What Women Want from Their Physicians: A Qualitative Analysis (original) (raw)
2007, Journal of Women's Health
Background: Despite increased efforts to improve the education of trainees in women's health, little information exists about what women want from their healthcare providers. Existing information from studies focuses on patient care and medical knowledge rather than on all six competencies mandated by the Accreditation Council of Graduate Medical Education (ACGME). Objectives: To identify what adult female patients want their physicians to know and be able to do in all ACGME competency areas in order to guide development of graduate women's health curricula. Methods: We conducted two focus groups with 18 volunteer adult female patients and one focus group with 5 community advocates. Questions addressed all six competency areas. The same female researcher moderated all three sessions. Two researchers analyzed session transcriptions for themes. Results: Female patients and community advocates consistently stressed the need for their physicians to be able to navigate the healthcare system and to be their advocates. They also noted the need for physicians skilled in working with patients from a variety of cultures and for developing and maintaining respectful doctor-patient relationships, including good interpersonal communication. Conclusions: Patients' expectations of physicians extend beyond medical knowledge and patient care into the areas of communication, systems-based practice, and professionalism. Curricular changes in women's health at the postgraduate level should emphasize skills in these competencies, and needs assessment processes would do well to include patient viewpoints in the future.
Related papers
Women's health care issues for medical students: An education proposal
Women's Health Issues, 1996
oices from social, legislative, medical, and educational institutions have expressed dissatisfaction with the current level of general physician competence to deal with women's health issues. In her 1993 article, White described an extremely low level of awareness of issues related to women's health promotion and disease prevention among internal medicine housestaff in her teaching hospital.' Review of hospital admission records of 120 patients revealed notations of tobacco use and rectal examinations on 97% and 72% of charts, whereas histories of Papanicolaou smears and mammograms were noted on only 5%and 4% of the charts. Breast examinations were performed by housestaff on only 33% of patients. The author surmised that "perhaps the housestaff's undergraduate medical training did not standardize consideration of women's health issues as part of the routine patient history and physical examination taught in clinical preparation courses." Similarly, Conway reported relatively low levels of knowledge regarding preconception care among internal medicine resident physicians at Cook County Hospital.' Congresswoman Lowey has described the teaching of women's health as being "fragmented and disjointed throughout the educational process," resulting in gaps in physicians' knowledge about the special health needs of women. She calls for a goal of "educating all physicians in the full range of women's health issues" and proposes that medical schools "be examined with respect to content of curricula for gender differences in disease 0 1996 by The Jacobs Institute and optimal teaching of women's health.
The Women's Health Specialty: Curriculum Implications
I n the 25 years before the mid-1990s the women's health movement, through a network of social-action groups and women's health centers, developed a distinctive women's health care specialty. It is vested not in particular diseases or body parts, as is customary in medicine, but in process. Hunt's1 study of 73 women's health agencies in nine western countries revealed key features of the specialty: women-only services, the creation of woman-space, self-help and holism, feminist counseling and woman-towoman support, feminist teamwork, diversified health care, information sharing and social action, and accessibility.
Journal of Hospital Medicine
BACKGROUND: Women in medicine experience discrimination, hostility, and unconscious bias frequently and with deleterious effects. While these gender-based challenges are well described, strategies to navigate and respond to them are less understood. OBJECTIVE: To explore the lived experiences of female teaching attending physicians emphasizing strategies they use to mitigate gender-based challenges in clinical environments. DESIGN: Multisite exploratory, qualitative study. SETTING: Inpatient general medicine teaching rounds in six geographically diverse US academic hospitals between April and August 2018. PARTICIPANTS: With use of a modified snowball sampling approach, female attendings and their learners were identified; six female attendings and their current (n = 24) and former (n = 17) learners agreed to participate. MEASUREMENTS: Perceptions of gender-based challenges in clinical teaching environments and strategies with which to respond to these challenges were evaluated throu...
Gender Differences in Attending Physicians' Feedback to Residents: A Qualitative Analysis
Journal of graduate medical education, 2017
Prior research has shown a gender gap in the evaluations of emergency medicine (EM) residents' competency on the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) milestones, yet the practical implications of this are not fully understood. To better understand the gender gap in evaluations, we examined qualitative differences in the feedback that male and female residents received from attending physicians. This study used a longitudinal qualitative content analysis of narrative comments by attending physicians during real-time direct observation milestone evaluations of residents. Comments were collected over 2 years from 1 ACGME-accredited EM training program. In total, 1317 direct observation evaluations with comments from 67 faculty members were collected for 47 postgraduate year 3 EM residents. Analysis of the comments revealed that the ideal EM resident possesses many stereotypically masculine traits. Additionally, examination of a subset of the residents (those...
Biology of sex differences, 2016
Addressing healthcare disparities is a national priority for initiatives in precision and individualized medicine. An essential component of precision medicine is the understanding that sex and gender influence health and disease. Whether these issues are addressed in post-graduate medical education curricula is unknown. A questionnaire was designed and administered to residents across the Mayo Clinic enterprise to assess current knowledge of sex and gender medicine in a large program of post-graduate medical education and to identify barriers and preferred teaching methods for addressing sex and gender issues in health and disease. Descriptive and qualitative thematic analyses of the survey responses were compiled and analyzed. Responses were collected from 271 residents (response rate 17.2 %; 54 % female; 46 % male). A broad cross-section of training programs on all Mayo Clinic campuses (Arizona, Minnesota, and Florida) was represented. Sixteen percent of the respondents reported ...
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.