UTC 84/ L2 181 Minutes (original) (raw)

L2/00-187R

Approved Minutes of the UTC 84 / L2 181 Joint Meeting

Boston, MA -- August 8-11, 2000

November 8, 2000

Number of members in good standing as of this meeting: 20, number of members in regular attendance: 18, Quorum: 9.

PRESENT: Apple Computer (by proxy); Basis Technology; Compaq Computer; Hewlett-Packard Company; IBM Corporation; Justsystem; Microsoft Corporation; NCR Corporation; Peoplesoft; Progress Software; Sybase, Inc.; Unisys Corporation.

NOT PRESENT: Government of India, MIT; Hyperion Solutions; Oracle, Inc.; RLG; Reuters LTD.; SAP AG; Sun Microsystems; Xerox Corporation

Total members represented: 12, Total not represented: 8

Calendar Updates

UTC 85/L2 182 - November 7-10, 2000_,_ San Diego, host NCR
UTC 86/L2 183 - January 29 - February 1, 2001_,_ Cupertino, host IBM
UTC 87/L2 184 - May 21- 24, 2001, Pleasanton, host Peoplesoft
UTC 88/L2 185 - August 7-10, 2001_,_ Seattle, host Microsoft
Calendar details posted at www.unicode.org/unicode/timesens/calendar.html

UTC 83/L2 180 Minutes

[84-M1] Motion: Approve the minutes of UTC 83/L2 180 after incorporating feedback received at the meeting. [L2/00-115R]

Moved by Mike Ksar, seconded by Murray Sargent

10 for (Basis, Compaq, HP, IBM, Justsystem, Microsoft, NCR, Peoplesoft, Sybase, Unisys)
0 against
2 abstain (Apple, Progress)

Action Item Review

[84-A1] Action Item for Ken Whistler:Document character rejections from this and the previous meeting.

[84-A2] Action Item for Murray Sargent:Add descriptive text for the math proposal that can be used in publication of the Standard. We need to know how the math characters should be used in practice, any systematic relationships, and the use of other characters with the math property that won't be in the math block.

UTC Membership Roll Call Adjustment

NOT PRESENT: Progress Software no longer present.

Total members represented: 11; Total not represented: 9

Normalization - Test Suite

[84-M2] Motion: Add the Normalization Test Suite to the Unicode Character Database, with the file to be included in the Unicode 3.0.1 update, make associated changes to UAX#15, Unicode Normalization Forms, in particular to the conformance clause.

Moved by Mark Davis, seconded by Sandra Martin O'Donnell

10 for (Basis, Compaq, HP, IBM, Justsystem, Microsoft, NCR, Peoplesoft, Sybase, Unisys)
0 against
1 abstain (Apple)

[84-A3] Action Itemfor Mark Davis:Add explanatory text to UAX#15, Unicode Normalization Forms to explain the use of the test suite and the associated conformance clause changes.

UTC Membership Roll Call Adjustment

PRESENT: Progress Software now present.

Total members represented: 12; Total not represented: 8

Character Foldings

[84-A4] Action Itemfor Asmus Freytag:Complete the table given in the Character Foldings proposal, L2/00-261, and make suggested updates including the rationale section.

Normalization - Quick Check

[84-C1] Consensus: Incorporate the QuickCheck data and routine into UAX#15, Unicode Normalization Forms. Update section 8 and note that the file is informative. [L2/00-263]

[84-A5] Action Itemfor Mark Davis:Update section 8 of UAX#15, Unicode Normalization Forms to describe the QuickCheck routine.

Character Mapping Tables

[84-A6] Action Itemfor Mark Davis:Schedule an Ad Hoc UTC meeting during the September IUC to discuss character mapping issues.

