, the reformist voices within the traditionalist Deobandi madrassas. These waves of change and reform from within are not restricted to mainstream Islamist movements but are also visible in smaller trajectories of Islamic social forces. Several visible changes within the Deobandi social trajectory, for instance, are also symptomatic of this overall reformist trend. These are only few examples confirming the brewing in of a sea change that is visible more in intellectual articulations and civil society and less in states’ policies and institutions. The element of change in ideas, ideals, targets, strategies, and focus inside Islamic movements and without, is explained by an emergent framework of post-Islamism that will be explained shortly.
The encounter of the Muslim community with western modernity ushered in a new course of events involving multidimensional interactions and conflicts in economic, political, social and cultural areas. As a result of this eventful encounter, three different major reactions came about among Muslims towards modernity: the first one is modernism which aims at the western-type modernization and cracks a door to secularism. The second one was a movement which, harboring fundamentalist and reformist ideas, rejected modernity entirely and viewed the backwardness vis-à-vis the West in Muslims' inadequate understanding of Islam. The third one was the (neo-) traditionalist approach. This study offers an account of the encounter with a little background and also an analysis of all three responses that Muslims held towards modernity. It finally presents whether or not these approaches brings in anything new in terms of Muslim sectarianism. Öz Modernite ve İslam Toplumunun Buna Tepkisinde Farklılaşması: Modern, Islahçı ve Gelenekçi Tavırların Ortaya Konulması İslam toplumunun Batı Modernizmi ile karşılaşması ekonomik, politik, sosyal ve kültürel zeminlerde çok boyutlu bir etkileşim ve çatışma sürecini beraberinde getirdi. Bu karşılaşmada Müslümanlar arasından üç farklı tepki ortaya çıktı: İlki Batı tipi bir modernleşmeyi hedefleyen ve bu çerçevede sekülerleşmeye kapı açan yaklaşımdı. İkincisi, modernleşmeye toptan karşı çıkan ve Batı karşısındaki geri kalmışlığı İslam'ı yeterince yaşayamamakta gören köktenci ve ıslahçı yaklaşımdı. Üçüncüsü ise (yeni-) gelenekçi yaklaşımdı. Bu makalede İslam toplumunun Batı modernizmi ile karşılaşma süreci ve bunun arkaplanı ele alınmış, bu çerçevede İslam toplumunda oluşan üç farklı tutum tahlil edilmiştir. Bu çalışma, ayrıca, bahsedilen eğilimlerin İslam mezhepçiliği açısından yeni olarak ne ortaya koyduklarını tartışmaktadır. Anahtar Kelimeler: Modernite, Modern, Islahçı, Gelenekçi.