Some Notes on Kamalaśīla’s Understanding of Insight Considered as the Discernment of Reality (bhūta-pratyavekṣā) (original) (raw)
2008, Buddhist Studies Review
The present article aims to explain Kamala??la’s understanding of the nature of insight, specifically considering it as the ‘discernment of reality’ (bh?ta-pratyavek??) -- a technical term identified with insight (vipa?yan?) in the author’s well known Bh?van?krama? texts. I approach my analysis of bh?ta-pratyavek?? from three different angles. I begin by providing a rationale for its translation. This is followed by an account of Kamala??la’s reading of key passages in the La?k?vat?ra S?tra describing the process to which the term refers. Here the aim is to illustrate Kamala??la’s understanding of bh?ta-pratyavek?? as it is actually experienced in meditation. The final section examines bh?ta-pratyavek?? in relation to other important technical terminology employed in the course of making arguments against his historical rival in debate, the Ch’an monk Mo ho yen. By providing these three different perspectives on the same process it is my hope that both scholars and practitioners wil...
Sign up to get access to over 50M papers
Related papers
Meditation and Knowledge in Indian Buddhist Epistemology (2023)
In: Hiroko Matsuoka, Shinya Moriyama, and Tyler Neill (eds.), To the Heart of Truth: Felicitation Volume for Eli Franco on the Occasion of His Seventieth Birthday. Wien: Arbeitskreis für Tibetische und Buddhistische Studien Universität Wien, 2023, pp. 667-684, 2023
Philosophy of Vipassana Meditation: Appreciating the Rational Basis of the Insightful Meditation
2007
Sceptical modem scholarship has so far ignored the philosophical significance of ViJl"SsaniL Suspecting it as just another form of mystical religious practice, and therefore lacking any academic value, the academic world often consciously sleers dear of vipassanii.. In this paper however, I intend to make a bold claim that vipassanii has a solid philosophical and phenomenological foundation. So the aim of this paper is to demystifying!he viJl"SSani by showing the ways in wbich the principles of Yiprus8.lJi suppon my claim thai it hl!Ji " profound philosophical foundation. The paper is simply an in.illl1ioo to anyone, !he sceptics and the faithful alike, to consider the strengtbs and the weaknesses of the arguments presental here. The arguments in the paper unfold progressively, .. they are drawn upon the delineation and the discussion of some of the key concepts of the vipB1lSlll1ii. Beginning with Ibe epistemological argument of p8i1if. (insightful awareness), the paper defends ils claim, by way of exploring the phenomenological argument of vl'XillJlii (experience), the psychological argument of flI¢Ia (craving), the sOleriological argument of shaking off the ta!'hi (craving), Ihe epistemological argument of slHfIpajaiiiia (correctly and wholly understanding the reality), the methodological argument of satipal!hiina (foundations of mindfulness); and the paper concludes with some practical remarks on the significance of catching the moment as a way of applying vipassanii in daily tife.]
Asiatische Studien, 2023
The “middle wayˮ (madhyamā pratipad) is a concept of great significance in Buddhism. For Mahāyāna philosophers, the concept of the middle way free from the two extremes of superimposition (samāropa) and denial (apavāda) has ontological import. In the history of the development of Mahāyāna thought, we also see a tendency to work out a dimension of the middle way related to yogis’ spiritual cultivation and to combine it with the middle way’s ontological aspect. The eighth-century Mādhyamika thinker Kamalaśīla is one whose theory of the middle way has a close connection with his theory of spiritual cultivation. The purpose of this paper is to explore Kamalaśīla’s view on the relationship between (1) the middle way that lies between the two extremes of superimposition and denial, and (2) his theory of spiritual cultivation. I first clarify Kamalaśīla’s definition of the two extremes of superimposition and denial by examining his Madhyamakāloka and Madhyama-kālaṃkārapañjikā. Based on the knowledge thus gained, I then delve into the four-teenth chapter of the Avikalpapraveśadhāraṇīṭīkā, a text where Kamalaśīla clearly reveals his take on the relationship between yogi’s meditative examination and the middle way of the two extremes of superimposition and denial. My conclusion is that for Kamalaśīla, meditative examination from the perspective of Madhyamaka ontology is the means to abandon the two extremes of superimposition and denial. Moreover, the middle way itself consists in the attainment of non-conceptual gnosis (nirvikalpajñāna) and the awareness obtained subsequently to that (pṛṣṭhalabdhajñāna), both of which result from such meditative examination.
2020
As Buddhist literature makes abundantly clear, the Buddha's knowledge is an instance of yogic perception; it radically differs from the ordinary cognition of empirical objects and results from a special training that includes ascetic toil and meditative practices. This essay aims to explore the role of special cognitive processes-in particular the Buddha's vision of the Truths and cognitive processes relating to meditation practices-in the Buddhist epistemological tradition of South Asia. It argues that, given the Indian philosophical context, an epistemology with Buddhist presuppositions had to consider why and how meditation practices can make a difference as regards the results of cognition. Passages from Dharmakīrti's work will be examined that show how Dharmakīrti represents yogic perception and the function of meditation practices (especially visualization) in transforming habitual processes of conceptualization.
Buddhist Insight: A Phenomenological Study of Dependent Arising on the Path to Enlightenment
This study is an analysis of insight into dependent origination and how these two features are positioned on the path to Enlightenment. Through a phenomenological investigation into meditation experiences of Theravada Buddhist practitioners, this paper examines the mechanisms, applications and outcomes of insight. Using interviews with Buddhist meditators, key insights are highlighted which result in the fetter breaking experience for the practitioner. By mapping these insights onto an ontological and soteriological study of the Buddhist path, we can confirm certain aspects of the path as a living tradition which leads to awakening. I have found that there is a similar psychological transformation for most Buddhist meditators who follow the same path of practice. These transformations result in fewer attachments and therefore less suffering. The maps we have been provided with, by the Buddha, certainly do chart a field of consciousness beyond normal cognition. This study demonstrates how insight provides us with a key to exploring the deeper parts of consciousness, thus allowing insight into the nature of reality.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.