A critical study on the pre trial process in the juvenile justice system in Malaysia under the Child Act 2001 / Nadzriah Ahmad and Habibah Kiprawi (original) (raw)
Related papers
Protection of Child Offenders at the Pre-Trial Process in Malaysia: Are We Doing Enough?
Environment-Behaviour Proceedings Journal, 2020
The adverse effects of the pre-trial process on child offenders are damaging, particularly on their mental, emotional and physical developments. This study adopted the qualitative design, and the results indicate that the majority of the child offenders affirmed that they were subjected to some forms of ill-treatment during the pre-trial process, particularly during the investigation stage, where they are subjected to questioning. Thus, the results can facilitate the policymakers in strengthening and developing the current laws and policies and to introduce diversion programmes as an alternative to the juvenile justice system in Malaysia. Keywords: pre-trial process; questioning, juveniles; ill-treatment. eISSN: 2398-4287© 2020. The Authors. Published for AMER ABRA cE-Bsby e-International Publishing House, Ltd., UK. This is an open access article under the CC BYNC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). Peer–review under responsibility of AMER (Association of...
Legal Issues in Sentencing Child Offenders in Malaysia
2020
Malaysia as one of the countries that had signed the Convention of the Rights of the Child (CRC), has now reformed their Juvenile Criminal Justice System by introducing the Child Act 2011 (Act 611). The reformation includes the provision that allocates the orders for juvenile offenders to be issued by Magistrates from the Court for Children. This article aims to discuss the legal problems arising from punishing child offenders in Malaysia. The discussion will focus on the theoretical aspects of the underlying adjudication of each order in Act 611. This preliminary study found that the reform legislation through the Act 611 has not able to protect the best interests of children, particularly among those that conflict with the law. Order based on the theory of rehabilitation should be prioritized by the legislative and judiciary so the children could be given a second chance.
The Rehabilitation Theory in Adjudicating Child Offenders and Its Application in Malaysia
Asian Social Science, 2013
Children who find themselves on the wrong side of the law must bear the legal consequences to ensure that they obey societal norms. The question is: what theory forms the legal basis for legal action against these troubled young offenders? Will the courts apply the deterrence theory by sentencing them to harsher punishments, or will they apply the rehabilitation theory by passing lighter orders? The objective of this article is to debate one of the theories applied by the Court for Children in their adjudicating process-the rehabilitation theory, and its application. This article will also discuss two legal provisions in the Child Act 2001 Malaysia (Act 611) which are based on the rehabilitation theory. This study finds that the rehabilitation theory is the best and most suitable theory to be applied to child offenders because it focuses on individual rehabilitation by taking into consideration the aspects of education, societal integration and rehabilitating them of their criminal mentality. The two aforementioned provisions, namely, on ‘approved school’ and ‘community services’, are orders founded on the rehabilitation theory and can potentially prevent child offenders from involving themselves in criminal activities in the future. The importance of this study is paramount as it shows that Malaysia is clearly behind in assimilating rehabilitative values and theory into Act 611. Ultimately, the placement of specific legislative provisions regarding community service within Act 611 is an initiative that must be expedited.
Comparing Reforms of Juvenile Justice in Bangladesh and Malaysia
Substantive Justice International Journal of Law
The article attempts to critically compare juvenile justice reforms in both jurisdictions of Bangladesh and Malaysia. It explores legal reforms in line with the international standards to ensure the effective juvenile justice system as well as child well-being in the respective legal systems. The juvenile justice practice of Bangladesh and Malaysia are a testament that diverse juvenile laws, norms and systems exist. After ratification of UNCRC, significant progress has been achieved in both countries. Malaysia adopted mechanisms for rehabilitation in terms of job-based education and alternatives measures by the Child Act 2001. Child-oriented justice and alternative measures have started with the commencement of Children Act 2013 in Bangladesh. For both countries, there is a need for establishing a child-friendly justice system, which would ensure sustainable juvenile justice.
Evaluation of the Child Criminal Justice System in the Perspective of Children with the Law
The juvenile criminal justice system is an important part of maintaining justice and protecting children's rights in criminal cases. Through literature study techniques, this paper aims to evaluate the juvenile justice system in Indonesia from the perspective of children in conflict with the law. The results of the study show that there are still some deficiencies in the juvenile justice system, such as the low quality of legal services and the minimal participation of children in the judicial process. Some efforts that can be made to improve the juvenile justice system include improving the quality of legal services, providing greater opportunities for children to be involved in the judicial process, and increasing alternative dispute resolution outside of juvenile justice. It is hoped that the results of this research can make a positive contribution to improving the juvenile justice system in the future.
Protecting the Rights of Children in the Indonesian Juvenile Justice System
Journal of Law, Policy and Globalization, 2019
Delinquency rate of children every year always increases, if we look closely at the development of criminal acts committed by children so far, both in terms of quality and modus operandi. The research is an empirical legal research or commonly called as socio-legal research. It was conducted at Mamuju district, West Sulawesi, Indonesia. The results show that the implementation of the children rights' protection in the process of juvenile criminal justice has been going well, although there are still rights of the children that have not been fully fulfilled. Such as the right to be free from torture, punishment or other cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment, not being arrested, detained or imprisoned. The process of juvenile criminal justice is not fully running smoothly, because in practice several obstacles are encountered. These obstacles include: the lack of understanding from law enforcement officials regarding child protection, limited number of juvenile judges or judges specializing in child criminal cases, many courts still do not have a special courtroom for juvenile court trial, the lack of defendant's knowledge of the rights owned, there is no place to child custody or a Penitentiary for Children, so that child custody must be joined with adult in the sense that child custody with adult prisoners is not separated so that it can adversely affect child custody.
2012
This thesis examines the extent to which, and the reasons why, the government of Malaysia provides educational opportunities for children and young people who are being detained in the closed (penal) institutions on orders under section 91 (1) (f) and section 97 of the Child Act, 2001. This thesis presents a detailed analysis of the driving factor(s) that motivate the government of Malaysia in formulating and implementing policy and law in regards to providing educational opportunities for such young people. The thesis, therefore, examines the conceptualization by the Malaysia Prisons Department of children"s rights, particularly their rights to education and offender rehabilitation. Analysis reveals that, educational rights in Malaysia have such priority because education is seen generally as the way to socialize (all) young people and to improve human capital and economic potential in Malaysia. Consequently, rehabilitation in Malaysian penal institutions is conceptualized almost entirely as education. The thesis argues that the Malaysian government has been using children"s rights to education and also offender rehabilitation to improve the process of socialization of young people in prisons institutions to enable them to contribute to the achievement of the national goals.
2019
The criminal law system of Indonesia formed a special court system for children criminals. This system is determined by considering that juvenile has distinguishing factors than adult that drive them to conduct criminality. Those can be analyzed based on psychological and sociological factors. The main purpose is to secure access for justice towards children criminality. However, provisions in Juvenile Court System law still have weaknesses that will endanger the access of justice. Therefore, in the enforcement aspects, that inclusivity is often being abandoned. This research is interdisciplinary by using normative-empirical method and qualitative method. Normative-empirical is analyzing on legal instrument using statute approach and also using primary data taken from interview. Qualitative method is a method that holistically describes a phenomenon by analyzing the quality of relations, situations, and other materials. This research analyzed on the inclusivity of juvenile delinquen...