Bidi

[84-M3] Motion: The UTC accepts the data file of mirrored characters as an informative file to be added to the Unicode Character Database with the file to be included in the Unicode 3.0.1 update. Incorporate the comments received during the meeting and have a final review by the editorial committee. [L2/00-236]

Moved by Mark Davis, seconded by V. S. Umamaheswaran

11 for (Apple, Basis, Compaq, HP, IBM, Justsystem, Microsoft, Peoplesoft, Progress, Sybase, Unisys)
0 against
1 abstain (NCR)

[84-A7] Action Itemfor Mark Davis:Change the name of the mirrored character data file to _BidiMirroring.txt_and incorporate the other changes suggested during the discussion. [L2/00-236]

[84-M4] Motion: The UTC accepts two changes to UTR#9, The Bidirectional Algorithm, for sections 3.12 and 4.7, regarding higher level protocols and mirroring, to be included in Unicode 3.0.1 after final review by the editorial committee. [L2/00-154]

Moved by Mark Davis, seconded by Asmus Freytag

10 for (Apple, Basis, Compaq, IBM, Justsystem, Microsoft, Peoplesoft, Progress, Sybase, Unisys)
0 against
2 abstain (HP, NCR)

[84-A8] Action Itemfor Editorial Committee:Incorporate the two changes to _UTR#9, The Bidirectional Algorithm_into Unicode 3.0.1, and include with the list of errata. [L2/00-154]

August 9, 2000

PRESENT: Apple Computer (by proxy); Basis Technology; Compaq Computer; Hewlett-Packard Company; IBM Corporation; Justsystem; Microsoft Corporation; NCR Corporation; Peoplesoft; Sybase, Inc.; Unisys Corporation.

NOT PRESENT: Government of India, MIT; Hyperion Solutions; Oracle, Inc.; Progress Software; RLG; Reuters LTD.; SAP AG; Sun Microsystems; Xerox Corporation

Total members represented: 11, Total not represented: 9

WG2 - 10646 Part 1

[84-A9] Action Item for Arnold Winkler: Update the L2 page with the SC2 user id and password.

[84-A10] Action Item for Ken Whistler and Asmus Freytag: Create a list of all repertoire additions to 10646 Part 1 with glyphs.

[84-A11] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Create a WG2 proposal summary form for the new terminal graphics characters and for THAANA LETTER NAA in time for the WG2 meeting. [L2/00-255]

[84-M5] Motion: The UTC accepts the code points and character names for new characters as documented in L2/00-255 as modified with the addition of THAANA LETTER NAA.

Moved by Ken Whistler, seconded by Mark Davis

11 for (unanimous)

[84-A12] Action Itemfor Ken Whistler: Produce a modified version of L2/00-255 which contains the Unicode accepted characters which have not yet been proposed to WG2 (will include THAANA LETTER NAA, terminal graphic characters, and the word joiner) so that the 10646 editor may easily make comparisons.

[84-A13] Action Item for Lisa Moore: Respond to WG2 on the UTC position on additional Georgian characters. [L2/99-082]

[84-A14] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Send Lisa the e-mail trail on the additional Georgian characters.

[84-A15] Action Item for Asmus Freytag: The UTC instructs its WG2 liaison to postpone discussion of new scripts other than Philippine which the UTC has accepted. [L2/00-235]

[84-A16] Action Item for Editorial Committee: Prepare an erratum to the notation section of Unicode 3.0, to incorporate the notation for Unique Sequence Identifiers for combining characters include in 3.0.1. [L2/00-150R]

[84-A17] Action Item for Asmus Freytag: The UTC instructs its WG2 liaison to support the notation for Unique Sequence Identifiers at the September meeting. [L2/00-235]

UTC Membership Roll Call Adjustment

PRESENT: Progress Software now present.

