A Fit Memorial for the Times to Come ...': Admonition and Topical Application in Mary Sidney's Antonius and Samuel Daniel's Cleopatra (original) (raw)

2011, The Review of English Studies

Whether designed for the closet, the academic stage, or the public theatres, virtually all late Elizabethan plays about ancient Rome dealt, in one way or another, with the collapse of the republic. Yet that does not mean that they were 'republican', as some recent critics have argued. Rather, the playwrights summoned the Roman past to address, however obliquely, many of the ethical and constitutional issues driving debates about the succession and international politics-and, by default, religion. The following is a case study of two 1590s closet dramas, Mary Sidney's Antonius (1592), a translation from the French of Robert Garnier, and Samuel Daniel's companion piece Cleopatra (1594). Emulating the uses of classical history by Protestant polemicists, divines, and imaginative writers, the two invoke parallels between ancient Rome and Philip II's Spain, Egypt and Elizabethan England, in a bid to underscore the twin dangers of an unsettled succession and royal indolence. At the same time, they exploit the rhetoric of anti-absolutism and anti-imperialism as a vehicle for anti-Spanish sentiment. Far from questioning monarchy per se, Sidney and Daniel denounce Hapsburg designs for global sovereignty and implicitly critique Elizabeth's queenship, suggesting, by contrast, what the godly ruler should be.. .. err not princes you as men must dy: you that sitt high, must fall, and low, as others ly. Psalm 82 1 Whether designed for the closet, the academic stage, or the public theatres, virtually all late Elizabethan plays about ancient Rome dealt, in one way or another, with the collapse of the republic and emergence of princely rule. Thomas Lodge's The work on this essay was made possible by the generosity of several institutions: the British Academy and the Huntington Library which funded a Visiting Fellowship at the Huntington, and Jesus College and the English Faculty at Oxford both of which provided much-needed travel grants. I am grateful to