Designs of Soviet war monuments, 1941–1945: transformation of the memorial genre, the models, the visual language and its sources (original) (raw)

Summary

The article examines Soviet memorial designs of the Great Patriotic War period (1941–1945). These monuments were unorthodox in terms of visual language, and they differed strikingly from the Stalinist neoclassical mainstream of the previous decade. Architects tried to find means of commemoration of the enormous tragedy of war that they faced. Analysis of the poetics of their designs along with the commonplaces of the respective critical discourse reveals the process whereby the memorial genre was transformed. This article discusses the monumental tradition developed by the 1940 s, the models, the sources of motifs and solutions, and some stylistic and architectural peculiarities characteristic of wartime projects. Whereas previously the Soviet architects from the early 1930s had been working on the ‘ultimate’ monument – the Palace of Soviets in Moscow – with the beginning of the war they shifted to improvising in order to ‘stretch’ the limits of genre. I examine the ways in which they broke the limits and shaped the dense, overwhelming memorial narrative to be transmitted by the monuments. New memorials were considered as a form of heroic epic, analogous to the literary epics but expressed by means of architecture and sculpture. The nationalistic sentiments typical of the war years were reflected in both the design ideology and the perception of memorials. Alongside persistent motifs (such as 'prancing' tanks) emerged new themes (the commemoration of victims along with heroes). The technique of provoking the viewer’s emotions, as well as the visual language and architectural style of some structures and particular solutions (such as massive stone cubes), demonstrate the inheritance from the post-Revolutionary Modernist architecture. This unorthodox stylistic flexibility illustrates the ‘liberation’ of architects – and the short cultural ‘liberalization’ on the wartime period.

References

Afanas’ev, Kirill. 1944. Arkhitekturnye proekty na vystavke “Geroicheskii front i tyl” (Architectural designs at “The heroic front and home front” exhibition). In Arkhitektura SSSR 6. 29–33. Search in Google Scholar

Arkin, David. 1944. Monumenty geroiam Velikoi Otechestvennoi voiny. Zametki o konkurse (Monuments to the heroes of the Great Patriotic War. Some notes on the competition). In Arkhitektura SSSR 5. 3–11. Search in Google Scholar

Bakhareva, Iuila & Tamara Kovaleva (eds.). 2005. Arkhitektory blokadnogo Leningrada (Architects of the besieged Leningrad). St. Petersburg: NP-Print. Search in Google Scholar

Bass, Vadim. 2017. Monument: who controls the past. Ob odnom mekhanizme arkhitekturnoi kommemoratsii (The monument: who controls the past. On one mechanism of architectural commemoration). In Sotsiologiia vlasti 29(1). 122–155. 10.22394/2074-0492-2017-1-122-155 Search in Google Scholar

Cohen, Jean-Louis. 2011. Architecture in Uniform: Designing and Building for the Second World War. Canadian Centre for Architecture.Search in Google Scholar

Dobrenko, Evgenii. 2020. Pozdnii stalinizm: estetika politiki (Late Stalinism: the aesthetics of the politics). Moscow: Novoe Literaturnoe Obozrenie. 10.12987/yale/9780300198478.001.0001 Search in Google Scholar

Ehrenburg, Il’ia. 1945. Nastala rasplata (The retribution has come). In Krasnaia zvezda Jan. 31 (See: Krasnaia Armiia v logove fashistskogo zveria. Leningrad, 1945). Search in Google Scholar

Goldman, Natasha. 2006. Israeli Holocaust Memorial Strategies at Yad Vashem: From Silence to Recognition. In Art Journal 65, 2 (Summer). 102–122. Search in Google Scholar

Hollerbach, Erich. 1924. Lenin v monumental’nom iskusstve (Lenin in the monumental art). In O pamiatnike Leninu (On the Lenin memorial), 34–88. Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo. Search in Google Scholar

Il'in, Lev. 1924. Ob uvekovechenii Lenina (On immortalization of Lenin). In O pamiatnike Leninu (On the Lenin memorial), 95–104. Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo.Search in Google Scholar

Izakov, Boris. 1945. Tannenberg. Pravda, Jan. 29 (See: Krasnaia Armiia v logove fashistskogo zveria. Leningrad, 1945).Search in Google Scholar

Khiger, Roman. 1942. Monumenty otechestvennoi voiny (Monuments of the patriotic war). In Arkhitektura SSSR, 1. Search in Google Scholar

Khmel’nitskii, Dmitri. 2007. Arkhitektura Stalina. Psikhologiia i stil’ (Architecture of Stalin. Psychology and the style). Moscow: Progress-Traditsiia.Search in Google Scholar

Konkurs na sostavlenie proektov monumentov geroiam Velikoi Otechestvennoi voiny (Design competition for the monuments to the heroes of the Great Patriotic War). 1942. Moscow.Search in Google Scholar

Kosenkova, Iulia. 2000. Sovetskii gorod 1940-kh – pervoi poloviny 1950-kh godov: Ot tvorcheskikh poiskov k praktike stroitel’stva (The Soviet city of the 1940s – first half of the 1950s: from the creative search to the practice of construction). Moscow: URSS. Search in Google Scholar

Krasin, Leonid. 1924. Arkhitekturnoe uvekovechenie Lenina (Architectural commemoration of Lenin). In O pamiatnike Leninu (On the Lenin memorial), 23–33. Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo. Search in Google Scholar

Lasswell, Harold. 1938. Propaganda technique in the world war. New York: Peter Smith. Search in Google Scholar

Malinina, Tat’iana. 1978. Iz istorii sovetskoi arkhitektury 1941–1945 gg.: Dokumenty i materialy (Documents and materials on the history of the Soviet architecture of 1941–1945). Moscow: Nauka. Search in Google Scholar

Malinina, Tat’iana. 1991. Tema pamiati v arkhitekture voennykh let: po materialam konkursov i vystavok 1942–45 gg. (The theme of memory in architecture of the wartime period: on the materials of competitions and exhibitions of 1942–45). Moscow: NII teorii i istorii izobrazitel’nykh iskusstv. Search in Google Scholar

Matsa, Ivan. 1943. Pamiatniki geroiam (Monuments to the heroes). In Literatura i iskusstvo, Sept. 11.Search in Google Scholar

Ot redaktsii [Editorial]. 1940. In Arkhitektura Leningrada 4. 7–18. Search in Google Scholar

Pozharskii, A. 1945. Proekty tsentral’noi ploshchadi Stalingrada (k itogam konkursa) (Designs for the central square of Stalingrad: on the results of the competition). In Arkhitektura SSSR 11. 21–27. Search in Google Scholar

Sirvint, N. 1940. Pamiatniki na mestakh boev s belofinnami (The monuments at the fields of battles against the White Finns). In Arkhitektura SSSR 10. 50–53.Search in Google Scholar

Siuzor, Pavel. 1914. Rech’ ob okhrane pamiatnikov (The talk on the heritage preservation). In Arkhitekturno-khudozhestvennyi ezhenedel'nik 31. Search in Google Scholar

Vesnin, Viktor. 1937. Tvorcheskie voprosy (The creative issues). In Diskussiia na s’ezde (The debate at the congess). In Arkhitektura SSSR 7–8. 28–44.Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2021-06-11

Published in Print: 2021-06-26