Under mother's eyes: Black gaze, state violence, and resilience in Rio de Janeiro (original) (raw)
In 2009, French street artist JR appeared in the oldest favela in Rio de Janeiro and started taking photographs of women who were collectively mourning the recent slaughter of three teenagers. In a communal effort, these black-and-white portraits were reproduced at an enormous scale and pasted onto the favela's facade. Up close, the images were so big that they seemed to have no particular form. But from a distance, the faces assembled, revealing women's eyes gazing steadily at the city beneath the favela. In this article, I explore how the installation can be understood as a commentary on gendered and racial state violence against Black motherhood. I turn to the images as ethnographic subjects to theorize ways Black femininity is constructed, experienced and understood in Rio. The central question I pose in this article is about the power and potential of the motherly gaze to replace the violent male stare—the one that misrepresents and disempowers those most vulnerable to distortion's ill effects. I make the case that the (bri)collage is a call to further examine the relationship of poor Black mothers with the state, how they combat negative public representation ascribed to Black youth, and how they negotiate the safety of their families.
Sign up for access to the world's latest research.
checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Related papers
Black Mothers' Experiences of Violence in Rio de Janeiro
This exploratory essay approaches gendered aspects of anti-black violence through the experiences of black mothers whose children were the victims of homicide in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Commonly understood to primarily affect black men, urban violence in Brazil has less-visible effects on black women. Their struggles to survive encompass not only their own fights against poverty, discrimination, and race and gender discrimination, but it also entails the consequences of violent acts perpetrated or facilitated by the state upon black men in their families. However, these experiences are either invisibilized or not taken into consideration in traditional analyses of violence. How can black women's experiences deepen the analysis of anti-black violence and enrich African diaspora studies? Do the violent deaths of their relatives contribute to black women's radicalization and activism? What are the main components of their political struggles? This essay addresses these issues in the framework of African diaspora scholarship and black feminist theory.
From the Backstage of War: the Struggle of Mothers in the Favelas of Rio de Janeiro
This article analyses the political status of mothers whose children have been killed by members of the Brazilian military police and armed forces in the favelas of Rio de Janeiro in the course of the 'war against drugs'. These mothers bear witness to the reality of state interference in the lives of their families. The loss of a child interrupts their intimate affective bonds and temporal linkages between the past, present and future, thereby requiring a resignification of the meaning and temporality of their lives. The war waged by the state and the mothers' struggle for justice gives rise to a social dynamic that positions these mothers in a reordering of space and a redefinition of time, creating a spatio-temporal existence of pain, despair and hope.
Favela Women: Repression and Resistance in the Shantytowns of Rio de Janeiro
Anyone even vaguely acquainted with the favelas (squatter settlements, shantytowns) of Brazil will understand that in this grossly male-chauvinist and racist society it is Afro-Brazilian women who represent the plight and promise of the urban poor. Whether speaking of Carolina Mária de Jesus and her diary of survival in São Paulo during the 1960s or Benedita da Silva, a former favelada (female squatter) who rose to represent a destitute constituency of Rio de Janeiro in the federal legislature, the public image of the favela conflates poverty, race and femaleness. 1 This is not by itself a remarkable or even uniquely Brazilian phenomenon. In many nations with large black populations, including the United States, state agencies have produced a whole body of literature that ascribes to poor urban women the malignant persistence of poverty. 2 The notion that the urban poor bear both a moral and medical stigma that makes them responsible for their own predicament is nothing new in Brazilian history.
"Look, Blackness in Brazil: disrupting the grotesquerie of Racial representation..."
This article experiments with collage to explore the visual representation of blacks and blackness in Brazilian media, popular culture and politics, examining how these representations constitute statements regarding dynamics of racial domination. The work proposes that the introduction of disruptive elements into the very images that objectify the black body could create the necessary conditions for a valuable criticism of how blacks and blackness are disposed within the nation's formation. The articulation with black studies in visual culture and performance, black feminism, African diaspora and post-colonial theories intends to develop analytical frames to examine the interconnection between the representational process of 'stereotyping', symbolic violence and anti-black ideologies in the context of the national formation narratives. Methodologically, the articulation of these fields of inquiry intends to provide tools able to highlight and disrupt the regimes of racial representation circulating in Brazilian popular culture.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.