Brazilian Dystopia | 147 Brazilian dystopia: development and Climate Change Mitigation (original) (raw)

Abstract

The Amazonian Rainforest is an area of particular ecological importance to the world. And it is mainly its deforestation, rather than the usual combination of the carbonized energy and transport economic sectors, which make Brazil the world's fourth largest emitter of greenhouse gases. Brazil, with its political and diplomatic alliances with Russia, India, China and South Africa also occupies a prominent position in the complex negotiations with developed countries over the manner in which the "right to development" is defined and understood on the one hand, and then, on the other, balanced with ecological concerns. There are many such concerns but the focus of this article is climate change mitigation. The "dystopia thesis" concludes that humanity faces a plethora of imminent inter-related crises in complex feedback loops. It also concludes that these problems cannot be solved, or even sufficiently ameliorated, from within the context of capitalist reform, or at least not so as to avoid suffering on a colossal scale. This extremely broad, abstract theoretical conclusion, is examined empirically in this article in the particular case of the relationship between the Brazilian economy and the development of the Amazon on the one hand, and climate change mitigation efforts on the other. The examination provides further evidence for the dystopia thesis's most pessimistic conclusions. For our own well being, indeed our very survival, we must protect the Amazonian Rainforest; but we are not going to be able to do so with mechanisms functioning within the context of the present world political economy.

Loading...

Loading Preview

Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.

References (75)

