The Threat of Insurance On the Robustness of Principal-Agent Models (original) (raw)
Related papers
On multiple-principal multiple-agent models of moral hazard
2007
In multiple-principal multiple-agent models of moral hazard, we provide sufficient conditions for the outcomes of pure-strategy equilibria in direct mechanisms to be preserved when principals can offer indirect communication schemes. The conditions include strong robustness in the direct mechanism game, as developed in the literature on competing mechanisms by Peters and , and a no-correlation property we define. We provide a rationale for restricting attention to take-it or leave-it offers, as is typically done in applications. We show via examples that it is necessary to allow direct mechanisms to be stochastic and to include private recommendations from principals to agents to preserve the corresponding equilibrium outcomes, and that the no-correlation condition is tight.
2015
We solve a long-term contracting problem with symmetric uncertainty about the agent’s quality and a hidden action of the agent. As information about quality ac-cumulates, incentives become easier to provide because the agent has less room to manipulate the principal’s beliefs. This result is opposite to that in the literature on “career concerns ” in which incentives via short-term contracts become harder to provide as the agent’s quality is revealed over time.
Optimal incentive contracts when agents can save, borrow, and default
Journal of Financial Intermediation, 1999
The standard Principal-Agent (PA) model assumes that the principal can control the agent's consumption profile. In an intertemporal setting, however, Rogerson (1985, Econometrica 53, 69-76) shows that given the optimal PA contract, the agent has an unmet precautionary demand for savings. Thus the standard PA model is invalid if the agent has access to credit markets. In this paper we generalize the standard PA model to allow for saving and borrowing by the agent. We show that the impact of such access critically depends upon the treatment of default. If default is not permitted, efficiency is strictly reduced by the introduction of credit markets, and the equilibrium level of borrowing or saving is indeterminate in the model. If default is allowed, however, the optimal contract depends upon the level of bankruptcy protection in the economy, which is described by a minimum level of wage income. We show that there is an optimal intermediate range of bankruptcy protection. Within this range, allowing default increases efficiency in the economy relative to the case of no default. Also, the model predicts specific levels of consumer debt, interest rates, and default rates as functions of the level of bankruptcy protection level.
Optimal Contracts with Privately Informed Agents and Active Principals
SSRN Electronic Journal, 2000
This paper considers an optimal contracting problem between an informed risk-averse agent and a principal, when the agent needs to perform multiple tasks, and the principal is active, i.e. she can influence some aspect of the agency relationship. It discusses the optimality of action restrictions in the equilibrium menus of linear contracts showing that private information considerations add new trade-offs to the optimal contracts in the multitask setting. The paper also has novel implications for the capital budgeting literature that studies informational problems. In particular the nature of the private information, e.g.
Comparative statics in principal-agent problems
2008
Principal-agent problems are widespread in economics. Since it is usually believed little can be said in general settings (Mirrlees (1975), Grossman and Hart (1983)) applied work typically uses the …rst-order approach, justi…ed by strong assumptions on the distribution of shocks, or restricts attention to linear contracts, justi…ed by the assumptions under which Holmström and Milgrom (1987) have shown that this is the optimal contract. In this paper we dispense with these assumptions and develop a general approach to principal-agent problems. We do so by applying results from the theory of monotone comparative statics to the Grossman-Hart approach. We o¤er general results on the intensity of incentives, the shape of the optimal contract, and the value and use of information. The paper thus: (i) provides a technique for analyzing moral hazard problems and (ii) highlights which assumptions of the linear contracts or …rst-order approach are critical for drawing various conclusions. We show that the linear contracts model of Holmström and Milgrom (1987) is surprisingly robust and that all but one of its comparative statics hold under general assumptions in a static setting. Classic results on the value of information due to Holmström (1979) are also generalized. (JEL L13, L22).
Dynamic Contracts with Moral Hazard and Adverse Selection
The Review of Economic Studies, 2012
We study a novel dynamic principal-agent setting with moral hazard and adverse selection (persistent as well as repeated). In the model an agent whose skills are his private information faces a finite sequence of tasks, one after the other. Upon arrival of each task the agent learns its level of difficulty and then chooses whether to accept or refuse each task in turn, and how much effort to exert. Although his decision to accept or refuse a task is publicly known, the agent's effort level is his private information.
The Principal-Agent Model with a Continuum of Constraints: The Infinite-Dimensional Approach
1998
This paper is a survey about the existence of optimal contract mechanisms in the principal- agent problems with moral hazard and adverse selection under a continuum of individual rationality and incentive compatibility constraints. It presents the main existing results under a unified notation, shows explicitly in what sense they are particular cases of the general model presented in Balder (JET, 68 (1996): 133-148), and provides a simple method (the model machine) to construct new models within the infinite dimensional approach.
Existence of Optimal Mechanisms in Principal-Agent Problems
2011
Abstract: We provide general conditions under which principal-agent problems admit mechanisms that are optimal for the principal. Our result covers as special cases those in which the agent has no private information-ie, pure moral hazard-as well as those in which the agent's only action is a participation decision-ie, pure adverse selection. We allow multi-dimensional actions and signals, as well as both financial and non-financial rewards.
The Irrelevance of Control Rights in Agency Models under Risk Neutrality
Managerial and Decision Economics, 2013
The allocation of control rights is a key issue in incomplete contracts. In this paper, we add an exit option, the right of early termination, to the standard agency model for employment contracts. We address two questions: (1) Who should have this right? (2) What is the effect of its inclusion in a contract? Under risk neutrality, we find that (1) it does not matter for investments and economic efficiency to whom this right belongs, although it may affect contractual terms and income sharing, and (2) although the allocation of this right does not matter, its inclusion can have either a positive or a negative effect on economic efficiency. Our analysis provides a benchmark for more general analyses on control rights under risk aversion. plicity, we do not explicitly model the outside agent's optimal decision.