An investigation into how school governing bodies can assist with the performance of underperforming and dysfunctional schools in less advantaged urban communities in the Western Cape (original) (raw)
After 15 years in the democratic dispensation of South Africa, having access, equity and redress in educational provision have not yet been achieved. Instead, the reality speaks of underperformance (schools with a less than 60% national matric pass rate) as well as dysfunctional schools (with a less than 20% pass rate) continue in the Western Cape amidst a 7% increase in the Matric pass rate nationally. The intention of the Western Cape Education Department (hereafter referred to as the WCED) to reduce the number of dysfunctional schools from 85 to 55 resulted in a decrease to 78 schools. The overall increase of the 2010 matric pass rate in the Western Cape from 75.7% to 76.8% does not reflect an increase of quality educational provision to children from less advantaged urban areas. The aim of this study is to determine how and why some formerly identified dysfunctional and underperforming schools in less advantaged urban areas improved their performance while others did not. Also looking at, the role played by the School Governing Body in improving performance as a stakeholder, especially the role of the parental entity. It is clear that there are particular challenges facing parents from disadvantaged communities that directly influence their involvement and contribution to the improvement of performance in dysfunctional and underperforming schools. This research project focuses entirely on education but it is done within the field of development studies, trying to address certain developmental issues that impact educational provision and performance The theory of Structuration is used in the theoretical framework to understand the relationship between the agent (learners, parents, educators) and the structure (education system, society). It is useful to understand and address the challenges that prevent/delay improvement in the performance and function of schools in certain less advantaged urban communities. The Humanistic paradigm is used as a theory to emphasise the importance of a grassroots/ bottom up approach to development and to bring better understanding of parental involvement in educational provision. The mixed method approach (using both qualitative and quantitative research methods) that is widely acceptable in the field of educational research and in the development milieu is applied to address the question at hand. The use of a literature study, semi-structured interviews with focus groups and questionnaires to participating schools provide useful data for the research. The findings from this research will benefit the participating schools, the WCED and the education system. November 2012 iv DECLARATION I declare that An investigation into how School Governing Bodies can assist with the performance of underperforming and dysfunctional schools in less advantaged urban communities in the Western Cape is my own work, that it has not been submitted before for any degree or examination in any other university, and that all the sources I have used or quoted have been indicated and acknowledged as complete references
Related papers
The Role of School Governing Bodies in Underperforming Schools of Western Cape: A Field Based Study
Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences, 2014
The schools in South Africa have been facing immense challenges for a long period of time especially after independence in 1994. The School Governing Bodies (SGBs) play a major role in the administration and finance functions of the school and its development however, school governing bodies are sometimes used by individuals and organised groups to discriminate against learners in South Africa. It is found that some SGBs are not working properly because they do not have the necessary skills and they are not sure about their roles and responsibilities. This indeed happens in poorer communities, where people have few resources and many cannot read and write. The situation is made worse by the fact that some of the schools do not get enough money, support and training from the government. A strong sentiment amongst teachers was that the core of the problem of ineffectual SGBs was located in bad leadership and management. In light of the above challenges an attempt is made in this article to discuss the definition of the role of the School Governing Bodies (SGBs) in terms of the South African Schools Act. The article also focuses on the findings that were generated through responses to a number of questions around the theme of school governing bodies that were included in the questionnaires administered to principals and teachers.
This article reports on the findings of a research project which sought to explore the challenges of parental involvement in rural public schools of Ngaka Modiri Moleme in North West province. It shows the state of affairs in rural public school of desperate parents who cannot make any meaningful contribution to their learners' education owing to their disadvantaged educational background, and how their non involvement hampers quality public education in South Africa. This article argues that parental involvement is a constitutional imperative which must be embraced properly by all those with vested interest in sustaining quality public education. The paper further argues that parents in rural public schools around Ngaka Modiri Moleme need intervention in the form of capacity building.
Researchfora International Conference, Lagos, Nigeria, 29th - 30th November, 2019
The success and failure of education – especially in the school context – lies entirely in its governance. Having poorly trained and illiterate SGBs has a strong influence in schools’ productivity. However, rural schools are experiencing poor performance, which is attributed to poor governance. This study examined the challenges of various school governing bodies and sought solutions to those challenges in order to improve the performance of schools in a rural ecology. The study was conducted in the Thabo-Mofutsanyane district of the Free State. Emancipation theory was used as the theoretical framework for the study. This study adopted a qualitative research approach. The participant comprises all SGBs in the selected school of the Thabo-Mofutsanyane district in Bethlehem in the Free State. The principal, the chairperson and the deputy chairperson of the SGB, the secretary and the deputy chairperson and the treasurer were used as participants, totaling six participants. Unstructured interviews were used as the method of data collection and the data collected were transcribed and analysed using thematic analysis. The study showed that poor performance of the schools is significant to the poor training of SGBs, levels of illiteracy and financial struggle. It was recommended that there must be minimum educational requirements that must be made for people to qualify as members and the development of proper courses to empower the SGBs alongside adequate funding.
SSRN Electronic Journal
This paper explores governance dynamics in four case study schools in low-income communities in South Africa's Eastern Cape province. A main aim is to identify empirically the causal mechanisms through which horizontal, school-level governance might function as an 'institutional substitute' for weaknesses in the province's education bureaucracy. The case studies uncovered both vicious circles of capture, and virtuous spirals-with the latter characterised by shared developmental commitment among school leaders, teachers, parents and the community, strong enough to counter efforts at predation. The findings offer encouragement that nonhierarchical entry points for improving educational outcomes indeed have some potential to achieve gains.
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EDUCATIONAL SCIENCES
Since the advent of the new educational dispensation in 1994, the South African National Department of education has embarked on a process of enhancing the improvement of pass-rates in secondary schools. However, despite these efforts the process has not been very smooth as some schools have not improved or least show signs of the improvement of their performances. This paper therefore explores factors contributing to school improvement in secondary schools. During this generative qualitative study data was collected from principals, SMT members, Teachers, and SGB member's focus groups. Face to face interviews were held with principals, focus group interviews were held with school management teams, teachers and school governing body parents. Documentary analysis from three highly improved schools (those that have seen dramatic improvement in learner attainment and basic functionality over three years) and three less improved schools (those that have not improved their learner attainment and basic functionality over three years) was also done. Data was then analysed using constant comparative analysis within an inductive analytical framework. Among the findings of the study is that management and leadership, effective curriculum management, effective school governance and an effective support structures are at the heart of any school improvement success.
2017
School Governing Bodies (SGBs) as part of the community, play an important role in the enhancement of a culture of teaching and learning in schools. This idea is important in the enhancement of a culture of teaching and learning in schools, but rarely applicable in most of disadvantaged high schools. Disadvantaged schools in this context refer to rural poor schools with no proper resources and teaching. This means that learners in such communities could not be able to do schoolwork, due to the lack of parental involvement. In this study, qualitative interpretive approach was used. The researcher preferred to use this method in order to obtain a more detailed understanding of the involvement of SGBs in the enhancement of a culture of teaching and learning in schools. Data was collected through unstructured interviews that are formal or informal whereby the participants answer freely the questions asked, allowing the expression of feelings during the interviews. In this study SGBs wer...
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.