  1. Aerts, R., C. Bakker, and H. De Caluwe. (1992). Root Turnover as Determinant of the Cycling of C, N, and P in a Dry Heathland Ecosystem. Biogeochemistry, 15(3), 175-190.
  2. Alfredsson, G., and Eide, A. (1999). The Universal Declaration of Human Rights : A Common Standard Achievement. Hague, Netherlands: Kluwer Law International.
  3. Andrew, Jane, Kaidonis, Mary A., and Andrew, Brian. (2010). Carbon tax: Challenging neoliberal solutions to climate change. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 21(7), 611-618.
  4. Baer, P., Athanasiou, T., Kartha, S., & Kemp-Benedict, E. (2008). The Greenhouse Development Rights Framework: The right to development in a climate constrained world. Berlin: Heinrich Böll Foundation.
  5. Boucher, Doug. (2011). The Root of the Problem: What's Driving Tropical Deforestation Today? Chapter 5: Cattle and Pasture, pg. 3-11. Union of Concerned Scientists Citizens and Scientists for Environmental Solutions. Retrieved from, http://www.ucsusa.org/global\_warming/ solutions/forest_solutions/drivers-of-deforestation.html
  6. Börner, Jan, Sven Wunder, Sheila Wertz-Kanounnikoff, Marcos Rϋgnitz Tito, Ligia Pereira, and Nathalia Nascimento. (2010). Direct conservation payments in the Brazlian Amazon: Scope and equity implications. Ecological Economics, 69(6), 1272-1282.
  7. Brady, Nyle C. (1996). Alternatives to slash-and-burn: a global imperative. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 58(1), 3-11.
  8. Broto, V. C. (2011). Review Essay: Climate Change and Sustainable Development Perspectives in Construction and Planning. Urban Studies, 48(13), 2905-2910.
  9. Butler, R. (2008, December 12). Lula pledges big cuts in Amazon deforestation -- after he leaves office. Retrieved October 23, 2013, from Mongabay: http:// news.mongabay.com/2008/1212-amazon_targets.html
  10. Butler, R. (2009, June 02). Brazil's plan to save the Amazon rainforest. Retrieved October 23, 2013, from Mongabay: http://news.mongabay. com/2009/0602-brazil.html
  11. Butler, R. (2012, July 22). Cattle Ranching's Impact on the Rainforest. Retrieved October 23, 2013, from Mongabay: http://rainforests.mongabay. com/0812.htm
  12. Butler, R. (2013, October). Amazon Destruction: Why is the rainforest being destroyed in Brazil? Retrieved October 23, 2013, from Mongabay: http:// rainforests.mongabay.com/amazon/amazon_destruction.html
  13. Butler, R. (2013, October 23). Drivers of Deforestation. Retrieved 10 23, 2013, from Mongabay: http://rainforests.mongabay.com/deforestation\_ drivers.html
  14. Celentano, Danielle, Erin Sills, Marcio Sales, and Adalberto Veríssimo. (2011). Welfare Outcomes and the Advance of the Deforestation Frontier in the Brazilian Amazon. World Development, 40(4), 850-864.
  15. Cederberg, Christel, U. Martin Persson, Kristian Neovius, Sverker Molander and Roland Clift. (2011). Including Carbon Emissions from Deforestation in the CarbonFootprint of Brazilian Beef. Environmental Science & Technology, 45(5), 1773-1779.
  16. Central Intelligence Agency World Fact Book. (2013). https://www.cia.gov/ library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/br.html
  17. Davidson, Eric A., Alessandro C. de Araújo, Paulo Artaxo, Jennifer K. Balch, I. Foster Brown, Mercedes M. C. Bustamante, Michael T. Coe, Ruth S. DeFries, Michael Keller, Marcos Longo, J. William Munger, Wilfrid Schroeder, Britaldo S. Soares-Filho, Carlos M. Souza Jr, and Steven C. Wofsy. (2012). The Amazon basin in transition. Nature, 481(7381), 321-328.
  18. de Motta, R. (2012). The Brazilian Policy on Climate Change: Regulatory and Governance Aspects. Brasilia: International Policy Centre for Inclusive Growth -No: 154. Retrieved March 31, 2013
  19. d'Oliveira, M.V.N., E.C. Alvarado, J.C. Santos, J.A. Carvalho. (2011). Forest natural regeneration and biomass production after slash and burn in a seasonally dry forest in the Southern Brazilian Amazon. Forest Ecology and Management, 261(9), 1490-1498.
  20. Dyson, T. (2005). On Development, Demography and Climate Change: The End of the World as We Know it? Population and Environment, 2, 117-149.
  21. East, A. J. (2008). What is a carbon footprint? An overview of definitions and methodologies. In Vegetable in-dustry carbon footprint scoping study-Discussion papers and workshop. Retrieved from, http://www. enviroconnews.com/?m=201203
  22. Fairlie, S. (2012). Maximizing Soil Carbon Sequestration: Carbon Farming and Rotational Grazing. Mother Earth News, pp. 1-4.
  23. Retrieved from http://www.motherearthnews.com/ Fearnside, Philip M. (1996). Amazonian deforestation and global warming: carbon stocks in vegetation replacing Brazil's Amazon forest. Forest Ecology and Management, 80(1-3), 21-34.
  24. Fearnside, Philip M., Ciro Abbud Righi, Paulo Mauricio Lima de Alencastro Graҫa, Edwin W.H. Keizer, Carlos Clemente Cerri, Euler Melo Nogueira, Reinaldo Imbrozio Barbosa. Biomass and greenhouse-gas emissions from land-use change in Brazil's Amazonian 'arc of deforestation': The states of Mato Grosso and Rondônia. (2009). Forest Ecology and Management, 258(9), 1968-1978.