Total members represented: 12; Total not represented: 8

[84-A18] Action Item for Asmus Freytag: The UTC instructs its WG2 liaison to support a new ordering of Korean characters through collation (by using ISO 14651) and a request for new names for Korea characters through the use of annotations. [L2/00-229]

Not a Character

[84-M6] Motion:Not a Character has the following characteristics:

• they are not to be publicly transmitted
• they can be deleted without an impact of the interpretation of the text
• they should be removed in normalization
• their presence may also indicate corrupted text. Moved by Mark Davis, seconded by Michel Suignard

10 for (Apple, Basis, HP, IBM, Justsystem, Microsoft, NCR, Peoplesoft, Sybase, Unisys)
0 against
2 abstain (Compaq, Progress)

[84-M7] Motion: Give the code point range FDD0..FDEF Not a Character status. Moved by Asmus Freytag, seconded by Michel Suignard

9 for (Apple, Basis, HP, IBM, Microsoft, NCR, Peoplesoft, Sybase, Unisys)
0 against
3 abstain (Compaq, Justsystem, Progress)

[84-A19] Action Itemfor Michel Suignard: Create a document proposing to WG2 to add the range FDD0..FDEF to 10646-1, clause 8.

[84-A20 Action Item for Ken Whistler: Add the FDD0..FDEF not a character range to the pipeline document on the web.

[84-A21] Action Item for Editorial Committee: Create not a character errata for Unicode 3.0.1 (p. 28 Special Non-character Values, p. 38, and any other appropriate places, but do not add the FDD0..FDEF range until after the September 2000, WG2 meeting.

[84-A22] Action Item for Ken Whistler: Update the property files for the FDD0..FDEF range but delay posting until after V3.0.1.

WG2 - 10646 Part 2

[84-A23] Action Item for Lisa Moore: Have John Jenkins ask Cora Chang to verify the mappings for the TCA compatibility character extension. The verification needs to be done by the end of the first week of September. [L2/00-169]

August 10, 2000

PRESENT: Apple Computer (by proxy); Basis Technology; Compaq Computer; Hewlett-Packard Company; IBM Corporation; Justsystem; Microsoft Corporation; NCR Corporation; Peoplesoft; Progress Software; Sybase, Inc.; Unisys Corporation.

NOT PRESENT: Government of India, MIT; Hyperion Solutions; Oracle, Inc.; RLG; Reuters LTD.; SAP AG; Sun Microsystems; Xerox Corporation

Total members represented: 12, Total not represented: 8

Internationalized Domain Names

[84-M8] Motion: Endorse the model for determining character acceptability as given in paper L2/00-215 and convene and ad hoc meeting to determine what will be the definition of the filtering and folding for Internationalized Domain Names. Note that [L2/00-217 is the requirements document.

Moved by Asmus Freytag, seconded by Sandra Martin O'Donnell

12 for (unanimous)

[84-A24] Action Itemfor Lisa Moore: Ask Rick McGowan to set up an e-mail list for the IDN discussion, contact Paul Hoffman (to chair), and invite others to participate. [L2/00-215]

WG2 - 10646 Part 2

[84-M9] Motion: The UTC accepts the 527 CNS compatibility ideographs for encoding on Plane 2, starting at F800, following the encoding given in the FCD with the holes removed and closed up. [L2/00-169]

Moved by Mike Ksar, seconded by V.S. Umamaheswaran

11 for (Apple, Basis, HP, IBM, Justsystem, Microsoft, NCR, Peoplesoft, Progress, Sybase, Unisys)
0 against
1 abstain (Compaq)

Grapheme Joiner

[84-M10] Motion: The UTC accepts the COMBINING GRAPHEME JOINER with a suggested code point assignment of U+0363. The COMBINING GRAPHEME JOINER will be used to indicate that the adjacent character(s) are part of a single grapheme in terms of grapheme production. It will behave in general like a virama and for line breaking, it will behave like a glue character. It will be a combining mark with a canonical class of zero. The UTC discourages its use for graphical effects, such as for circled numbers. [L2/00-156]

Moved by Mark Davis, seconded by Tex Texin

10 for (Basis, Compaq, HP, IBM, Microsoft, NCR, Peoplesoft, Progress, Sybase, Unisys)
1 against (Apple)
1 abstain (Justsystem)

