Data-Driven Processes in Participatory Urbanism: The “Smartness” of Historical Cities (original) (raw)
Related papers
Interweaving the digital and analog lives of cities: urban sensing and user-generated cities
REAL CORP 2013 Proceedings
A research process lasting from 2009 to 2012 has conceptualized, designed and implemented multiple tools and strategies to experiment novel forms of technologically-supported urban interaction. The goal of this process has been to understand the rituals which have started to shape contemporary citizens' perception and performance of urban public and private spaces. An ethnographic approach has been used to gather insights about these emergent rituals, affecting the ways in which people have transformed the ways in which they work, learn, relate, consume, travel and entertain themselves in the city. With the active collaboration of public administrations, organizations, citizen groups, tourist operators and research teams these practices have been enacted in the cities of Rome, Turin, Trieste, Cosenza, London, Berlin and Hong Kong for variable amounts of time. Engagement and results have been formally gathered, observed, processed and measured, allowing the research team to both explore the current scenario and envision new ones. Real-time content harvesting from social networks, natural language analysis, geo-referencing/geo-coding/geo-parsing technologies, expert systems and ubiquitous technologies such as smartphones, custom electronic devices and conceptual consumer products have been employed to explore the ways in which people are and will be able to: perceive and understand their urban surroundings; access services and information; co-produce knowledge and distributed intelligence; collaborate in the creation of shared projects and city-governance practices; create and maintain peer-to-peer infrastructures for connectivity, commerce, services and culture. This paper will present the initial analysis – including previous research taken into account in the fields of urban sensing, citizen science, urban planning, urban infrastructure management, urban environment perception and more –; the methodologies, both shared and project-specific, used to conceive, design, implement the prototypes and to measure their effects; the reports about each project in the aforementioned cities, including their usage on-the-field as well as elements of urban and digital ethnographic observation and user experience analysis; a description of a scenario for further research and for the production of service and product concepts, some of which are already in-progress, in the areas of the arts, culture, tourism and city administration. What emerges is the opportunity to create multi-layered interactive landscapes in urban contexts which allow city dwellers to communicate, collaborate, govern their city, exchange knowledge and information, consume, entertain themselves, produce and distribute services.
(Smart) City and the (Open) Data. A Critical Approach to a Platform-driven Urban Citizenship
Partecipazione e Conflitto, 2020
This paper represents a first attempt to reconstruct a theoretical map of the relation between technology (digital media) and citizenship. We start from the reconstruction of the role of citizens in the smart city paradigm and then face the challenge that the so-called Big Techs move to the ideal of an engaged "smart community" by promoting an individual relationship between users/citizens and digital platforms. Finally, we present two emerging participation paradigms concerning Data Activism and Cooperativism, which seem to represent relevant fields for experiencing (and observing) the agency of a future, networked citizenship.
Shared Ethnography of Shared Cities
This paper aims to foreground issues for design ethnographers working in urban contexts within the smart-city discourse. It highlights ethnography’s role in a shared urban future by exploring how ethnographers might pave the way for envisioning digital infrastructure at the core of Smart City programs. This paper begins by asking whether urban development practitioners can design for inclusive interaction with Smart Urban Infrastructure. The research suggests how ethnographers can work with ‘cities’ to rapidly develop diagnostic tools and capture insights that inform design processes with both utility and inclusive interaction as their key values. This involves rethinking how we consider places where space and information intersect. This work led to developing rapid means to assay a site and sensitize to contextual issues by tapping into heuristic expertise innate in city dwellers. This means doing ethnography in parallel with publics as opposed to performing ethnography ‘on’ them. Hence we discuss a fresh ethnographic perspective that can be especially useful in this context; shared ethnography
Smarten Up! Open Data, Toolkits and Participation in the Social City
Communications & Strategies, 2014
The current era of austerity is placing increasing pressure on governments everywhere to do more with less, particularly at the local level where government services have the greatest impact on citizens' everyday lives. Thereby the roles of information and communication technologies and citizens are highlighted. This article is designed to yield insights into how local city administrations can facilitate and optimize citizen involvement in the context of the co-production of city services deploying mobile devices. Cities can be seen to open up public data aiming at offering new opportunities for the generation, use and integration of, among others, economic, social and environmental data. They seek to do so via city-hosted toolkits allowing users – which are the most important users of the city's urban environment and generating the most current data and knowledge that may inform and enrich governing practices, such as planning - to develop mobile applications emphasizing lo...
