Enhancing Efficiency at Nonprofits with Analysis and Disclosure (original) (raw)

Abstract

The U.S. nonprofit sector spends $2.54 trillion each year. If the sector were a country, it would have the eighth largest economy in the world, ahead of Brazil, Italy, Canada, and Russia. The government provides nonprofits with billions in tax subsidies, but instead of evaluating the quality of their work, it leaves this responsibility to nonprofit managers, boards, and donors. The best nonprofits are laboratories of innovation, but unfortunately some are stagnant backwaters, which waste money on out-of-date missions and inefficient programs. To promote more innovation and less stagnation, this Article makes two contributions to the literature. First, this Article breaks new ground in identifying sources of inefficiency at nonprofits. The literature focuses on incentives, arguing that managers and board members are less motivated to run a nonprofit efficiently because they cannot keep its profits. In response, this Article emphasizes that the problem is not just motivation, but also...

Loading...

Loading Preview

Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.

References (24)

  1. or corporate money." Suzanne Coffman, Just What Are Public Charities and Private Foundations, Anyway?, Sept. 1, 2001, https://trust.guidestar.org/just-what-are-public-charities-and-private-foundations-anyway [https://perma.cc/E27U-P96W\].
  2. 7 Henry Hansmann, The Role of Nonprofit Enterprise, 89 Yale L. J. 835,844 (1980) ("Of course, one would expect that when the profit motive is eliminated a price is paid in terms of incentives.") [hereinafter "Nonprofit Enterprise"];
  3. Burton A. Weisbrod, The Nonprofit Economy 23 (1988) ("Nonprofit managers may also have less incentive to be efficient, since efficiency cannot lawfully be rewarded.") [hereinafter "Nonprofit Economy"];
  4. Dennis R. Young, If Not For Profit, For What? 130 (1983) ("A commonly held view is that nonprofits maintain quality but produce services in a relatively wasteful fashion"); id. at 129 (attributing this "sluggishness" to lack of profit motive and capital constraints).
  5. See Swords, supra note 109, at 573 ("Good reporters --hard-news, hard-news reporters --love nothing more than exposing such abuses.").
  6. See Prakash & Gugerty, supra note 11, at 34-35 (advocating "accountability clubs" as signals of quality and offering examples of club standards on board composition, HR management, fundraising practices, and transparency).
  7. Hansmann, Economic Theories, supra note 16, at 31-32. At first blush, the influence of donors as a group might seem limited, since donations on average are less than a third of U.S. nonprofits' revenue. See Brody, Agents Without Principals, supra note 16, at 470 ("few nonprofits actually rely on donors for the bulk of their support.") Yet some (e.g., social services organizations) rely much more on donations than others (e.g., hospitals). Even when donations fund only a fraction of the budget, managers still don't want to lose them, or they will have to make painful cuts in services and employee headcounts.
  8. Schizer, Comparing the Deduction With the Exemption, supra note 4, at 665.
  9. See Timothy Doyle, The Conflicted Role of Proxy Advisors, Harv. Law School Forum on Corporate Governance Blog, (May 22, 2018), https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2018/05/22/the-conflicted-role-of-proxy-advisors/ [https://perma.cc/UQ33-PUPW\] ("proxy advisory firms are incentivized to align with the comments of those who pay them the most and to move targets and change policy to create a better market for their company-side consulting services")
  10. Specifically, Charity Navigator awards between one and three stars based on two factors. First, "financial health" reflects access to working capital, growth in the program budget, and spending on administration and fundraising.
  11. Second, "accountability and transparency" evaluates governance practices, such as whether the charity has an independent board and audited financials. See Charity Navigator, Charity Navigator's Methodology, https://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm?bay=content.view&cpid=5593&from=short-url#rating [https://perma.cc/97Z6-TVXJ\].