[84-A25] Action Itemfor Mark Davis: Prepare a WG2 proposal summary form and a cover sheet for the combining grapheme joiner as input to the WG2 meeting in September. [L2/00-156]

[84-A26] Action Itemfor Ken Whistler: Add the combining grapheme joiner to the pipeline on the web. [L2/00-156]

SQL Character Syntax

[84-A27] Action Itemfor Arnold Winkler: Communicate with the SQL working group about establishing a liaison with L2/Unicode. [L2/00-184]

[84-A28] Action Itemfor Editorial Committee: Correct the terminology used on the Unicode web site (particularly in the Technical Introduction) based on the confusion in terms noted in Appendix B of L2/00-184.

[84-A29] Action Itemfor Toby Phipps: Include the issues raised in L2/00-184 in the TR on using Unicode in databases.

Variation Selector

[84-M11] Motion: Change the previous approval of U+2063 VARIATION SELECTOR to amend the name to VARIATION SELECTOR 1 and the suggested encoding to U+FE00, and adjust the proposed encodings in the math symbols proposal accordingly.

Moved by Ken Whistler, seconded by Asmus Freytag

11 for (Apple, Basis, Compaq, IBM, Justsystem, Microsoft, NCR, Peoplesoft, Progress, Sybase, Unisys)
0 against
1 abstain (HP)

[84-30] Action Itemfor Ken Whistler: Update the pipeline document on the web with the new information on VARIATION SELECTOR 1 and include the changes in name and location in the final math proposal which will be sent to WG2.

Unicode Character Properties

[84-31] Action Itemfor Editorial Committee: Add comments to the Unidata file that properties have been updated for V3.0.1.

Erratum in C1 Control Characters

[84-32] Action Itemfor Editorial Committee: Control code erratum - remove the glyph at 0084. [L2/00-264]

[84-33] Action Itemfor Ken Whistler: Fix the nameslist - remove the alias given for 0084. [L2/00-264]

Technical Report Status Language

[84-34] Action Itemfor Mark Davis: Update the status language for technical reports, including new language for proposed and draft proposed TRs. [L2/00-269]

August 11, 2000

PRESENT: Apple Computer (by proxy); Basis Technology; Compaq Computer; Hewlett-Packard Company; IBM Corporation; Microsoft Corporation; NCR Corporation; Progress Software; Sybase, Inc.; Unisys Corporation.

NOT PRESENT: Government of India, MIT; Hyperion Solutions; Justsystem; Oracle, Inc.; Peoplesoft; RLG; Reuters LTD.; SAP AG; Sun Microsystems; Xerox Corporation

Total members represented: 10, Total not represented: 10

UTR#20 Unicode in Markup Languages

[84-M12] Motion: Advance _Draft UTR#20: Unicode in XML and other Markup Languages_to UTR#20: Unicode in XML and other Markup Languages. [L2/00-266]

Moved by Mike Ksar, seconded by V.S. Umamaheswaran

10 for (Unanimous)

[84-35] Action Itemfor Asmus Freytag: Update UTR#20: Unicode in XML and other Markup Languages. and forward to W3C for their discussion. [L2/00-266]

[84-36] Action Itemfor Editorial Committee: Review the final results from W3C on_UTR#20: Unicode in XML and other Markup Languages_. Make editorial updates as appropriate and forward major changes to the UTC for its approval. [L2/00-266]

UTC Membership Roll Call Adjustment

PRESENT: Justsystem, Peoplesoft now present

Total members represented: 12; Total not represented: 8

Math Alphanumeric Characters

[84-C2] Consensus:UTR#20: Unicode in XML and other Markup Languages will be updated with the math alphanumeric characters when they are added to the standard in V3.1. [L2/00-240, 250, 251, 271]

[84-M13] Motion: Assign the math alphanumeric characters in Plane 1 the general category property of Symbol Other. [L2/00-266]