  25. Fearnside, Philip M. (2012). Brazil's Amazon forest in mitigating global warming: unresolved controversies. Climate Policy, 12(1): 70-81.
  26. Fearnside, P. M. (2005). Deforestation in Brazilian Amazonia: History, rates and consequences. Conservation Biology, 19(3), 680-688.
  27. Fearnside, Philip M. (1995). Potential impacts of climatic change on natural forests and forestry in Brazilian Amazonia. Forest Ecology and Management, 78(1-3), 51-70.
  28. Fearnside, Philip M. (2001). Saving tropical forests as a global warming countermeasure: an issue that divides the environmental movement. Ecological Economics, 39(2), 167-184.
  29. Finkbeiner, M. (2009). Carbon footprinting-Opportunities and threats. International journal of Life Cycle Assessment, 14, 91-94.
  30. FSC Watch (2008) Exposed: FSC-certified clear-cutting of Massachusetts public forests USA.
  31. Foster, John Bellamy (2011). Capitalism and Degrowth: An Impossibility Theorem" Monthly Review, Volume 62 (8), pp.26-33.
  32. Gerwing, Jeffrey J. (2002). Degradation of forests through logging and fire in the eastern Brazilian Amazon. Forest Ecology and Management, 157(1-3), 131-141.
  33. Hamm, B. I. (2001). A Human Rights Approach to Development. Human Rights Quarterly, 23, 1005-1031.
  34. Heyward, M. (2007). Equity and international climate change negotiations: a matter of perspective. Climate Policy, 7(6), 518-534.
  35. Hochstetler, K., and Viola, E. (2012). Brazil and the Politics of Climate Change: Beyond the Global Commons. Environmental Politics, 21(5), 753-771.
  36. Human Development Reports. (2013). Brazil, Country Profile: Human Development Indicators, UNDP. Retrieved from, http://hdr.undp.org/ en/statistics/ and http://hdrstats.undp.org/en/countries/profiles/BRA. html Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatistica. (2010). www.ibge.gov.br Jassal, Rachhpal, Andy Black, Mike Novak, Kai Morgenstern, Zoran Nesic, David Gaumont-Guay. (2005). Relationship between soil CO2 concentrations and forest-floor CO2 effluxes. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, 130(3-4), 176-192.
  37. Kovel, Joel (2002) The Enemy of Nature: The End of Capitalism or the End of the World? Zed Books.
  38. Lashof, D. A., & Ahuja, D. R. (1992). Relative Contributions of Greenhouse Gas Emissions to Gglobal Warming. Nature, 344, 529-531.
  39. Laurance, William F. (1999). Gaia's Lungs. Natural History, 108(2): 96.
  40. Laurance, W. F. (2007). A New Initiative to Use Carbon Trading for Tropical Forest Conservation. Biotropica , 39(1), 20-24.
  41. Lee, H., Park, T., Kim, B., Kim, K., & Kim, H. (2013). A real option-based model for promoting sustainable energ yprojects under the clean developmen tmechanism. Energy Policy, 54, 360-368.
  42. Leimbach, Marian. (2003). Equity and carbon emissions trading: a model analysis. Energy policy, 31(10), 1033-1044.
  43. Lofquist, L. (2011). Climate change, justice and the right to development. Journal of Global Ethics, 7(3), 251-261.
  44. Mazzei, Lucas, Plinio Sist, Ademir Ruschel, Francis E. Putz, Phidias Marco, Wagner Pena, and Josué Evandro Ribeiro Ferreira. (2010). Above- ground biomass dynamics after reduced-impact logging in the Eastern Amazon. Forest Ecology and Management, 259(3), 367-373.
  45. Nitschelm, Jennifer J., Andreas Lϋscher, Ueli A. Hartwig, and Chris Van Kessel. (1997). Using stable isotopes to determine soil carbon input differences under ambient and elevated atmospheric CO2 conditions. Global Change biology, 3(5), 411-416.
  46. NOREDD (2011) "Indigenous Peoples Condemn Climate Talks Fiasco and Demand Moratoria on REDD+" http://noredd.makenoise.org/ indigenous-peoples-condemn-climate-talks-fiasco-and-demand- moratoria-on-redd.html
  47. Pandey, D., Agrawal, M., & Pandey, J. S. (2011). Carbon footprint: current methods of estimation. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 178(1-4), 135-160.
  48. Peters, G. P. (2010). Carbon footprints and embodied car-bon at multiple scales. Current Opinion in Environ-mental Sustainability. doi:10.1016/j.cosust.2010.05.004.
  49. Pew Research. (2010) Global Attitudes Project. http://www.pewglobal.org/2010/09/22/chapter-5-environmental-issues/ Pew Research. (2009). Global Warming Seen as a Major Problem Around the World Less Concern in the U.S., China and Russia. PewResearch Global Attitudes Project.
  50. Pielke Jr., Roger (2013) The Climate Fix: Climate Change and Europe's Carbon Emissions Failure, Basic Books.
  51. Potter, Garry (2009) New Orleans And Katrina, Past Prediction, Future Dystopia, Swans Commentary. http://www.swans.com/library/art15/ potter01.html
  52. Potter, Garry (2010a) Dystopia: What is to be done? New Revolution Press.
