The White Album: on racialized violence and the witnessing of the witness (original) (raw)
Related papers
Black bodies at risk: Exploring the corporeal iconography of the anti-police brutality movement
Journalism, 2021
Black bodies at risk are in constant conversation with each other. The Black witness who films a fatal police encounter on her phone is talking to the Black victim, promising not to leave him in his final moments. The distant Black witness who sees that video then talks back to the witness and the victim, creating powerful imagery that amplifies the tragic footage. In this manner, those working under the broad banner of the Black Lives Matter movement have reimagined a dynamic Black visual public sphere, where moral arguments about police brutality are sustained through an assemblage of strategic visual appeals. In this essay, I argue that this call-and-response of Black corporeal iconography forms the vanguard of embodied protest journalism in the 21st century. I explain how the concepts of “strong objectivity,” which is rooted in feminist standpoint theory, help validate and liberate the flesh witnessing of the marginalized. Moreover, I offer two broad categories of imagery that B...
This essay argues that we must look beyond the evidentiary functions of online videos of police violence, like those documenting Eric Garner's killing by the NYPD and the shooting of Walter Scott in South Carolina, to aesthetics as a response to the limits of juridical process. As merely evidence, these videos are " framed " by what the essay calls the " police hermeneutic, " which captures and diffuses their political potential through an interpretive monopoly. Looking closely at the videos surrounding the 2009 killing of Oscar Grant III on the Fruitvale BART station platform, the essay draws on Jacques Rancière's conception aesthetics in relation to the police order and Michel Foucault's description of the " spectacle of the scaffold, " to argue that a political potential inheres on the aesthetic level of these images. There the police distribution of bodies and subjects, and interpretation of events, is at once made visible and disrupted by the interventions of fellow travelers and their cell phones on the BART station and then digital media platforms. In the wake of more than two years of high profile killings of unarmed black men and women approximately 4000 police departments have initiated body mounted camera programs, while the US Justice Department has earmarked $20m to support and expand these programs. [1] [#N1] Though it is decidedly unlikely that the recent coverage of these incidents reflects any sort of quantitative increase in police violence toward people of color and the poor, a qualitative surge in public attention fuels this effort to increase and intensify the surveillance of law enforcement; no doubt this attention and subsequent response is, in part, a product of digital cellular phone videos and their Aesthetics, Politics, and the Police Hermeneutic: Online Videos of Po...
Digital witnessing and the erasure of the racialized subject
Journal of Visual Culture, 2022
Humanitarian agencies are relying more frequently on remote sensing, satellite imagery and social media to produce accounts of violence. Their analysis aims at creating more compelling narratives for the court of law or of public opinion and has contributed towards a forensic turn, thus complicating the already fraught relationship between the practice of witnessing and political subjects. This article explores how digital witnessing allows us to ‘see’ further and deeper into places that are at a distance from us, whilst at the same time creating the conditions that make certain subjects recede from view. I will discuss these issues in relation to a country I am familiar with and one that has been central to the forensic imagination – Pakistan – although the particular geographies within Pakistan that this imagination works with are not mine. Thinking with non-linear temporalities of violence, I explore how the forensic turn may have actually contributed to the erasure of the racial...
In the Wakes of Rodney King: Militant Evidence and Media Activism in the Age of Viral Black Death
The Velvet Light Trap, 2019
This essay explores the historical and critical legacy of the Rodney King tape, namely, it’s transformation of the concerns of the field of documentary studies in the turn toward “visible evidence” in the 1990s. This turn privileged the power of visibility, particularly in radical and activist practices, but visibility is a fraught concept for minority subjects. I argue for an approach called “militant evidence” as an expanded and updated framework for media activism and the use of visible evidence. In this formulation, accumulated visible evidence is deployed within larger media and activist ecologies toward an abolition of police violence.
"Whose Streets? Police Violence and the Recorded Image"
Arts, 2019
This essay reframes street photography in terms of the images and videos taken by bystanders who find themselves witness to egregious acts of state-sanctioned police violence against black and brown bodies in the United States. Along the way, it challenges the belief that bystanders are "innocent" observers and investigates the meaning of "evidence" and the role of representation in order to argue for a model of seeing that can simultaneously reveal moments of ongoing racial debilitation and work to create new political subjects capable of transformative collective action. The goal is twofold: (1) to disrupt a history of photography-and more specifically a history of street photography-that emphasizes innovation, biography, and universal experience; and (2) to reorient what it means to discuss the politics of the image (in particular, the digital "documentary" image) away from a discourse that either privileges "uncertainty" or understands images as empty simulations, and toward one that acknowledges representation's complexity but also its ongoing power. In the United States, we may never be able to tell a story in and about public space without replaying scenes of violence and targeted assault, but this essay argues that finding ways to let voices and images from the past-both tragic and redemptive-resonate in the present and speak to us in the future, may provide some way forward.
