Commercial Trade, the Arabic Qur'ān, and Imperial Apocalypse: How Quranic Geography Was Formed Against Christian Empire (original) (raw)
Related papers
Qur'ānic Exegesis and the Reshaping of Early Islamic History: A Case Study of Sura Q 107
2024
This study examines the historiography of early Islam by assessing the reliability of Qurʾānic exegeses as sources documenting the early history of Islam and the biography of the Prophet Muḥammad in Mecca. Focusing on Qurʾānic exegetical practices from late antiquity to the medieval period, this article argues that there is a significant discontinuity in how Qurʾānic exegeses align with the historical context of the Qur’an, especially in relation to Meccan sūras such as Q 107. Significantly, this challenges the continuity of tradition, the fundamental concept upon which the “Islamic sciences” are based. This discontinuity is herein revealed through a historical–critical analysis of the exegesis of Q 107:4 that demonstrates how Qurʾānic exegetical practices have reinterpreted and reshaped early Islamic history in response to the pressures of new identity formation and made Qurʾānic exegeses more reflective of the social and political contexts of the exegetes than of the historical milieu of the Qurʾān itself. This analysis contributes to the ongoing discussion of the role exegesis played in reshaping the history of Islam. Indeed, it emphasises the importance of critically evaluating these sources in order to uncover a more nuanced historical narrative of early Islam.
The Composition and Writing of the Qur'an: Old Explanations and New Evidence
Journal of College of Sharia and Islamic Studies, 2020
This article challenges the view, common among Western academics since early last century, that the Qurʾān was left incomplete as a book and did not take final shape until well after the Prophet's death. Against this, it highlights an example of structural continuity: that of center-periphery connection between adjacent sūras. This type of connection is identified throughout the phases of revelation, from the early Meccan period to the late Medinan one. The structural consistency illuminated here indicates that one author or authority likely arranged the Qurʾān, a finding in accordance with recent stylometric analysis of the text carried out at Princeton University. It also accords with an examination of the theme of jihād in the Qurʾān, the conclusions of which were presented at the 2017 International Qur'anic Studies Association conference in Boston. Far from suggesting a multiplicity of voices, the doctrine of jihād is characterized by overall consistency and adherence to core principles, pointing to a likely single origin. Next, before the conclusion of the article, an updated hypothesis for the early writing and transmission of the Qurʾān is presented, taking into account the existence of minor variations in the old codices, the reports about an ʿUthmānic commission issuing a standard text, and the fact that no prototype manuscript has been discovered.
Arabic 5701 Term Paper: The Qur'an under Christian Inspection
A review and investigation of 8 th century Christian polemics against the Qur'an In the early history of Islam many conversations, disputes, and debates revolved around the heart of the faith: the Qur'an. While many of these contestations had a wide variety of themes, topics, and audiences an interesting discourse over the history of the Qur'an and its genesis were held between Christians and Muslims. The major topic pertaining for both of these groups was the authenticity of the Scriptures and their preservation with each side arguing for their prescribed beliefs but early Islamic history gives us a vital insight to what the Christians during the initial Caliphate empires of the Umayyad and Abbasid periods believed about the compilation and transmission of the Qur'an.
The Written Torah and the Oral Qurʾan in Pagan Mecca
Non Sola Scriptura: Essays on the Qur'an and Islam in Honor of William A. Graham, 2022
This paper offers a detailed examination of Q 6:91, a puzzling verse that seems addressed partly to the Jews and partly to the pagans. A close textual analysis of this text and the surah as a whole suggests that Q 6:91 speaks to the pagans alone, and that a variant reading of this verse which has all the imperfect verbs in the third person (yajʿalūnahu, yubdūnahā, yukhfūna) is preferable to its currently dominant reading (featuring tajʿalūnahu, tubdūnahā, tukhfūna). The verse also seems to provide an implicit defense of the piecemeal and oral nature of Quranic revelations as well as a simultaneous critique of the Torah’s mode of preservation, a topic that the paper probes at some length. Finally, the study surveys Muslim exegesis of Q 6:91 and shows that discussions of this verse in modern academic scholarship would have benefited greatly from substantive engagement with works of tafsīr and qirāʾāt. The paper ends by calling for such engagement in all studies of the Quranic text.
