Best of the Best of the Best? How International are Top International Law Journals Really? (original) (raw)
Related papers
A Comparison of Asian Law Journals Published in Asian and Western Countries
Publications
The purpose of this study was to compare Asian law journals published in Asia with those published in Western countries to determine the characteristics of the journals in relation to the geographic region in which they are published. In this study, Western countries refer to the Anglo-Saxon English-speaking countries, such as the United States and the United Kingdom. Using the Scimago Journal and Country Rank (SJR), 12 Asian law journals published in Asia and 8 Asian law journals published in Western countries were analyzed for performance, authorship, and topical research areas. Human rights issues affecting Asian countries were more prevalent in journals published in Western countries. In terms of journal performance, Asian law journals published in Western countries had a higher h-index, SJR, and citation rate than those published in Asia. Journals published in Western countries are published by reputable commercial publishers or university presses, and journals published in Wes...
2020
Introduction of study: This study portrays the European Journal of International Law's published data from 2006-2019, indexed in the Scopus-Elsevier database. Methodology: The retrieved data tabulated in MS Office Excel Sheet. The author's role and collaboration, type of documents, and association of the first author with the country aimed to explore the issue and year wise frequency of publications. Results: Total 739 documents published and distributed in seven categories original articles 582; 78.7%, followed by 59; 8% review articles and 56; 7.5% editorials got the top slot in the publications. Single or solo authors wrote the documents produced by 841; 1.1% authors, majority 621; 84%; research papers. The affiliation of the first author belongs to forty-three countries. In this study, The United Kingdom on the top slot with 147; 19.8% publications, followed by United States 119; 16.1%, and Italy 118; 16%. Twelve articles published in random years got a maximum of 348 and a minimum of 100 citations. Conclusion: The European Journal of International Law regularly publishes a consistent approach and promotes international law writings. This journal's dynamic is the facilitation of translations from French, Spanish, Italian and German languages to the English language.
Legal Journals: In Pursuit of a More Scientific Approach
European Journal of Legal Education, 2005
In 1942, the American sociologist of science, Robert Merton, suggested as one of the norms of academic science that universities ought to be places of 'organised scepticism'. Academic law journals should contribute to this mission, since the quality of an academic discipline largely depends on the quality of its publication culture. Informed by the American experiences including the dominant law reviews, and by contrast an international medical journal, this article tries to obtain a better view of the publication culture involving legal scholarship and the possibilities of improving it. The American format of the law review is generally very distant from the form of publication used in most other disciplines and from legal publications in many other parts of the world. One of the major problems of the legal discipline is that non-Americans generally do not publish in American law reviews vice versa. As a consequence, a proper, worldwide academic exchange of ideas is hindered. With the exception of a few journals, the world remains divided. This inhibits progress in legal scholarship. If a 'world format' for a legal article is to be adopted, the European model seems more appropriate than the American one.
2020
Aim of the study: This study aimed to collect the figure of documents published in ten journals on the subject of Law indexed in the Scopus-Elsevier database and citations. Methods/Approaches: The study's data acquired from the Scopus-Elsevier database with enrolled International standard Serial Number (ISSN) as default in the searching menu, and downloaded comma-separated value (CSV) file for calculating the results. Results: This study reveals that 3967 documents were published in ten law journals from 2010-2019. Total 2793; 73% of documents got citations in this study-maximum 834; 83.4% of documents published in Harvard Law Review. And 153; 15.3% of documents published by Harvard Law Review and American Law and Economic Review as a minimum. Total 2495 citations from 1-10 times get on top position out of 28317 citations counted collectively. The 282; 91.5% documents of the Journal of Law and Economics cited out of 308 documents as maximum, and 442; 53% documents of Harvard Law Review as a minimum. External citations 1966; 68% are larger than from 927; Self-citations. Conclusion: The citing strength shows the value and worth of publications in the disciplines of Law and Litigation in this technological era. The viewing and referencing describe the sensitivity, awakens, and attention of law intellectuals towards justice.
