The Invisibility of Gender: A Feminist Commentary on Age-Based Healthcare Rationing (original) (raw)
Related papers
Just Caring: In Defense of Limited Age-Based Healthcare Rationing
Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics, 2009
The debate around age-based healthcare rationing was precipitated by two books in the late 1980s, one by Daniel Callahan and the other by Norman Daniels. These books ignited a firestorm of criticism, best captured in the claim that any form of age-based healthcare rationing was fundamentally ageist, discriminatory in a morally objectionable sense. That is, the elderly had equal moral worth and an equal right to life as the nonelderly. If an elderly and nonelderly person each had essentially the same medical problem requiring the same medical treatment, then they had an equal right to receive that treatment no matter what the cost of that treatment. Alternatively, if cost was an issue because the benefits of the treatment were too marginal, then both the elderly and nonelderly patients requiring that treatment ought to be denied it. If there were something absolutely scarce about the treatment, then some fair process would have to be used to make an allocation decision (and that fair...
Journal of Social Issues, 2016
Women tend to live longer than men, and thus typically have more interactions with the healthcare system in old age than men do. Ageism and stereotypes of older people in general can have an important impact on elders’ physical and mental health and well‐being. For example, internalized negative stereotypes can produce self‐fulfilling prophecies through stereotype embodiment and contribute to weakness and dependency. Ageist beliefs and stereotypes can interfere with health care seeking as well as with diagnosis and treatment recommendations; they can, for example, contribute to gender disparities in the health care of older adults if older women are perceived as too frail to undergo aggressive treatments. Ageism also results in disrespectful treatment of older patients, which is communicated through baby talk and other forms of infantilization or the shrugging off of patients’ complaints and concerns as “just old age.” Intersectional identities can result in a cumulative burden for ...
Youngest first: Why it is wrong to discriminate against the elderly in health policy
In South Africa and abroad the elderly are systematically discriminated against at all levels of healthcare allocation decision-making. Such discrimination is perhaps surprising in light of the National Health Act and the Older Persons act, which explicitly recognise the elderly as a vulnerable group whose equal rights require special protection. However, ethical theory and public opinion offer some reasons to think that discrimination against the elderly may be justified. This paper examines possible ethical grounds for age discrimination. I claim that there are very few cases in which the aged may be discriminated against, and that age alone is never sufficient grounds for discrimination.
Gender Relations and Applied Research on Aging
The Gerontologist, 2010
As a concept in gerontology, gender appears as lists of traits learned through socialization when theorized at all. I argue for a framework that theorizes the intersections of relations of gender inequality with those of age. This framework holds that men and women gain resources and bear responsibilities, in relation to one another, by virtue of mundane categorization into naturalized stratified groups. Current research shows that this approach allows explanation of gender differences, which appear in many reports but which usually go untheorized, as responses to social inequality. I illustrate applications to research and practice in relation to three areas of old age experiences: financial security, spousal care work, and health. Throughout, I discuss implications of focusing on inequality to enhance our abilities to engage in effective research, practice, and policy for older people, women and men alike. For instance, an understanding of the gender division of labor and workplace discrimination makes clear that financial status in later life cannot be reduced to individual choices concerning paid labor or retirement planning. And understanding that people orient their behaviors to gender ideals allows us to see that men and women perform spousal care in similar and different ways that require varied responses from practitioners; it also reveals contexts in which men engage in positive health behaviors. Finally, I argue that gerontologists interested in facilitating favorable outcomes for old people should consider research and practice that would disrupt, not reinforce, the bases of gender inequalities in later life.
Out of the multiple margins: Older women managing their health care
CJNR (Canadian Journal of Nursing …, 2004
Cette étude phénoménologique féministe explore le sens des expériences vécues par les femmes d'âge mûr au fil de leurs négociations avec le système de santé. Plusieurs entrevues réalisées auprès de divers groupes de femmes d'âge mûr (immigrantes, autochtones, canado-japonaises et les femmes qui adhèrent à des groupes communautaires et sociaux) ont révélé que les négociations qu'elles devaient mener pour obtenir des soins de santé correspondant à leurs besoins constituaient un processus difficile qui nécessitait l'apport d'un soutien mutuel. Des facteurs liés à l'accès aux services, au pouvoir et à la pauvreté influaient sur leurs expériences en matière de soins. Les entrevues axées sur une approche interactive ont stimulé chez plusieurs participantes des prises de conscience, un désir de militer et une réflexion. Les résultats suggèrent que de telles réflexions peuvent aider d'autres femmes à comprendre le concept de « marginalité multiple » (être d'âge mûr, être femme, être membre d'une minorité visible) qui contraint et rend difficile leur accès à des soins de santé.
"Ageism and Feminism: From 'Et Cetera' to Center
NWSA Journal, 2006
Although women's studies scholars and activists do not deny the reality of ageism, they have relegated it to secondary status, neglecting to theorize age relations or place old age at the center of analysis. After explaining what we mean by age relations and their intersections with other inequalities, we discuss the ways in which old people are oppressed, and why age relations represent a political location that needs to be addressed in its own right. We then demonstrate ways in which feminist theories and activism might change if the focus shifted to old people.