Smarten Up! Open Data, Toolkits and Participatory Governance in the Social City
Communications & Strategies
The current era of austerity is placing increasing pressure on governments everywhere to do more with less, particularly at the local level where government services have the greatest impact on citizens' everyday lives. Thereby the roles of information and communication technologies and citizens are highlighted. This article is designed to yield insights into how local city administrations can facilitate and optimize citizen involvement in the context of the co-production of city services deploying mobile devices. Cities can be seen to open up public data aiming at offering new opportunities for the generation, use and integration of, among others, economic, social and environmental data. They seek to do so via city-hosted toolkits allowing users – which are the most important users of the city's urban environment and generating the most current data and knowledge that may inform and enrich governing practices, such as planning - to develop mobile applications emphasizing local deployment. The analytical framework focuses on the role of the (purposefully) city-provided toolkit and the citizens' capacities to engage in the public domain guided by the Living Lab approach. In doing so, the dynamics between the provided tools (and data) addressing the needs of the city and citizens underpinning citizens' everyday life experience in navigating and appropriating the urban space, are drawn out. The empirical results are used as preliminary evidence to yield a more rounded understanding of co-production of e-government information and services leveraged as a core innovative process, currently being played out, in the city of Athens (Greece) and Ghent (Belgium).
Creative Urban Methods for the Datafied City
Amsterdam University Press eBooks, 2023
Datafied and smart cities produce some challenges for inclusive, resilient, and sustainable urban futures. How can creative methods contribute to thinking and designing ways to imagine and co-create datafied cities with and for participatory citizenship and values for inclusion and sustainability? This question is central to the agenda of the research group [urban interfaces] and their collaboration in interdicisplinary and transdisciplinary partnerships. Working with and around the concepts of participation, criticality and imagination, the group brings cultural inquiry into datafied cities together with a methodological inquiry into creative urban methods. In the following, we sketch this agenda and approach and some recent examples of what such creative methods may yield.
2021
This article addresses the integration of cultural perspectives in the smart city discourse and in the implementation of the UN Agenda 2030; it does so specifically with respect to land patterns and land use. We hope to increase the ability of relevant stakeholders, including scientific communities working in that field, to handle the complexity of the current urban challenges. Culture is understood here in the broadest sense of the word, including the values and conceptualizations of the world, and the modes of technological creation and control of the environment. This concept of culture varies among stakeholders, depending, in particular, on their activities, on the place they live in, and also depending on their scientific background. We propose to complement existing targets that are explicitly related to culture in the UN and UNESCO agendas for 2030, and introduce a target of culture awareness for city information infrastructures. We show that, in the specific case of land pat...
