[Python-Dev] Remove HTTP 0.9 support (original) (raw)

Senthil Kumaran orsenthil at gmail.com
Thu Dec 16 09:14:04 CET 2010

On Wed, Dec 15, 2010 at 02:20:54PM -0800, Glenn Linderman wrote:

On 12/15/2010 10:39 AM, Antoine Pitrou wrote: I would like to remove HTTP 0.9 support from http.client and http.server. I've opened an issue at http://bugs.python.org/issue10711 for that. Would anyone think it's a bad idea?

(HTTP 1.0 was devised in 1996) Please address the following comment from the server.py source: # The default request version. This only affects responses up until # the point where the request line is parsed, so it mainly decides what # the client gets back when sending a malformed request line. # Most web servers default to HTTP 0.9, i.e. don't send a status line. defaultrequestversion = "HTTP/0.9" What do you mean by "address"? The patch changes this to 1.0. And, as the comment says, this only affects what happens when the client sends a syntactically invalid request line, so whether the server does a 0.9-style or 1.0-style response is unimportant.

Just what you did... justify the unimportance of not changing it :) Since now it is different than "most web servers".

+1 to removing HTTP 0.9 related code in http.client and http.server.

Until today, I hadn't cared to read any details of HTTP 0.9 except that I knew that some code was present in http library to support it. Reading a bit about the HTTP 0.9 'Internet Draft' written 1991 is enough to convince that, if we have to fall back on any old behavior falling back to HTTP 1.0 is perfectly fine.

Regarding this comment

Most web servers default to HTTP 0.9, i.e. don't send a status line.

Even HTTP 0.9 says that response SHOULD start with status line, but gives a suggestion that clients can "tolerate" bad server server behaviors when they don't send the status line and in that the case response is the body.

http://www.w3.org/Protocols/HTTP/Response.html

So, It cannot be associated with the behavior "most webservers", back then and even more so now.

-- Senthil

More information about the Python-Dev mailing list