Moved by Mark Davis, seconded by Lisa Moore

1 for (Apple)
6 against (Basis, HP, Microsoft, NCR, Sybase, Unisys)
5 abstain (Compaq, IBM, Justsystem, Peoplesoft, Progress)

[84-M14] Motion: Assign the math alphanumeric characters in Plane 1 the general category property of Lu, Ll, Nd as appropriate, and give them compatibility equivalents using the tag, consistent with the existing letterlike symbols. [L2/00-240, 250, 251, 271]
Moved by Asmus Freytag, seconded by Ken Whistler

8 for (Basis, HP, Justsystem, Microsoft, NCR, Progress, Sybase, Unisys)
1 against (Apple)
3 abstain (Compaq, IBM, Peoplesoft)

[84-M15] Motion: Add to the identifier syntax in V3.0.1 the following note: A useful set of characters to consider for exclusion from identifiers consists of all characters whose compatibility mappings have a tag.
Moved by Asmus Freytag, seconded by Ken Whistler

12 for (unanimous)

[84-37] Action Itemfor Editorial Committee: Add to the errata documented in V3.0.1: A useful set of characters to consider for exclusion from identifiers consists of all characters whose compatibility mappings have a tag.

Komi Cyrillic

[84-C3] Consensus: The UTC agrees in principle with adding new characters to support Komi Cyrillic, but thinks there needs to be further opportunity for review. The UTC also would like to see the three columns at 0500, 0510, and 0520 used for encoding additional Cyrillic characters. [L2/00-182]

[84-38] Action Itemfor Asmus Freytag: The UTC instructs its liaison to relay its position that it agrees in principle with adding additional Cyrillic characters to support Komi Cyrillic, but would like to see further opportunity for review. [L2/00-182]

[84-39] Action Itemfor Asmus Freytag: The UTC instructs its liaison that it would like to see the roadmap updated with a new Cyrillic block at the columns 0500, 0510, 0520.

UTC Membership Roll Call Adjustment

NOT PRESENT: HP, Progress no longer present

Total members represented: 10; Total not represented: 10

W3C Liaison Report

[84-M16] Motion: Communicate to the W3C that math alphanumerics encoded in Plane 1 can be used as data in markup languages; there is no consensus at UTC as to whether the math alphanumerics should be used in tags and attributes. Furthermore, NL, LS, and PS should all be treated the same as CR and LF in parsing documents.

Moved by Mark Davis, seconded by Ken Whistler

9 for (Basis, Compaq, IBM, Justsystem, Microsoft, NCR, Peoplesoft, Sybase, Unisys)
0 against
1 abstain (Apple)

[84-40] Action Itemfor Mark Davis: The UTC instructs its liaison to relay to the W3C I18N working group that when working with different versions of the Unicode Standard, there could be a problem for the schema spec when using patterns. If one wants a precise value that doesn't change, use an explicit list.

Unicode Policies on Encoding Characters

[84-41] Action Itemfor Mark Davis: Based on the feedback received at the meeting, update the document on Unicode character encoding policies. [L2/00-268]

[84-42] Action Itemfor Editorial Committee: Review the final document on Unicode character encoding policies and post on the web. [L2/00-268]

UTC Membership Roll Call Adjustment

PRESENT: HP, Progress are now present

Total members represented: 12; Total not represented: 8

Script Names

[84-M17] Motion: Advance Proposed Draft UTR#24: Script Names to Draft UTR#24: Script Names. [L2/00-275] Moved by Ken Whistler, seconded by Murray Sargent

11 for (Apple, Basis, Compaq, HP, IBM, Justsystem, Microsoft, Peoplesoft, Progress, Sybase, Unisys)
0 against
1 abstain (NCR)

[84-43] Action Itemfor Mark Davis: Update Proposed Draft UTR#24: Script Names to reflect its change in status to Draft UTR#24: Script Names. [L2/00-275]

Handling Surrogates

[84-44] Action Itemfor Editorial Committee: Pull out appropriate text from L2/00-262 on handling surrogates and create a FAQ.