JOURNAL OF QUR'ANIC STUDIES, vol. 25, pp. 93-119, 2021
Comment le Qur’ān est-il nommé, défini, figuré? Comment le Qur’ān est-il jugé, évalué? Comment le Qur’ān est-il lu et compris? Comment le Qur’ān est-il utilisé, transformé, exploité? Ces questions, au centre du débat des journées d’étude, ont été appliquées à la réception de l’Alcoranus dans les commentaires à la Comédie. La question des sources arabes de la Comédie, depuis la publication des thèses de Asín Palacios, a donné lieu à une polémique considérable entre partisans et decrateurs de la dépendance de Dante aux traditions musulmanes. Les chercheurs ont toutefois compris qu’il faut repenser les terms du débat et évaluer le rôle joué par les intermediares latins ou romans. On a donc insisté sur la reconstruction des canaux de transmission possibles de la culture arabe, à la fois dans le christianisme et dans l’Alighieri, ou sur l’évaluation de l’image de la religion musulmane et de son fondateur, Mahomet, répandue au Moyen Âge. En revanche, la réception du texte de l’Alcoranus est restée insuffisamment étudiée, confinée dans le cadre, qui est d’ailleurs philologiquement sûr, de la citation indirecte. La communication s'est concentrée donc sur l’image du livre sacré de l’Islam rendue par les anciens commentaires à la Comédie. Le texte de l’Alcoranus apparaît le résultat d’un filtrage idéologique et culturel réitéré qui devient une opportunité pour rappeler les tópoi les plus courants de la polémique anti-islamique.
Looting and Learning: War and the Qur'an in European Oriental Studies
Erudition and the Republic of Letters, 2024
This essay examines the relationship between war and European Qur’anic studies from the mediaeval period to the nineteenth century. It surveys manuscript sources that bear traces of wartime looting and the work of Muslim captives and converts. It argues that war played a recurring role in European oriental studies, helping to shape its practices, aims, and geography. In their early stages, war contributed to a broader shift in academic oriental studies toward the study of the Qur’an in its multilingual Islamic intellectual contexts. Later, as colonial expansion facilitated access to new sources, illicitly acquired manuscripts, especially early Qur’an fragments, were instrumental for historical scholarship on the Qur’an.
EARLY MEDINAN SURAS: THE BIRTH OF POLITICS IN THE QUR'AN
ReOrient , 2024
The central conceptual intervention of this article is that of connecting questions of chronology in the Qur'an with larger problems to do with processes of identity formation in early Islam. More specifically, I propose a new division of the Medinan Qur'anic period. Through a detailed analysis of Sura 16 (Sura al-Naḥl), this article will show that it was revealed in Medina after the Hijra and before the Battle of Badr, contrary to the common view that approaches this and other similar Medinan suras (including Suras 7 and 29) as Meccan composed and Medinan adjusted. My analysis demonstrates that approaching suras like Sura 16 as chronological composites is neither necessary nor defensible. By attempting to reorient our understanding of the Qur'an's chronology, this article tries to break new ground in how we imagine the limits of Muslim identity during this immensely significant transitional moment in the life of the Prophet, the Qur'an, and Islam.
This paper argues that quranic recitations emerged in connection with developments in the final Byzantine-Sasanian war (602-28), particularly the disruption of Syrian and Levantine trade by the war's second phase (610-21). Basal surahs articulated the prophet as a new Moses. Summoned to the border of paradise during his devotions, God's servant was assured that the final judgment would soon resolve his people's crisis. In that eschatological context, the oaths of surahs 90 and 95 invoked the Deuteronomy 8 narrative, where Moses proclaimed that the Hebrew people would soon leave their insecure wanderings by returning to God's promised land. For basal quranic ideology that promised land was paradise itself, which men became worthy to return to by sacrificing their material wealth in God's service. That eschatological ideology was exegetically displaced, however, when later quranic recitations worked to instead articulate Mecca as a new Arabian promised land, which believers would render secure in historical time.