Prisoners' perceptions of the right to a decent life in Romanian prisons (original) (raw)
Related papers
Are human rights respected in Romanian prisons?
2016
The purpose of this Master thesis is to see if human rights are respected in Romanian prisons. In order to see this, the national, European and international legal frameworks are presented in order to show what rights the inmates have. Afterwards, the situation in prisons is presented through international reports and reports of NGOs. The second part is meant to analyze the social reintegration of ex-inmates after they leave the prisons. The thesis will look into human rights violations and improvements made in the past 10 years (2006-2016), and will resemble the reports made by the International Community/Groups of experts when monitoring an issue in a certain state. The thesis will resemble to a fact-finding mission in order to address the gaps and propose possible solutions to meet them. The study leads to the remarks that in some cases the detention conditions have improved, but in others, over time they have worsened. Also, the study is meant to draw attention over the importan...
CAUSES OF VIOLATING PRISONERSʼ RIGHT TO A DECENT LIFE. ROMANIA IN THE EUROPEAN CONTEXT 2
Social Sciences and Education Research Review, 2019
This paper presents a part of the results of a research project named "Prisoners' Rights. Romania in the European Context", conducted at the Institute of Sociology of the Romanian Academy, between November 2015 and September 2017. Given the novelty of our study for Romania, we have considered an exploratory data analysis as a feasible methodology, able to objectively highlight and model our findings. Based on the perception of the sociological inquiry respondents (N = 557), the main causes of the violation of their right to a decent life in penitentiary were identified to be overcrowding, disinterest on the part of the state and old infrastructure of penitentiaries. From a statistical point of view, the Pearson's chi square test indicated significant or highly significant associations between most of the causes of the breaching the prisoners' right to decent living.
Causes of Violating Prisoner’s Right to a Decent Life: Romania in the European Context
Social Crimonol, 2018
This paper presents a part of the results of a research project named “Prisoners’ Rights. Romania in the EuropeanContext”, conducted at the Institute of Sociology of the Romanian Academy, between November 2015 and September2017. Given the novelty of our study for Romania, we have considered an exploratory data analysis as a feasiblemethodology, able to objectively highlight and model our findings. Based on the perception of the sociological inquiryrespondents (N=557), the main causes of the violation of their right to a decent life in penitentiary were identified tobe overcrowding, disinterest on the part of the state and old infrastructure of penitentiaries. From a statistical point ofview, the Pearson’s chi square test indicated significant or highly significant associations between most of the causesof the breaching the prisoners’ right to decent living.
Romania had been struggling for many years with the issue of overcrowding of places of detention, which has attracted numerous convictions in front of the European Court of Human Rights since 2007 (Case of Bragadireanu v. Romania), reaching a semi-pilot decision in 2012 (the Case of Iacov Stanciu v. Romania). Although the Court has recently acknowledged some progress made by the Romanian authorities to improve the conditions of detention, it found that the measures were ineffective, the factual situation was not changed, the resulting aspect and the large number of repetitive complaints in court, in which the plaintiffs invoke the precariousness of the detention conditions in our country, which leads to violation of art.
2015
In this paper we aim to analyze the social reintegration of persons deprived of liberty in the Romanian detention system, from a judicial and sociological perspective. The first part of the article presents the essential aspects of social reintegration, ranging from definitions, to key factors, general principles, ground rules, international and European legislation. The second part of the article presents the evolution of the social reintegration system in Romania from 1874 onward, focusing on the current situation and analysing the actual situation and the legislative acts in force, as well as the present Romanian Strategy for the social reintegration of prisoners between 2015 and 2019. The final part of the article presents the results of a sociological survey, conducted in March 2015 at the Maximum Security Penitentiary in Craiova and which aimed to test the hypotheses outlined after the analysis of social documents.
Human Rights of Inmates in E.U. Member States: United in Diversity and Discipline
Bulletin of the Transilvania University of Braşov. Series VII: Social Sciences • Law
International politics nowadays unavoidably speak in terms of the expansion, defense, and institutionalization of human rights. This raises the issue of universalism in its cultural, philosophical, moral, and legal manifestations in light of the current human rights discussion. Moreover, the disciplinary power within the state is now the subject of a disciplinary mechanism in a broader context of international surveillance of human rights protection. The watcher has become watched and we can only ask ourselves: who holds the power within a state in today’s world?
Mental Health in Romanian Prisons
Mental illness in Romanian prisons constitutes a serious matter to be addressed. Almost 4,800 out of 34,000 offenders (13%) incarcerated in Romania during 2007 were diagnosed with mental health problems, which means that one out of seven offenders were mentally ill. Unfortunately, despite the alarming data, there are no permanent and professional programs for this category of beneficiaries. Additionally, the multidisciplinary team lacks in providing support. Even if in 2009 the number of incarcerated people decreased, the high number of mentally ill offenders and the absence of programs, developed for this category of people, remain a huge problem.
Incarceration and the restriction in the enjoyment of the rights of prisoners
2019
Human rights are universal standards that protect and safeguard all persons from severe mistreatments and abuses. The notion of human rights is grounded on the recognition that “all human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights” and everyone is therefore “entitled to all rights and freedoms” contained in the human rights law. All the rights and freedoms guaranteed by the law can however, be subjected to a restriction according to other laws of the land. The respect and protection for the human rights of a person depend upon his status, whether he is an adult or a child; a prisoner or freeman; male or female. It was argued that prisoners are entitled to all their personal rights as well as personal dignity that are not temporarily taken away by the law or necessarily inconsistent with the circumstances in which they have been placed. The question to ask is do the laws expressly stated the rights that are not forfeited as a result of incarceration? If the answer is in the...