FREE Karl Marx Vs Adam Smith Essay (original) (raw)

Looking at the beginnings of civilization, one can identify a common theme between all nations. This theme was and still is that these civilizations were structured and divided according to different powers, no matter it being social, economic, or political power. The perfect system for economics and society have been based on a wide array of ideas, ranging from Social Darwinism to needs of all human beings. Adam Smith and Karl Marx were individuals who held widely differing political views on their ideas of the perfect government. Adam Smith has been regarded as the father of modern day economics, and Karl Marx is regarded as the father of communism. .
One of Smiths dramatic conclusions was that people mainly acted out of their own self-interests, and if permitted to follow their own interests it created natural social harmony and economic productivity. According to The Wealth of Nations, a greater division of labor lead to a greater amount of productivity. With division of labor, the process of manufacturing is broken up and branched into its very basic parts, the worker performs one or two basic acts instead of multiple tasks. According to Adam Smith, the size of a particular market limits the divisions and size of a manufacturer, which means that the demand must be equal to or greater than the amount of product. Smith believed that social progress would result from free trade and a self-regulating economy. He stated that government should have a hands off policy when dealing with the economy. On the other hand Karl Marx had differing opinions on how the economy should be run.
Karl Marx's, Communist Manifesto unlike The Wealth of Nations opposed the idea of a free market economy and any form of economic competition. The Communist Manifesto had little impact when it was first published in 1848, but later it became one of the most revolutionary writings in the world and the basis of Marxism.

1. Karl marx vs. adam smith

These arguments began with the publication of The Wealth of Nations by Adam Smith in 1776. ... However, in 1848, a new idea called "Communism" comes up with The Communist Manifesto written by Karl Marx. ... In this essay, first of all, I will analyze these two texts to find out the differences and similarities between the ideas of Karl Marx and Adam Smith. ... In The Wealth of Nations, Adam Smith claimed that the governments should encourage entrepreneurs so as to increase the productivity. ... Capitalism and Communism that are firstly mentioned Adam Smith and Karl Marx respectively assigned...

2. Adam Smith vs. Karl Marx

Adam Smith vs. Karl Marx Both Adam Smith and Karl Marx are considered two of the top twenty most influential people in the world for the millennium. ... Adam Smith also theorized that the division of labor is the root of all opulence in civilization. ... It is clearly evident that Adam Smith and Karl Marx were two of the greatest men in the history of the world. ... They both wrote famous documents, Adam Smith's "The Wealth of Nations" and Karl Marx's "Communist Manifesto," which back up their theories for benefiting the society the best....

3. Adam smith VS carl marx

Adam Smith vs. Karl Marx Being reared in the typical capitalist community in the United States, it is much easier for me to relate to the thoughts of Adam Smith. ... My stance is clear: I believe that Adam Smith has the more credible stance. ... From my upbringing and my education, I believe that Adam Smith is correct is his beliefs and ideas. I believe that Marx is wrong in the points that I have described above. ...

4. Adam Smith vs. Karl Marks: The division of labor

On the Division of Labor Karl Marx and Adam Smith both realized that there have been benefits to the division of labor, but Marx believes that through strict specialization, a person is being individually hurt by being devoid of greater experiences. ... Smith states the now famous example of the pin makers. ... (Marx, 483) Even Smith states that people, when subjected to such mundane lines of work, will become stupid and ignorant. ... (Marx, 483) Smith believes that this can all be justified through the education of the working class. ... Just as Smith said, their minds will deter...

5. International Trade Protectioism

This idea originated with the influential British economist, philosopher, and author of The Wealth of Nations, Adam Smith. He inspired the writings of great economists such as David Ricardo, Karl Marx, Thomas Malthus, and others. According to Smith, specialization and trade is the best solution to create a flourishing American economy, with its industries ruling the economic world. ... Peterson, holder of the Lundy Chair of Business Philosophy at Campbell University, agrees with Smith's philosophy. ...

Got a writing question? Ask our professional writer!
Submit My Question