Assessment of law journals in Croatia, Italy and Spain
2021
Legal science is quite distinctive compared to other disciplines, also social sciences disciplines (variety of publications, interlink between practice and research, multiple audiences, etc.). In addition, the fact that legal science has always shied away from bibliometrics-based evaluation practices make the field a specific case study. The case study presented in this chapter is located precisely in this context and within a heated discussion that sees the law domain and its communities at the centre of the debate. An overview of the practices, policies, and criteria applied in law journal assessment in three countries (Croatia, Italy, and Spain) is provided. The panorama is varied, but it is constantly changing. Most of the qualitative criteria for journal assessment are common to all three countries, but significant differences are in place when it comes to mandating these criteria in practice. According to the survey on law journals across countries, an adequate definition of t...
SCIENTOMETRIC STUDY OF WORLD LITERATURE IN THE FIELD OF LAWAND ALLIED AREAŜ
“PARIDNYA"-The MIBM Peer Reviewed Journal, 2023
This paper attempts to highlight quantitatively the research outputs of the law and related areas available in the "National Library and Information Services Infrastructure for Scholarly Content (N-LIST)" consortium. In this consortium, more than 15 database providers like Ebrary, South Asia Archive, JSTOR, and more give access to more than 17,388 scholarly publications like e-books, e-journals, conference proceedings, and theses in various languages. The largest number of scholarly materials, i.e., more than 16,427, are available in the English language, and that number is growing every day. The core goals of this paper are to identify the distribution of research output by major topics and to locate database providers for the research output of publications in law and related fields for the benefit of Indian law researchers.
A Very Short History of International Law Journals (1869–2018)
European Journal of International Law
The first part of this article presents an overview of the rise of the first international and comparative law journals in the late 19th century followed by an account of the three factors lying behind the relative fall of the comparative element in the title of some of the international law journals published in French, Russian, Spanish, German, Japanese, Italian and English from 1869 to the end of World War I. The second part surveys the consolidation of international law periodicals in the interwar period under the impact of the establishment of the League of Nations in both Latin America and Europe, including Nordic and Eastern Europe. The third part examines the expansion and main characteristics of international law journals during the Cold War and their geographical extension towards Asia, Oceania and, occasionally, the Middle East and Africa. The fourth part focuses on the main features of the global post-1989 period in the field of periodicals of international law, examining the impact on them of the expansion and sectoral specialization of international law, regionalization, globalization, interdisciplinarity and the transformative influence of new technologies respectively. The conclusion reflects on the first 150 years of international law journals and points to future developments.
2021
This study evaluated the publications published in journals indexed in the Scopus-Elsevier database on Contract Law as article title from 1960-2019. Methods: Data of published documents on contract law downloaded from Scopus-Elsevier database on comma-separated value (CSV) file to fill the study's purpose. To calculate the yearwise publications, estimate the document's format, assess the pattern of authorship, place of publication, and gauge the first author's affiliation with their country. Results: There is 1551 document written by 2017; 1.3 authors in nine publication formats. Articles, book chapters, and review articles 1237; 79.7% attract the researchers for due attention and publish these at 1366 places. Seventy-three countries participated in 1551 documents; the United States 305; 19.6%, United Kingdom 281; 18.1%, and Germany 174; 11.2% are on the top slots among the 73 countries.. Conclusion: This study reveals that the law of contract is an emerging subject in the discipline of law. Geo-political situations, international trade, and the country's own rules and customs played an essential role in making legal agreements or contracts between two parties.
Research trends on law subject during 2005 – 2019: A biblio-profile
2021
This study aims to evaluate the research productivity published in fifteen law journals. Data of the survey downloaded from the Scopus-Elsevier database, store, and tabulated in MS Excel to determine the frequency of printed documents, and figure out the number of articles, conference papers, editorials, erratum, letters, notes, review articles, and short surveys yearly. Total 8789 documents published in fifteen law journals from 2005-2019, the 6483; 74% of documents published in article format, followed by review 1372; 16%, and note 387; 4%. The Journal of Advanced Research in Law and Economics published 1240; 14.1%, documents as maximum, and minimum 235; 2.6% by American Law and Economics Review journals. The research productivity of 8789 documents shows that these fifteen law journals published 586 documents annually and 1.6 papers daily. This colossal contribution of law personals indicated the attachment, affiliation, and association with thinking ideas for society's betterment.