  12. "Global giving performs rigorous due diligence . . . to ensure they are performing charitable work in a transparent and accountable manner, and that they meet local requirements for registration with their local government. . . .
  13. O]ur nonprofit partners have the opportunity to share extra information about the effectiveness of their work. Organizations can share information about how they listen to their stakeholders, test out new ideas, and improve their programs and services based on what they learn from data and feedback.")
  14. Diana Stork & Jill Woodilla, Nonprofit Organizations: An introduction to Charity Rating Sources and Cautions in Their Use, 6 Int'l J. Applied Man. & Tech. 5 (2008) (rating agencies rely predominantly on financial ratios).
  15. Gugerty & Kalman, supra note 8 at 68.
  16. See https://finance.yahoo.com/news/heres-every-states-average-social-132355610.html [https://perma.cc/BV5F- MK3W] (average social security benefit in U.S. is 1,503permonthorabout1,503 per month or about 1,503permonthorabout50 per day); https://www.cleiss.fr/docs/regimes/regime\_france/an\_3.html [https://perma.cc/YVY8-YNUJ\]. (French solidarity allowance for elderly brings monthly income €868.20 or approximately 32perday,assuminganexchangerateof1.085dollarsperEuro);https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/progdesc/ssptw/2018−2019/europe/ukraine.html(minimumpensioninUkraineforthoseaged65orolderis4032 per day, assuming an exchange rate of 1.085 dollars per Euro); https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/progdesc/ssptw/2018-2019/europe/ukraine.html (minimum pension in Ukraine for those aged 65 or older is 40% of 3,723 hryvnias (the monthly minimum wage) or 1,489 hryvnias; at an exchange rate of .037 dollars per hryvnia, this is 32perday,assuminganexchangerateof1.085dollarsperEuro);https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/progdesc/ssptw/2018−2019/europe/ukraine.html(minimumpensioninUkraineforthoseaged65orolderis4055.10 per month). 132 https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/ethiopia/overview [https://perma.cc/85X8-XXHF\].
  17. 141 See generally Douglas C. Bennett, Assessing Quality in Higher Education, 87 Liberal Education (2001), https://www.aacu.org/publications-research/periodicals/assessing-quality-higher-education [https://perma.cc/JD8K- 3PGK] (describing various approaches to measuring quality in higher education); see also James P. Connell & Adena M. Klem, A Theory of Change Approach to Evaluating Investments in Public Education, in Measuring Impact, supra note 8, at 173 (impact measures for public education sector).
  18. See Daniel P. Forbes, Measuring the Unmeasurable: Empirical Studies of Nonprofit Organization Effectiveness From 1977 to 1997, 27 Nonprofit & Voluntary Sector Quarterly 183, 186 (1998) (describing "perception-based or reputational approach" to measuring organizational effectiveness of nonprofits).
  19. See, e.g., Kellie C. Liket & Karen Maas, Nonprofit Organizational Effectiveness: Analysis of Best Practices, 44 Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Q. 268 (2015) (evaluating nonprofits based on survey measuring utilization of best practices);
  20. Forbes, supra note 142, at 190 (noting studies that seek correlation between specific processes and effective outcomes).
  21. See, e.g., Benjamin Wermund, How U.S. News College Rankings Promote Economic Inequality on Campus, Politico, Sept. 10, 2017 ("criteria used in the U.S. News rankings . . . create incentives for schools to favor wealthier students over less wealthy applicants").
  22. $500,000 for corporations making false statements under penalty of perjury);
  23. I.R.C. § 7207 (providing for a fine up to $50,000 for corporations filing false returns).
  24. Briana Cummings, Note, Benefit Corporations: How to Enforce a Mandate to Promote the Public Interest, 112 COLUM. L. REV. 578, 580 (2012). Benefit corporations are available in 36 states. B LAB, State by State Status of Legislation, https://benefitcorp.net/policymakers/state-by-state-status. [https://perma.cc/R8KW-LK94\] They are required to issue benefit reports. B LAB, Benefit Corporation Reporting Requirements, https://benefitcorp.net/businesses/benefit-corporation-reporting-requirements [https://perma.cc/7ELD-H6EZ\].