Section Index (original) (raw)

Issue

Status

Section

Title

Proposed Resolution

Priority

Duplicates

63

New

X [fs.op.file_size]

Enable efficient retrieval of file size from directory_entry

Yes

68

New

X 8 [class.path]

path::operator+= is defined, but not operator+

Yes

74

New

X 8.5 [path.itr]

Bidirectional iterator requirement on path::iteratoris very expensive

Yes

73

New

X 15.33 [fs.op.status]

status() effects cannot be implemented as specified

Yes

72

New

X 15.19 [fs.op.is_empty]

Should is_empty use error_code in its specification?

Yes

69

New

X 14.1 [rec.dir.itr.members] ¶39

recursive_directory_iterator effects refers to non-existent functions

Yes

70

New

X 15.36 [fs.op.system_complete]

system_complete refers to undefined variable 'base'

Yes

71

New

X 15.3 [fs.op.copy]

Errors in Copy

Yes

64

New

X 8.4.3 [8.4.3], 8.6 [path.non-member]

operator / (and other append) semantics not useful if argument has root

No

65

New

X 4.8.5 [path.modifiers.remove_filename]

remove_filename() post condition is incorrect

Yes

66

New

X throughout

Bitmask operations should use bitmask terms

No

67

New

X 8.4.9 [path.decompose]

path::root_directory() description is confusing

Yes

11

[NAD Future](active.html#NAD Future)

X 6 & 15

[PDTS] Lack of relative() operation function

Yes

54

[NAD Future](active.html#NAD Future)

X all

[PDTS] Concerns with security and testability

Yes

12

[NAD Future](active.html#NAD Future)

X [fs.filesystem.synopsis], [fs.op.file_size]

[PDTS] uintmax_t too small for large file sizes

Yes

5

WP

X 8.1 [path.generic]

[PDTS] Parent of root directory unspecified

Yes

22

WP

X 13.1 [directory_iterator.members]

[PDTS] directory_iterator underspecified

Yes

25

WP

X 15.4 [fs.op.copy_file]

[PDTS] Copying equivalent paths effects not specified

Yes

27

WP

X 15.14 [fs.op.file_size]

[PDTS] Return value of uintmax_t on error?

Yes

34

WP

X 6 [fs.filesystem.synopsis]

[PDTS] enum class directory_options has no summary

Yes

35

WP

X 6 [fs.filesystem.synopsis]

[PDTS] directory_options::skip_permission_denied is not used

Yes

36

WP

X 10.2 [enum.copy_options]

[PDTS] copy_options::copy_symlinks is not used

Yes

37

WP

X 15.2 [fs.op.canonical]

[PDTS] All functions with error_code arguments should be noexcept

Yes

40

WP

X 12 [class.directory_entry]

[PDTS] class directory_entry should retain operator const path&() from V2

Yes

41

WP

X 13 [class.directory_iterator]

[PDTS] directory_iterator, recursive_directory_iterator, move construct/assign should be noexcept

Yes

45

WP

X 15.7 [fs.op.create_directory]

[PDTS] create_directory should refer to perms::all instead of PosixS_IRWXU|S_IRWXG|S_IRWXO

Yes

48

WP

X 8.4.6 [path.native.obs]

[PDTS] path::templatestring() conversion rules

Yes

49

WP

X 8.4.1 [path.construct]

[PDTS] path and directory_entry move ctors should not be noexcept

Yes

53

WP

X 12 [class.directory_entry]

[PDTS] directory_entry multithreading concerns

Yes

56

WP

X 5 [fs.req]

[PDTS] Feature test macro for TS version

Yes

57

WP

X 2.1 [fs.conform.9945]

[PDTS] Inappropriate use of "No diagnostic is required"

Yes

58

WP

X 15.25 [fs.op.last_write_time]

[PDTS] POSIX utime() is obsolescent

Yes

60

WP

X 15.1 [fs.op.absolute]

[PDTS] Incorrect Throws specification for absolute()

Yes

62

WP

X 5 Requirements [fs.req]

Allocator requirements unspecified

Yes

1

WP

X All

[PDTS] Make namespaces consistent with Library TS policy

Yes

2

WP

X 2.1 [fs.conform.9945]

[PDTS] Tighten specification when there is no reasonable behavior

Yes

3

WP

X 4.7 [fs.def.filename]

