The second wave of hedge fund activism: The importance of reputation, clout, and expertise (original) (raw)
Related papers
Top Hedge Funds: The Importance of Reputation in Shareholder Activism
2015
We examine how hedge fund characteristics matters for announcement period returns. Using a large dataset of hand-collected information on post-financial-crisis activist interventions through mid-2014, we find that recent activism generates high and persistent announcement period returns: an average of more than 7% over the 21-day event window. These returns have persisted even as both the number of activists and their interventions have increased. But, intervening with large investments in large targets is significantly and positively related to announcement period returns, whereas intervening more frequently is negatively associated with announcement period returns. We develop a hedge fund reputation measure that is based on the size of investments in the recent past. The most reputed hedge funds have more assets under management, a longer track record of activism, a history of obtaining board seats, and invest in targets with the intent of making board changes. Top activists’ repu...
Myths and Realities of Hedge Fund Activism: Some Empirical Evidence
Forthcoming in Virginia Law & Business Review, 2012
The brand of shareholder activism associated with hedge funds is a highly topical, yet equally controversial issue. In this article, I provide a synthesis of the key issues surrounding the hedge fund activism phenomenon, many of which are unresolved or have become popularized notions. I focus on activist hedge fund campaigns outside the Unites States, about which little is still known. The empirical core of the study comprises a hand-collected dataset from press reports which contains 432 activist campaigns launched by 129 unique activist hedge funds across 17 countries between January 1, 2000 and December 31, 2010. This article casts doubt upon four aspects of the perceived dark side of hedge fund activism. Activist hedge funds are not short-term in focus, as some critics have claimed. Activist hedge funds do not often use equity decoupling techniques. They seldom seek control and despite all the press and attention lavished on hedge fund activism and its supposed evils in most cases are not mainly hostile to incumbent management.
Activist hedge fund success: The role of reputation
Strategic Management Journal, 2020
Activist hedge funds are the new breed of corporate raiders, yet we know little about how the management and board of target firms respond to activist investors. Using a behavioral perspective, we propose that an activist's reputation for being confrontational conveys information to the target company as to what they are likely to encounter in an activist campaign. To avoid the potential adverse consequences of engaging in such a contest, we propose and find that target companies are more likely to settle with an activist known for being confrontational. Our study contributes to corporate governance research by providing insight into the importance of the social context surrounding activist campaigns and the role of reputation in influencing how companies respond to activist investors.
Journal of Governance and Regulation
This paper examines the relationship between hedge fund activism and target firm performance, executive compensation, and executive wealth. It introduces a theoretical framework that describes the activism process as a sequence of discrete decisions. The methodology uses regression analysis on a matched sample based on firm size, industry, and market-to-book ratio. All regressions control for industry and year fixed effects. Schedule 13D Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) filings are the source for the statistical sample of hedge fund target firms. I supplement that data with target firm financial, operating, and share price information from the CRSP-COMPUSTAT merged database. Activist hedge funds target undervalued or underperforming firms with high profitability and cash flows. They do not avoid firms with powerful CEOs. Leverage, executive compensation, pay for performance and CEO turnover increase at target firms after the arrival of the activist hedge fund. Target firm ex...
Hedge Fund Activism, Corporate Governance, and Firm Performance
Journal of Finance, 2008
Using the first large-scale sample of hedge fund activism, from 2004-05, we show that activist hedge funds resemble value investors and that the announcement of hedge fund activism generates statistically significant abnormal returns, in the range of 5-7% for a 20-day window, with results that are robust for different buy-and-hold periods. Target firms have significantly lower market value relative to book value, and are profitable with strong operating cash flows.
The Game of 'Activist' Hedge Funds: Cui Bono?
SSRN Electronic Journal, 2015
This article aims to describe the contemporary objectives and tactics of activist hedge funds as well as the actions taken by the targeted companies as a result of their intervention. In this research, we explore the consequences of activism over time (impact on operational performance and share price returns) and compare these with a random sample of firms with similar characteristics at the time of intervention; we also analyse the singularities associated with salient subgroups of targeted firms. The sample used for our research consists of all 259 firms targeted by activist hedge funds in 2010 and 2011. We found evidence that any improvements in operating performance (return on assets, return on equity, Tobin's Q) result mainly from selling assets, cutting capital expenditures, buying back shares, reduce workforce and other basic financial manoeuvres. Although there is no evidence of deterioration over a 3-year period, the stock's performance of targeted companies over a 3-year span barely matches the performance of a random sample of companies. We found that the best way for activists to make money for their funds is to get the company sold off or substantial assets spun off. If not sold, the hedge fund episode often results for the targeted firms in change of senior management and board members, stagnation of assets and R&D. This research does not provide any evidence of the superior strategic sagacity of hedge fund managers, but does point to their keen understanding of what moves stock prices in the short term.
Activist Hedge Funds and the Corporation
2017
The long-term effects of hedge fund activism are controversial. Some empirical studies document that activism is associated with increased long-term firm value, suggesting that activists can better discipline management. Other studies, however, challenge these results, arguing that the incorporation of possible selection effects exposes activism as detrimental to long-term firm value. This Article contributes to this ongoing debate, producing novel empirical evidence on the relationship between activist campaigns, the financial value of firms, key governance arrangements, and corporate legal rules. We first document qualitative evidence that untargeted “control” firms sharing similar characteristics to targeted firms perform better in the long term than the target firms, and then show that hedge fund activism is associated with increased risk-taking but has no significant impact on managerial incentives. These combined findings Professor of Finance and Law. Mendoza College of Busi...
The Returns to Hedge Fund Activism
Financial Analysts Journal, 2008
Hedge fund activism is a new form of arbitrage. Using a large hand-collected data set from 2001 to 2006 we fi nd that activist hedge funds in the U.S. propose strategic, operational, and fi nancial remedies and attain success or partial success in two-thirds of the cases. The abnormal stock return upon announcement of activism is approximately seven percent, with no reversal during the subsequent year. Target fi rms experience increases in payout, operating performance, and higher CEO turnover after activism. We also fi nd large positive abnormal return to the self-reported hedge fund activists during our sample period. The abnormal return signifi cantly exceeds the returns to all hedge funds, the returns to equityoriented hedge funds and is robust to alternative risk adjustments and selection biases.
The Rise and Fall (?) of Shareholder Activism by Hedge Funds
SSRN Electronic Journal, 2000
Shareholder activism by hedge funds has over the past few years become a major corporate governance phenomenon. This paper puts the trend into context. The paper begins by distinguishing the "offensive" form of activism hedge funds engage in from "defensive" interventions "mainstream" institutional investors (e.g. pension funds or mutual funds) undertake. Variables infl uencing the prevalence of offensive shareholder activism are then identifi ed using a heuristic device we call "the market for corporate infl uence". The rise of hedge funds as practitioners of offensive shareholder activism is traced by reference to the "supply" and "demand" sides of this market, with the basic chronology being that, while there were direct antecedents of hedge fund activists as far back as the 1980s, hedge funds did not move to the activism forefront until the 2000s. The paper brings matters up-to-date by discussing the impact of the recent fi nancial crisis on hedge fund-driven shareholder activism and draws upon the market for corporate infl uence heuristic to predict future trends.