Did Scotland invent the cocktail? 15th century creation puts spotlight on early drinks (original) (raw)

Food and Drink

Did the Scots invent the first cocktail? A 15th century oat and whisky drink could be the first mixed drink and it is resonating with modern-day bartenders as more customers look for flavour-forward, local creations.

Published 13th May 2026, 15:07 BST

A 15th century Highland drink is putting Scotland back into the conversation around the origins of cocktails, with a discussion around Atholl Brose potentially being one of earliest recorded examples of mixing spirits with local ingredients.

Made from oats, honey and whisky, Atholl Brose dates back to at least the 1400s, placing it centuries before many recognised classics. While there is no clear agreement on the world’s first cocktail, its place in recorded history makes it one of the earliest known examples of a whisky-based mixed drink.

Sign up to The Scotsman Whisky Club here for monthly news, reviews, interviews and exclusive discounts

The drink is tied to Scottish legend. It is said the Earl of Atholl created a honeyed oat and whisky mixture to lure a rebel into capture, leaving behind a recipe that became associated with Highland hospitality and celebration.

The example highlights how early “cocktails” were not created in bars, but evolved from necessity, using ingredients that were readily available, with Scotland’s agricultural staples directly shaping what people drank.

Port Charlotte Atholl Brose | contributed

While this is an old, mixed drink, food historian Peter Gilchrist said: “Whisky has always straddled the world of medicine, ritual and recreation in Scotland. It is believed that whisky making was first introduced to the country by monasteries, who produced "aqua-vitae" as a health tonic.

“It's likely that "bitters" were developed at this time, using herbs and plants to fortify early whiskies with medicinal benefits. These were often very bitter and drank in the morning. Some old bitters recipes still exist today, although they're far from a cocktail that you'd want to sip on a summer evening.

“I believe Atholl Brose represents a shift towards Scots drinking whisky for pleasure; we need to remember that the craft of whisky making was still relatively new in the 15th century and was largely dominated by women who distilled bottles of whisky as part of their weekly housekeeping duties.

“Home distilling can often lead to stronger, harsher whiskies, and the act of "ageing" whisky to develop flavours didn't become popular until the Victorian era. The sweetness from honey and the "oat milk" brose would have balanced the palate, transforming home-made raw moonshine into a refreshing celebratory drink.

“It's difficult to say if Atholl Brose is the first ‘whisky cocktail’ with confidence, but it has been served at Scottish parties for over half a millennium; it's about time it had another moment!”

Regardless of whether it is indeed the first cocktail to be made here, its history is inspiring producers including Bruichladdich Distillery to revisit historic serves like Atholl Brose, reflecting a wider shift towards flavour-forward drinks rooted in provenance, authenticity and raw ingredients; echoing how these drinks were originally made, using what was available rather than formalised recipes.

Abi Clephane | contributed

Cocktail expert Abi Clephane, of Bruichladdich Distillery, said: “There’s so much debate around what the first cocktail was, but there’s no doubt Atholl Brose was one of the earliest, going back to at least the 15th century.

“The word cocktail came much later, but the act of mixing drinks didn’t. People have always done that. As soon as there were ingredients, people were combining them to make something better to drink.

Across Scotland, those early mixed drinks were shaped by what was to hand, from oats and honey to grain spirits, rather than formal recipes or techniques.

Peter Gilchrist | contributed

Ms Clephane explained: “In Scotland, you’re talking about oats, honey and grain spirits, that’s what people had. So that’s what went into drinks like Atholl Brose.

“It wasn’t about following a recipe or making something fashionable, it was just using what was there. That’s really where cocktails come from, making something enjoyable out of what you’ve got around you.

“It used to take a long time to make, because you had to make your own oat milk from scratch. Now you can just buy it and put it together in minutes. It’s probably easier than it’s ever been, which means there’s no reason people can’t try it again.

“When you look at something like Atholl Brose, it shows Scotland has been mixing drinks for centuries. It just hasn’t been talked about in the same way, but the history is there.

“Designed to be enjoyed after dinner, the cocktail leans into indulgent dessert-style flavours and is best sipped slowly as a final course.”

That approach can also be seen in other historic Scottish serves like the Hot Toddy, a centuries-old mix of whisky, honey, citrus and spices traditionally used for medicinal purposes, but often considered a less serious cocktail despite fitting the definition.

Scotland’s absence from the modern cocktail narrative is often attributed to how whisky has historically been positioned, with strict conventions limiting experimentation compared to other spirits. This is thankfully now changing.

Ms Clephane said: “Scotch whisky’s been quite gatekept in terms of how you drink it. There’s always been rules around it, whether that’s neat, with water or with ice, so there hasn’t been as much room for mixing it in the same way.

“A lot of the classic cocktails people think of are American whiskey-led, and they came from a different drinking culture. That’s probably why Scotland doesn’t get spoken about in the same way.”