The Grounds for Development of Corporate Liability Category in Civil Law (original) (raw)
Related papers
Negative Obligations in Civil Law: Problem Statement
The Journal of V. N. Karazin Kharkiv National University, Series "Law", 2019
The present article touches upon the issue of negative obligation interpretation in civil law. The provisions of foreign civil legislature concerning negative obligations are reviewed in detail. The article gives a detailed analysis of main issues in the scientific literature concerning the legal nature of negative obligations: impossibility of negative obligations delays, impossibility of partial performance, impossibility of negative obligation termination because of failure to perform, impossibility to enforce debt assignment . The opportunity of negative obligation counter-performance is also stressed. It is concluded that negative obligation counter-performance is considered to be possible in case such obligations are interrelated. The author comes to the conclusion that the existence of counter-negative obligations is possible that are also exposed to counter-performance provided they are interrelated. The peculiarities of such negative obligations as distribution agreements a...
2020
Among the main objectives of the Decree of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine № 650 of 07.17.2019 “On the Formation of a Working Group on the Recodification (updating) of Civil Legislation of Ukraine” is a comprehensive analysis of the existing civil legislation of Ukraine and the definition of areas of private legal relations that need to be brought into line with world trends in the development of private law. In this regard, it becomes necessary to study the issues related to the possibility of fixing in the civil legislation of Ukraine for relations related to entrepreneurial activity rules on pre-contractual liability (in order to prevent unfair conduct at the stage preceding the conclusion of the contract). The definition of the legal nature of pre-contractual liability has a great practical importance, since the question depended on the extent of damages, which would vary between tort and contract liability. The purpose of this study is to create theoretical provisions that ...
On the Issue of Corporate Systems’ Liabilities
Accounting. Analysis. Auditing, 2019
The current financial situation of both domestic and foreign organizations with a developed corporate network has aggravated the problem of building an effective system to manage payments within the group of organizations. It is also necessary to develop a methodology of accounting for and control of payments in corporate systems able to meet the requirements ofinternational practice. The article discusses some evidence confirming the need for ongoing payments and the emergence of liabilities in corporate systems. The authors prove that settlements with contractors are the link that transforms any systemof holding type into a single organism, which makes it possible to develop and build an effective management model for such corporate system, reduce tax risks and cut the costs of its maintenance. In their research the authors use the methods of comparison, grouping and analysis of results of activity of corporations on the issues of redistribution of financial resourceswithin the gr...
Contractual Liability – Legal Regimes in Comparative Law
TEME, 2018
The paper analyses contractual liability, or, more precisely, the obligation to compensate damage, due to (partial or complete) failure to perform, that is, due to nonconformity or delay in performance. Using the dogmatic and comparative method, the authors examine the starting points and features of the legal regime governing the circumstances and events that prevent the debtor from performing the contract, that is, that render performance impossible or exceedingly difficult. Comparing the solutions in various national legislations, the authors conclude that the comparative law does not provide a singular position on the circumstances that relieve the debtor from contractual liability. Taking the analysis a step further, the paper explores the reasons behind these differences in legal systems, where the authors find that these are the consequence of the concept of contractual liability applied in the given legal systems. Two main systems are identified: subjective contractual liability, which is based on the debtors' assumed fault, and objective liability, in which fault is not legally relevant. Having explored the legal frameworks of national legislations, the authors conclude that subjective contractual liability is prevalent in the countries of the European continental system, while objective liability is characteristic of the Anglo-Saxon systems, with certain deviances. From the standpoint of the debtor, opting for subjective contractual liability is more favourable, since the debtor knows, as soon as the contract is breached, that no damages are owned to the creditor if the breach was caused by circumstances the debtor could not have prevented. Conversely, the objective liability system is more beneficial for the creditor, since the debtor's fault, in principle, does not affect the creditor's right to claim damages.
Nature and Forms of Realization of Legal Liability
Administrative and Criminal Justice
The article focuses on the research of one of the fundamental institutions of law – legal liability, the role and importance of which in the current period of formation of the rule of law in Latvia is constantly increasing. However, many issues of legal liability are still under discussion. In recent years the problem of liability mainly out of legal problem, turned into a problem of interdisciplinary nature. The generic notion, in relation to legal liability, is social responsibility. The evolution of views on the nature of legal liability has resulted in the emergence of the concept of positive legal liability. The initial methodological premise of the research of legal liability is to address to the issue of social responsibility, since the general characteristics and forms of realization inherent in social responsibility, inevitably find their expression both: in legal responsibility and its individual types. Traditionally, legal liability is limited by its interpretation as lia...
Theoretical understanding of the system of legal forms of protection of corporate relations
2018
The work presents legal constructs that determine the possibility of forming brand new understandings of the prospects for the development of corporate relations. The author has proved that there are two opposing views about the nature of construction of the right to protection today. According to the first view, the right to protection is an integral part of subjective civil law. The theoretical position of other scholars is that the right to protection is independent in relation to subjective civil law. It is argued that such a right can be implemented within the framework of a guarding legal relationship; therefore, the right to defense is manifested solely outside the development of a regulatory legal relationship. Assigning the right to protection to the component of subjective civil law reduces the scope of the realization of such right within the boundaries of the implementation of the relevant subjective civil law, which is its element. Legal opportunities, which are guarant...
Legist Type of Legal Understanding in Civil Law
Vestnik Omskoj Ûridičeskoj Akademii, 2018
Аннотация. В статье проведен анализ действующей юридической доктрины, гражданского законодательства и правоприменительной практики Российской Федерации сквозь призму основных принципов легистского типа правопонимания. Авторы, руководствуясь правовыми позициями высших органов правосудия Российской Федерации и Европейского Суда по правам человека по гражданским делам, обосновывают выводы о необходимости пересмотра научных представлений о сущности отечественного права и доминирования одного лишь типа правопонимания в России-легистского.