  53. Potter, Garry (2010b) "Power and Knowledge: A Dialectical Contradiction", Journal of Critical Realism Vol.9, No.2, pp.133-154.
  54. Potter, Garry (2012) "Imaginaries and Realities, Utopia and Dystopia", Alternate Routes: A Journal of Critical Social Research, 23, pp.265-278.
  55. Rainforest Conservation Fund (2013). "RCF helps create 960,000-acre reserve in Peruvian Amazon!" July 13.
  56. Rapoza, K. (2011). "US Overtakes Brazil As World's No. 1 Beef Exporter", Forbes. Retrieved from, http://www.forbes.com/sites/ kenrapoza/2011/09/23/us-overtakes-brazil-as-worlds-no-1-beef- exporter/
  57. Ribeiro, Jeferson. (2012). Brazil's Amazon Fund bogs down, donors frustrated. AlertNet. Retrieved from, http://www.trust.org/alertnet/ news/brazils-amazon-fund-bogs-down-donors-frustrated/
  58. Robinson, J., Bradley, M., Busby, P., Connor, D., Murray, A., Sampson, B., & Soper, W. (2006). Climate Change and Sustainable Development: Realizing the Opportunity. AMBIO: A Journal of the Human Environment, 35(1), 2-8.
  59. Robinson, K. (2010). Brazil's Global Warming Agenda. Washington DC.: World Resources Institute.
  60. Rodrigues, Jorge L., Vivian H. Pellizari, Rebecca Mueller, Kyunghwa Baek, Ederson da C. Jesus, Fabiana S. Paula, Babur Mirza, George S. Hamaoui, Jr., Siu Mui Tsai, Brigitte Feigl, James M. Tiedje, Brendan J.M. Bohannan, and Klaus Nϋsslein. (2013). Conversion of the Amazon rainforest to agriculture results in biotic homogenization of soil bacterial communities. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 110(3), 988-993. Retrieved from http://www.pnas.org/content/110/3/988
  61. Rogers, Hugo H., Stephen A. Prior, G. Brett Runion, and Robert J. Mitchell. (1996). Root to shoot ratio of crops as influenced by CO2. Plant and Soil, 187(2), 229-248.
  62. Roman, M. (2010). Shifiting ground: Brazil Tackles Climate Change and Deforestation, but Rapid Growth, Energy Needs Undermine Progress. Stockholm: Stockholm Environment Institute. Retrieved March 29, 2013
  63. Rong, F. (2010). Understanding developing country stances on post-2012 climate change negotiations: Comparative analysis of Brazil, China ,India, Mexico, and South Africa. Energy Policy, 38, 4582-4591.
  64. Sarkar, Saral (1999). Eco-Socialism or Eco-Capitalism? A Critical Analysis of Humanity's Fundamental Choices, Zed Books.
  65. Sengupta, A. (2002). On the Theory and Practice of the Right to Development. Human Rights Quarterly, 24(4), 837-889.
  66. Smith, Nigel, Jean Dubois, Dean Current, Ernst Lutz, and Charles Clement. (1998). Agrogorestry Experiences in the Brazilian Amazon: Constraints and Opportunities. Conservation and Development of Brazil's Tropical Forest Regions.
  67. Søe, Astrid R. B., Anette Giesemann, Traute-Heidi Anderson, Hans- Joachim Weigel, and Nina Buchmann. (2004). Soil respiration under elevated CO2 and its partitioning into recently assimilated and older carbon sources. Plant and Soil, 262(1-2), 85-94.
  68. Sullivan, Sian. (2009) Green capitalism, and the cultural poverty of constructing nature as service-provider. Radical Anthropology, 3, 18-27.
  69. The Guardian. (2011, July 26). What is the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM)? The Guardian, p. 1-2. Retrieved from http://www.guardian. co.uk/environment/2011/jul/26/clean-development-mechanism
  70. Tollefson, Jeff. (2013). A light in the forest: Brazil's fight to save to Amazon and climate-change diplomacy. Foreign Affairs, 92(2).
  71. Tulip Hardwood Floors (2011). FSC Certified. http://www.tulipfloors.com/ sustainability/fsc_certified UFCCC. (2013). United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change . Retrieved April 12, 2013, from Parties & Observers: http:// unfccc.int/parties_and_observers/items/2704.php UFCCC-CMD. (2013). Clean Development Mechanism (CDM). Retrieved April 12, 2013, from The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Chanege: http://unfccc.int/kyoto\_protocol/mechanisms/ clean_development_mechanism/ite ms/2718.php
  72. United Nations (1986), Declaration on the Right to Development, United Nations General Assembly resolution 41/128 http://www.un.org/ ga/search/view_doc.asp?symbol=A/RES/41/128&Lang=E&Are
  73. UNDP. (2013, March 30). United Nations Development Program Human Development Index. Retrieved from United Nations Development Program: http://issuu.com/undp/docs/hdr\_2013\_en?mode=window USDA report (2006) Wood Market Update http://www.fas.usda.gov/ffpd/ Newsroom/Wood%20Market%20Update.pdf
  74. Wiedmann, T., & Minx, J. (2007). A definition of carbon footprint. ISAUK Research Report 07-01, Durham, ISAUK Research & Consulting.World People's Conference on Climate Change and the Rights of Mother Earth http://pwccc.wordpress.com/2011/06/16/bolivia-proposes-pathway-to- solve-climate-talks-be-clear-about-targets-and-honour-commitments/
  75. Zhang, Fuwei, Guo, Ying, and Chen, Xiaoping. (2011). Research on China's Power Sector Carbon Emissions Trading Mechanism. Energy Procedia, 12, 127-132.