Pay no attention to that man behind the curtain: Explaining semantics without semantics (original) (raw)

1. Home
2. e-Journals
3. The Mental Lexicon
4. Volume 11, Issue 3
5. Article

• Navigate this Journal
• About
• Online First
• Current issue
• Previous issues
• Author information
• Editorial information

• ISSN 1871-1340

• E-ISSN: 1871-1375

• Explaining semantics without semantics

• Source: The Mental Lexicon,Volume 11, Issue 3, Jan 2016, p. 350 - 374

• DOI: https://doi.org/10.1075/ml.11.3.02wes

• • Version of Record published : 16 Dec 2016

• Abstract

• Abstract

• Full-Text

• References (77)

• Cited By (39)

• Supplements

• Metrics

• Related Content

There is a distinction in scientific explanation between the explanandum, statements describing the empirical phenomenon to be explained, and the explanans, statements describing the evidence that allow one to predict that phenomenon. To avoid tautology, these sets of statements must refer to distinct domains. A scientific explanation of semantics must be grounded in explanans that appeal to entities from non-semantic domains. I consider as examples eight candidate domains (including affect, lexical or sub-word co-occurrence, mental simulation, and associative learning) that could ground semantics. Following Wittgenstein (1954), I propose adjudicating between these different domains is difficult because of the reification of a word’s ‘meaning’ as an atomistic unit. If we abandon the idea of the meaning of a word as being an atomistic unit and instead think of word meaning as a set of dynamic and disparate embodied states unified by a shared label, many apparent problems associated with identifying a meaning’s ‘true’ explanans disappear. Semantics can be considered as sets of weighted constraints that are individually sufficient for specifying and labeling a subjectively-recognizable location in the high dimensional state space defined by our neural activity.

© 2016 John Benjamins Publishing Company

Article metrics loading...

/content/journals/10.1075/ml.11.3.02wes

2016-12-16

2026-06-14

• From This Site

/content/journals/10.1075/ml.11.3.02wes
dcterms_title,dcterms_subject,pub_keyword
-contentType:Journal -contentType:Contributor -contentType:Concept -contentType:Institution
10
5

Full text loading...

• Article Type: Research Article

Most Read This Month

Article

content/journals/18711375

Journal

5

3

false

Most Cited