The political economy of financing local production in Italy, 1950-1990s (original) (raw)
Related papers
C. Sellar, T. Lan “Banks, Services, and the State: the infrastructure supporting Italian SMEs abroad
Salvatore, F. (ed.) Atti del XXXII Congresso geografico italiano “L’apporto della geografia tra rivoluzioni e riforme, 2019
Investigations of cluster-networks have studied the structure of spatial networks generated by firms’ value chains, between clusters, between city regions, and across different sectors. These discussions focus on the types of linkages and relationships that develop between cluster and the effects these linkages have on cluster performance and competitiveness. This paper focuses on the role of banks, together with service firms and state agencies such as ICE and various others that provide Italian small and medium enterprises (SMEs) with the services needed to operate over long distances. In so doing, we identify two gaps in the literature: first, the scarce treatment of knowledge transmission over long distance, and second, the lack of explanation of how internationalizing firms, especially SMEs, embed themselves in the host regional economies. This paper makes two contribution to the literature. First, it detects a cross-scalar and cross-sectoral service infrastructure that facilitate both long distance knowledge transmission and firms’ embeddedness. Such infrastructure began developing in the mid-1990s, the demand generated by manufacturers in the sending cluster led to internationalization in the banking, aimed at following clients. Once there, mergers and acquisitions and business opportunities expanded Italian banks to new clients and geographical areas, covering entire macro regions. After a certain point, banks would connect with service firms, corporate leaders, and also branches of ICE and other state agencies to build linkages of their own in key urban economies. By the mid-2000s or later according to the geographical area, these actors established communities of professionals supporting Italian manufacturers. This paper calls these communities ‘investment promotion communities’ (IPC). The second contribution consist in analyzing the relationship between internationalizing SMEs and IPC, showing the extent to which IPC have a common structure in different host regional economies vs. the extent to which they adapt to the local conditions.
China-USA Business Review
This work presents the main theoretical guidelines in order to understand the relationship between banks and enterprises in the Italian economical context. It begins by looking into the matter of coverage of the companies' financial needs and it proposes an analysis of the financial structure of small and medium-sized enterprises in Italy, in the years between 2007 and 2012. The subject of studying capitalization of small and medium-sized Italian enterprises and of access to external sources of funding represents an effective synthesis between the qualitative approach of the most important mentioned theories and the quantitative analysis of recent Italian situation. This paper, while depicting the main challenges in the relationship between banks and small and medium-sized enterprises, focuses on the weaknesses of the latter's financial structure, offering useful means to reach a desirable financial new equilibrium. There are many different implications, both from a practical and a social point of view: the wavering economic trend, the frequent enterprise crises and the continuous make the start of processes of patrimonial strengthening and the research for a more stable financial equilibrium, by the diversification of sources of funding. Furthermore, looking into this matter makes it possible to reach a strategic, long-term point of view on the sustainability of the Italian economic-productive system.
The importance of being unimportant: small firms and small banks in Italy
Global Business and Economics Review, 2002
According to the literature on the credit channel, changes in monetary policy affect small firms by changing the costs of external financing. The literature, however, has not yet explored the relationship between the cost of available credit to different groups of borrowers and the competitiveness of the banking industry. I suggest the existence of a relationship between the cost of loans to small borrowers and the degree of concentration in the banking industry. The intuition is that if many banks compete to finance small firms, small f m have the option to switch lender. This, in turn, forces competing banks to absorb, at least in part, the shock introduced by the change in monetary policy thereby sheltering small firms from the negative asymmetric effect of monetary policy.
A Counterfactual Analysis of the Bank-Industry Relationship in Italy, 1913-1936
Until the Banking reform in 1936, banks and industrial companies in Italy were strongly intertwined (both in terms on ownership and interlocking directorates). Using Imita.db -a large a dataset containing data on over 300,000 directors of Italian joint stock companies -this paper analyses what would have happened to the Italian corporate network in the years 1913, 1921, 1927 and 1936 if the "mixed banks" and their directors would have not been there. Our experiments show that new centers of the system would have emerged (financial and electricity and phone companies), confirming the interconnected nature of the Italian capitalism. We also analyze two industries, textiles and iron and steel, characterized by different labor-to-capital intensities to check for sectoral differences. Contrary to conventional wisdom, we find that local banks were important in funding both industries. Overall we call into question the role of mixed banks.