Ruth Somalo’s Abstract for the Brill publication Thamyris/Intersecting: Place, Sex and Race Online to be released over the summer of 2022 under the title: Toppling Things. The Visuality, Space and Affect of Monument Removal., 2022
Title: In search of an aesthetic of care: recording BLM protests and documenting one's life in a time of reckoning. Care can be defined as the serious attention or consideration applied to doing something correctly or to avoid damage or risk and the provision of what is necessary for the health, welfare, maintenance, and protection of someone or something. In order to define my production practice, at the recent Society for Cinema and Media Studies Conference I recently defined the changing role of the documentary producer as a "steward of care", which is not to be confused with any kind of humanitarian impulse. James Tompson's Towards an aesthetics of care locates the shape of a potential aesthetics of care "in the collision of professional practice, personal politics and domestic circumstances", an encounter that forces us to rethink the boundaries of our own practices, in my case a filmmaker, and activist, a researcher and a Spanish migrant in New York under a world pandemic. Auto-ethnography is a quickly growing field of creation in documentary, and in research in sociology, and anthropology, communications, psychology, and health sciences. Embracing the use of personal narrative and lived experience, I propose to look at the role of the footage collected during my participation in the Black Lives Matter Protest in 2020 New York, and how it operates in my most recent non fiction short films La flor triste (The sad Flower) and NY diary #3. The images we show are as important as the images we don't show. I do not show or address the footage of the police murders of George Floyd or Breonna Taylor as made public through social media, a gesture identified as "re-traumatizing" for people of color, especially when done by a white artist. In these work the object is not solely the collective trauma of the black community around me, but instead the representation of a persuasive mode of participatory resistance that has become transformational for its participants. The BLM protests became a political marker that continued a process to address my own privilege and status as a Spanish "white" immigrant in NY, but also to address the fact that I grew up in a post Franco Spain that has yet to reconcile its own history of state violence. The films can be understood as gestures
Say Their Names: Filmed Encounters Between Black Americans and the Police
There is a line of reasoning shared by police officials, police unions, legislators, and civil rights organizers that supposes that videos of the police behaving badly will naturally lead to reform. This is the logic that fuels expensive body camera programs, like the ones implemented by the NYPD, LAPD, and Department of Justice. However, the idea that surveillance in the hands of the state can be somehow emancipatory is laughable. To equate the footage of Rodney King or Eric Garner with footage taken from police cameras is to fundamentally misunderstand the nuance that images express. Existing social vulnerabilities migrate seamlessly into new technologies, and photography’s dominant mode is to reinforce, not resist, existing structures of power.
In the Wake of Visual Failure: Twitter, Sandra Bland, and an Anticipatory Nonspectatorship
Social Text, 2021
This article examines the role of the visual in instances of recorded anti-Black racial violence and pushes against dominant discourses of the technological rescue narrative— that technology and more visibility will lead to different outcomes of accountability, protection, and safety. Instead, this article argues that the tightly-bound association of anti-Black racial violence’s recognizability to the visual has created a dynamic that simultaneously moves us closer to and further away from its ontological truth. Examining Twitter as a multi-sensorial platform and its users’ imaginative engagements with the #IfIDieInPoliceCustody hashtag memorializing Sandra Bland’s death, the author identifies that users craft an anticipatory non-spectatorship, a mode of imaginative witnessing arising from the contexts of technological and visual failure and the situated imaginations of Black epistemologies. These users register a deep suspicion of the evidentiary and refuse the spectacular of racial violence’s visual form, instead highlighting its ubiquitous and quotidian nature by asserting themselves into their own scenes of visual failure and becoming witnesses to their own imagined deaths. Finally, in identifying the visual failures surrounding Sandra Bland’s jail cell, the author illuminates how the ontology of the glitch can demonstrate the mechanics of white supremacy’s operations.
History of Photography, 2022
In this article, we animate the interstitial practices shared by photojournalists and police officers, and sketch some of the stakes for visual practitioners ‘bearing witness while black’. We employ visual analyses of protest images by Black photographers while tracing the specific visual techniques of oversight mobilised by law enforcement. These include police departments’ co-optation of news images to identify and criminalise racial justice protesters alongside efforts to professionalise police officers into photographers. We theorise the anti-Black intersections shared across these expansive formations – policing and photojournalism – in an effort to account for the ways in which both systems maintain and invest in damaging visualities that shape consequences ‘on the ground’ for Black and brown communities.
In this article, we consider the power of the “Internet of things” and that of respectability policing. Our concern is the role of digital technologies in social stratification and neighborhood management. We begin by examining the use of ShotSpotter technology that provides audio detection of gunfire in (Black) neighborhoods and transmits the location of shots fired to police. We explore how ShotSpotter was used to investigate the murder of Janese Talton Jackson, becoming a tool of digital surveillance and discrimination in its monitoring of a Black community. We discuss how the discourse surrounding the murder of Jackson changed tenor from a most non-respectable, “just another” Black killing to a trending story upon the discovery that she was the sister of Ed Gainey, Pennsylvania House of Representatives (D). As such, in our article, we also take up the social construction of the non-respectability of Black womanhood and the effects of misogyny.