Design, Control, Predict: Cultural Politics In The Actually Existing Smart City
2018
Design, Control, Predict: Cultural Politics in the Actually Existing Smart City studies the discourses, rhetorics, intuitions, logics, policies, imaginaries, and imageries that animate the intersection between computational media technologies and cities. It presents three case studies in which a diverse array of actors and institutions engage in struggles to articulate, define, and render legible highly complex, unruly, and often woolly urban processes as problems of efficiency to be solved through technocratic intervention. The introductory chapter, "Cultural Politics, Smart Cities, Logistical Media" (Chapter 1), theorizes the relationship between two ways of studying the smart city as a cultural-political object. On one hand is a global imaginary that takes shape in pristine architectural renderings, diagrams detailing the embedding of data-generating technologies within urban spaces, and city-scale prototypes built de novo on greenfield sites (such as Songdo in South Korea, Masdar City in Abu Dhabi, and PlanIT Valley in Portugal). On the other is the "actually existing smart city"-the piecemeal interventions that take hold in extant cities. These two versions of the smart city are considered in tandem for two reasons: first, to understand the way that imaginaries shape actual interventions, and second to avoid hierarchical categorizations of the smart city based on their formal qualities (the "top-down" and "bottom-up" smart city). The chapter then moves to detail the dissertation's media-theoretical approach to the smart city. It argues that the smart city's computational media should be noted for their logistical affordances. Smart city technologies, like logistical media broadly, operate by orientating, arranging, and tracking mobile objects and people within urban spaces. Their principal concern is to eke out new efficiencies that can be mined and exploited to produce value. The chapter argues that a more nuanced approach is needed to study the smart city, one that accounts for the logistical affordances of urban computational media technologies while simultaneously situating those within cultural-political struggles around the legitimacy of smart city interventions.
D.P. Baker, W.P. Evand (eds.), Digital Information Strategies. From Applications and Content to Libraries and People, Edition: 1, Chapter: 13, pp. 185-198., 2016
According to technology pundits, we are at the brink of an information (technology) revolution. Within a decade, the “Internet of Things” (IoT, the interconnection of uniquely identifiable devices within the Internet infrastructure (Holler, et al., 2014), will generate huge amounts of digital data. This data may be applied to manage the urban environments in which the majority of the population of the world is living. Those urban environments will be turned into ‘smart cities’. The subject of the smart city is discussed extensively within scientific and political communities. Most attention is paid to the new and exciting possibilities that integrated information technology systems (ICTs) have to offer to citizens of these smart cities (Townsend, 2013). What is less discussed is the process of information management (IM) that is instrumental to the application of the ICTs within a smart city. The huge amounts of data necessary to manage a smart city require IM models that match the unprecedented scale of data processing that is required. This is highly relevant, because it is acknowledged in literature that the societal impact of this scale of data processing cannot be predicted (Mayer-Schönberger, Cukier, 2013). Proper attention to the IM issues that will emerge as smart cities are implemented is therefore highly relevant. In this chapter we will be exploring smart cities: those cities that succeed in the application of ICTs at a practical level and harvest the benefits of the IoT. We will discuss the application of ICTs and look at the aspects of digital data that are relevant in the ‘information value chain’ (IVC) that is being executed. We will follow the flow of data from the initial cue that starts the process, as picked up by sensors, the interfaces that provide interaction between the city and the individual citizen, and the intelligence behind the screens that is responsible for the delivery of applicable information to the citizen. We will start with a short sketch of ideas and ideals that underlie the smart city; followed by discussion of building blocks - sensors, screens and actuators - that enable the city environment to interact with the citizen on the street. After that, we delve into the IVC, following the path data takes along that chain in the course of its value creation for the city.
Subtle Revolutions, Proceedings of the 2nd Biennial Hybrid City Conference , 2013
Starting with a theoretical dialogue on the current "modus operandi" of the City through the prism of «new technologies», this paper discusses whether they are providing new «tropes» of social interaction and coexistence. Through the presentation of examples of socially driven operations in the Athenian Urban Grid (Hive Athens, Re-think Athens, Community based design networks), urban space is viewed as an on-going production of spatial relations, as a field of infinite transformations beyond design. The discussion focuses on the ability of new technologies to transform cities into “communication modes” incorporating issues beyond morphogenesis, identified in the decision-making process leading to it. Finally, it raises some questions on whether new technologies, as socially embedded processes, can be rendered as the backbone of the social structure; whether, they can transform the urban environment into a place of constant participatory actions, into unique civic laboratories, and thus innovate the term “hybrid city”. Keywords: urban data processing, urban formation processes, participatory planning