On 21st September 2010 Alessandro Profumo, CEO of Unicredit, one of the most important banking groups in Europe, stepped down under the pressure of some of the majority shareholders representing stakes in the “Foundations”, which had inherited the wealth of the former major saving banks of North Italy. At a distance of almost twenty years from the 1990 reform which started off the privatization of all public banks in Italy, the local public bodies that in the post-war period had guided the business policies of the smaller banks on their territory still exercised a decisive role in choosing the leadership and therefore in influencing the processes allocating resources. The literatures of economic and finance history have by now traced the role that the small Italian public banks, including the saving banks, played in the development of the industrial fabric of the Italian provinces, feeding financially the birth of the clusters and in more general terms the precious microcosm formed by artisans and small companies . What has not been studied so far is the mode in which the saving banks were able to face the internationalisation of a financial system which up to the eighties had conditioned them heavily, both positively and negatively. The savings banks and the local bodies which had always run them not only did not undergo the Italian financial reform of the 1980s/90s, but sought solutions could bring them and their territories notable advantages. The main aim of this paper is therefore to show how the savings banks, particularly in the north, did not undergo the process of privatisation officially starting in the 1990s, but with their new forms of organization managed to go on controlling financial flows at a local level. Surprisingly enough, the passage from a financial system based mostly on public bodies to another inspired by criteria adopted commonly in Western Europe did not cause any drastic changes in the ways the Italian public bodies had always managed financial flows towards the activities on their territory. After a historic introduction, the paper will go on to illustrate the features of the 80s and 90s banking and financial reforms, focusing in particular on the consequences felt by the savings banks. The final section is a case study of a savings bank, the Cassa di Risparmio di Torino (referred to in the text by its acronym CRT) which will describe how the banks adapted to the new norms and the advantages that came with them
In this essay I explore the role of knowledge in the financing of SMEs by combining the results of theoretical and empirical analysis with historical evidence. Theoretical explanations of the role of banks place particular emphasis on information asymmetries, thereby accounting for the privileged relationships that local banks have traditionally developed with small firms. However, as suggested in the "capabilities" literature, the concept of knowledge should be distinguished from that of information. Moreover, the operation of local banks has been strongly affected in the past by both government intervention and the attitude of the supervisory authorities. After providing a conceptual framework, I present some historical findings on the interweaving of economics and politics in SME finance with reference to the Italian experience. I then investigate the role of knowledge in the financing of SMEs in Trentino-South Tyrol-a region in northeastern Italy-in the second half of the twentieth century. For this purpose, I draw mainly on qualitative evidence provided by the records of Mediocredito Trentino-Alto Adige, a public law credit institute established in 1953 to issue medium-and longterm loans to SMEs in the region.
Banking structure and regional economic growth: lessons from Italy
The Annals of Regional Science, 2005
Following the literature on the comparative advantage of small versus large banks at lending to small businesses, and in light of the worldwide decline in the number of intermediaries that specialize in this type of lending associated with deregulation in the banking industry, we examine the role that specific categories of banks have played in the context of Italy's regional economic growth. Over the estimation period, 1970-1993, which ends in the year of full implementation of the banking reform that introduced statutory de-specialization and branching liberalization, Italy featured not only a substantial presence of SME's in the real sector, as is still the case, but also a large and heterogeneous set of credit institutions with different ownership, size and lending styles. Exploiting these peculiarities we study the role of specific intermediaries and gather indirect evidence concerning the likely effects, ceteris paribus, of the current consolidation processes. The main findings, stemming from panel regressions with fixed effects, are as follows. The overall size of the financial sector has a weak impact on growth, but some intermediaries are better than others: Cooperative banks and Special credit institutions play a positive role, Banks of national interest (basically large private banks) and Public law banks (government-owned banks) either do not affect growth or have a negative influence depending on how growth is measured. Cooperative banks were mostly small banks and Special credit institutions were all but large conglomerates with standardized credit policies, hence our results lend support to the current worldwide concerns of a reduction in the availability of credit to SME's resulting from consolidation and regulatory reforms in the banking industry.