Message 108163 - Python tracker (original) (raw)

Whatever is done, I think a bytearray should be handled the same as bytes. It must be that they give the same result. In basic operations, I believe that bytearrays can always substitute for bytes. "Bytes and bytearray objects contain single bytes – the former is immutable while the latter is a mutable sequence." For example:

b'abc'.capitalize() b'Abc' bytearray(b'abc').capitalize() bytearray(b'Abc')

This, to me, implies that .fromstring should accept bytearray (though probably not general buffer objects). In 2.x, I understand .fromstring to initialize an array from machine bytes read into a string, but not .fromunicode. This is not a text method, and the result may vary for 2 and 4-byte unicode builds. So I can see that 3.x needs .fromstring(bytes) but not .fromunicode(string).