[PDTS] Filename length needs bullet item

Yes

8

WP

X [fs.filesystem.synopsis]

[PDTS] file_time_type underspecified

Yes

15

WP

X 8.2.2 [path.type.cvt]

[PDTS] Missing behavior for characters with no representation

Yes

16

WP

X 8.4.3 [path.append]

[PDTS] Append behavior underspecified if target is empty

Yes

19

WP

X 8.6.1 [path.io]

[PDTS] Consider using quoted manipulators

Yes

21

WP

X 12.3 [directory_entry.obs]

[PDTS] directory_entry operator== needs clarification

Yes

24

WP

X 15.3 [fs.op.copy]

[PDTS] Incorrect effects clause for path copy

Yes

29

WP

X 15.27 [fs.op.read_symlink]

[PDTS] Unclear semantics of read_symlink on error

Yes

32

WP

X 15.36 [fs.op.system_complete]

[PDTS] system_complete() example needs clarification

Yes

33

WP

X 15.38 [fs.op.unique_path]

[PDTS] unique_path() is a security vulnerability

Yes

44

WP

X 10.2 [enum.copy_options]

[PDTS] enum classes copy_options and perms should be bitmask types

Yes

47

WP

X 15.25 [fs.op.last_write_time]

[PDTS] last_write_time() uses ill-formed cast

Yes

50

WP

X 8 [class.path]

[PDTS] path::compare(const string& s) wrong argument type

Yes

52

WP

X 13 [class.directory_iterator]

[PDTS] Better to avoid deriving from std::iterator

Yes

55

WP

X 7 [fs.err.report]

[PDTS] Clarify Error reporting

Yes

6

WP

X 4.15 [fs.def.path]

[PDTS] Path depth is underspecified

Yes

7

WP

X 6 [fs.filesystem.synopsis], 15.32 [fs.op.space]

[PDTS] Unhelpful comment for struct space_info

Yes

9

WP

X 6 [fs.filesystem.synopsis]

[PDTS] Unclear why range-based-for functions return different types

Yes

14

WP

X 8.4.1 [path.construct]

[PDTS] Incorrect postconditions for path copy/move constructor

Yes

18

WP

X 8.4.10 [path.query]

[PDTS] is_absolute() return clause confusing

Yes

59

[NAD Editorial](active.html#NAD Editorial)

X 10 [fs.enum]

[PDTS] Invalid expressions for bitmask types

Yes

39

[NAD Editorial](active.html#NAD Editorial)

X 6 [fs.filesystem.synopsis]

[PDTS] permissions() is missing from synopsis

Yes

4

NAD

X 4.14 [fs.def.parent]

[PDTS] Need definition of dot and dot-dot

Yes

38

NAD

X 12.3 [directory_entry.obs]

[PDTS] Make certain functions noexcept and drop error_code version

Yes

42

NAD

X 8 [class.path]

[PDTS] class path should have defaulted constructors/destructor/assignments.

Yes

61

NAD

X 6 [fs.filesystem.synopsis]

Surprising equivalent() behavior if neither file exists

Yes

10

NAD

X 6 [fs.filesystem.synopsis]

[PDTS] Apparently inconsistent return types from several functions

Yes

13

NAD

X 7 [fs.err.report] etc.

[PDTS] Missing actual error conditions thrown

Yes

17

NAD

X 8.4.5 [path.modifiers]

[PDTS] path member swap() unnecessary

Yes

31

NAD

X 15.30 [fs.op.rename]

[PDTS] POSIX guarantees atomicity for rename()

Yes

23

NAD

X 15

[PDTS] Request for create_regular_file() and/or touch()

Yes

26

NAD

X 15.13 [fs.op.equivalent]

[PDTS] Equivalence is a volatile property

Yes

28

NAD

X 15.25 [fs.op.last_write_time]

[PDTS] Possible last_write_time() postcondition?

Yes

30

NAD

X 15.28 [fs.op.remove]

[PDTS] remove() must avoid race

Yes

46

NAD

X 8.4.7 [path.generic.obs]

[PDTS] Do we really need generic*?

Yes

43

Dup

X 8 [class.path]

[PDTS] path::compare(const string&) should be path::compare(const string_type&)

Yes

51

Dup

X 13 [class.directory_iterator]

[PDTS] directory_iterator, recursive_directory_iterator, pointer/reference typedefs wrong

Yes