Winter fuel payments cut plan passes but PM faces revolt - how your MP voted (original) (raw)

Keir Starmer faced the biggest revolt of his premiership so far as MPs voted on the Government's decision to scrap winter fuel allowance for millions of pensioners

Video Loading

Video Unavailable

Starmer sees off backbench rebellion in winter fuel allowance vote

Keir Starmer has suffered a revolt over his controversial decision to axe winter fuel payments for millions of pensioners.

The PM won the vote in the Commons with a motion to cancel his plan defeated by 348 votes to 228 - a majority of 120. But some of his own MPs refused to back his decision to scrap winter fuel allowance for most OAPs amid a growing backlash.

Veteran left-winger Jon Trickett was the only Labour MP to rebel against the Government, along with the SNP, the Liberal Democrats and the Tories. No votes were recorded for 52 Labour MPs and it is understood around a dozen were not given permission to be absent.

The controversial plan to remove the £300 payment has faced criticism from charities and the public but it passed thanks to Labour's massive Commons majority.

Charity Age UK, which warned some 2.5million pensioners on low incomes could now miss out, said they were "deeply disappointed, but not surprised the vote to brutally means-test winter fuel payments was passed today". Charity director Caroline Abrahams said: "The reality is that driving through this policy as the Government is doing will make millions of poor pensioners poorer still and we are baffled as to why some Ministers are asserting that this is the right thing to do."

Keir Starmer faced the biggest revolt of his premiership so far (

Image:

PA)

Mr Starmer, who has admitted the move is unpopular, has resisted calls to rethink the cut for 10 million pensioners, or to tweak the eligibility for the £300 winter fuel payment. In the summer Chancellor Rachel Reeves announced the support would now be restricted to just OAPs on pension credit or other benefits. She said she was left with no other option after finding a £22billion black hole in the public finances left by the Tories.

MPs raised fierce criticism to the plan during a 90-minute debate in the Commons on Tuesday. Lib Dem spokeswoman for work and pensions Wendy Chamberlain said scrapping the winter fuel allowance for some pensioners is "simply wrong", while others shouted "shame" when the result was announced.

Jon Trickett, who was a shadow cabinet member during Jeremy Corbyn's leadership, was the one Labour MP to vote against the plan. After the vote he said: "I fear that removing the payment from pensioners will mean that many more will fall into poverty this winter. We know that the consequences of pensioner poverty are devastating. It can even be a matter of life and death. I have worked behind the scenes to try and change the Government's position, but to no avail. I could not in good conscience vote to make my constituents poorer. I will sleep well tonight know that I voted to defend my constituents."

Ahead of the vote, Money Saving Expert founder, Martin Lewis, who was due to meet the Chancellor on Tuesday, said he was confident there would be no Government U-turn on the issue. But he said a number of Labour MPs had privately asked him to attempt to change Ms Reeves's mind.

He told Times Radio: "I cannot tell you the look in the eyes, many of those MPs, when it was talked about, I was going to meet Rachel Reeves, which I'm doing later this afternoon, and there was a sort of look, and it was very plain, they were going, oh, I hope you manage to change her mind." He added: "I find it very fascinating, because many of the new Labour MPs are totally torn, they want to be loyal, they want to stick with the whip, they want to do the right thing, they want to go with the party. But they have their buttocks clenched about supporting this policy."

US ELECTION WHATSAPP: Join our US Election WhatsApp group here to be first to get all the biggest news and results as America heads to the polls. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don’t like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you’re curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.

POLITICS WHATSAPP: Be first to get the biggest bombshells and breaking news by joining our Politics WhatsApp group here. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don’t like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you’re curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.

NEWSLETTER: Or sign up here to the Mirror's Politics newsletter for all the best exclusives and opinions straight to your inbox.

PODCAST: And listen to our exciting new political podcast The Division Bell, hosted by Mirror interim political editor Lizzy Buchan and Express political editor Sam Lister, every Thursday.

Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds claimed Labour had "no choice" but to cut the winter fuel payment. He also rejected suggestions the controversial decision could see some die of cold this winter. Asked whether ministers accepted this was a possibility, he told the BBC: "No. We are making sure that we can reassure people by saying the state pension is higher than last winter and energy bills are lower than last winter."

Earlier this week it emerged Labour's own research from 2017 found cutting the winter fuel allowance would increase excess deaths by 3,850 that winter. They published their findings in a warning to the then-Tory government - a warning that has now come back to haunt their own Government.

Pensioners who are worried about losing the help have been urged to check if they are eligible for other benefits. It is estimated that 880,000 people who are entitled to pension credit don't claim it. The Government launched a week of action to raise awareness and call on everyone who is eligible to sign up. This will ensure they don't miss out on Winter Fuel Payments.

'I'd have to watch more closely how long I had my heating on'

Pensioner Dixie Janes described the decision to axe winter fuel payments for millions of OAPs as a "bit of a shock".

The 84-year-old former secretary worker says she is not eligible for pension credit and will no longer receive the £300 winter fuel payment as a result of the government changes. Over the last couple of years, Dixie said she the costs for "everything" - including her energy bills and food shops - had surged.

She said her reaction to the announcement to means-test the winter fuel payments was "disappointment, and worry I suppose,that I'd have to watch more closely how long I had my heating on". She told The Mirror: "Well it is a bit of a worry because if we got a really, really cold spell, then you have to have the heating on all the time.

Pensioner Dixie Janes said the removal of the support was a 'bit of a shock'

"At the moment, I ration it, and I only have it on for an hour in the morning and an hour and half in the evening - two and a half hours a day. But obviously if it's bitterly cold it has to go on more and that money was just sort of a comfort blanket."

Dixie, who lives in a social housing bungalow, added: "I'm not like most of my contemporaries, who have paid off their mortgages and are more comfortably off. I live in social housing and pay rent - that rent is a big chunk out of my pension - so it is more important for someone like me who is paying rent to receive the fuel allowance."