Chen, S. (2016). Selling the environment: Green marketing discourse in China's automobile advertising. Discourse, Context & Media, 12, 11-19. (original) (raw)
Related papers
“It’s Not Easy Being Green”: The Greenwashing of Environmental Discourses in Advertising
Canadian Journal of Communication, 2013
Under the political framework of free-market fundamentalism, corporations are appropriating environmental discourses through green capitalism and greenwashing. For environmental emancipation to occur, it is important to problematize the corporate discourses that put a price on nature and obfuscate the domination of nature by capital. The authors use an environmental political-economy framework to examine the ways particular products are represented through television advertising. Using a multimodal critical discourse analysis, they analyze three representations—Clorox Green Works cleaning products, the Ford Escape Hybrid, and Toyota Prius motor vehicles—in order to deconstruct and analyze how specific advertisements operate and how they contribute to problematic environmental discourses.
Too Influential or Too Inadequate? A Critical Discourse Analysis of Environmental Advertising
2020
This study focused on how environmental advertising constructs messages and shapes reality for consumers. Guided by discourse theory, this study used critical discourse analysis to examine and thematize images of environmental advertisements, resulting in the four themes of personalizing, personification, time, and shock value over specifics. From these findings and their analysis, it became clear that today’s consumers of environmental advertising are in a predicament: these advertisements create unwarranted feelings of responsibility, blame, and pressure, while simultaneously falling short in offering substantive advice on how to make meaningful change. To address this twofold problem, this study created a guide to be a more critical consumer of media, as well as a suggested media campaign to offer a better approach to environmental advertising.
Environmental Communication: A Journal of Nature and Culture, 2013
This paper compares hybrid car advertisements in the USA and China*the two largest car markets of the world*and analyzes the cultural, psychic, and historical factors that interrupt the translation of hybrids’ ‘‘eco-friendly’’ appeals to China. I evoke psycho- analysis to read the unconscious structures of desire embedded in the two distinct groups of advertising discourse. My analysis shows that while the American ads seek to erase the self from a fantasy of eco-harmony, the Chinese ones try to expand and multiply the self in the technical gaze of the West. Toward environmental pollution, the American ads respond with guilt and self-blame and the Chinese react with disgust and escapism. I argue that both types of discourse are structured around a psychic loss, which is inaugurated by each culture’s traumatic encounter with the technology of the motorcar.
International Journal of Chinese Culture and Management, 2008
After a long history of overexploitation and destruction of its natural resources, China has begun to include environmental protection among its economic development priorities. From the 1990s, the government has started to take important steps in this direction, by signing all relevant major international agreements, setting stricter measures to keep pollution out of densely populated areas and launching a number of eco-friendly projects aimed at enhancing 'environmental consciousness' in Chinese citizens. What level of environmental consciousness can be found in Chinese contemporary society? Are Chinese consumers ready for the so-called responsible consumption? What value do Chinese citizens attach to 'nature', 'the environment', 'responsible consumption'? Assuming it is rather difficult to give exhaustive answers, the author will try to shed some light on these issues through the analysis of an innovative project, which is going to reshape the island of Chongming, in Shanghai Municipality, into an environmentally friendly island.
Consumption Markets & Culture, 2012
To explain inconsistent behaviour that is well documented in green-marketing and consumption, the authors develop the (neo)structuralist model of meaning co-creation that is based on the signifying practices of hybrid car manufacturers and consumers. The model reveals that market agents are recruited into a symbolic order that requires the perpetual reinforcement of self-opposing meanings as a condition for signification. The main problem of green practice is not the issue of market agents' authenticity/hypocrisy. Rather it represents a more interactive phenomenon – the common structure of meaning-creation – which silences important transformative action choices and thus defeats its own purpose.
Organization, 2013
In this article we examine the marketing representations of the Toyota Prius, the first 'green' massproduced automobile. Drawing on an interpretive analysis of Prius print advertisements in Canadian publications between 2006-2011 and a matched sample of other automobile advertisements, we observe how the Prius advertisements invoke imagination and how this process is channelled, via the integration of text and images offered in the advertising space, to particular themes and ideas. Through the use of an ambiguous system of signs, audiences are invited to imagine and thereby co-create the significance of hybrid electric vehicles. Three areas of imagining are emphasized by the advertisement structure-nature, harmony and agency-and we analyze these imaginings as potential moments of knowledge creation about climate change. We examine how the activity of imagining in relation to these three areas influences viewers' knowledge and perception of climate change as well as their sense of responsibility for anthropogenic climate change. We discuss the consequences of using ambiguous messages to promote socially and politically charged products for consumers' understanding and imagination.
2011
This chapter examines how corporations generate green capital by exploiting the difference in truth claims attributed to visual modality in advertisements. Analysis of a corpus of UK advertisements produced by automotive and energy companies finds that adjudications about the truth values attributed to images or visual argument are treated differently to similar linguistic claims. Firstly, the chapter summarizes the relationship between ancient ethos and modern corporate image maintenance by making apparent the sharedneed to demonstrate strength of character, virtuousness and an appreciation of an audience’s values and concerns. Following the explanation of modality as a means of distinguishing truth claims in text and image, the chapter turns its attention to the adjudications regarding environmental claims in text and image. This piece concludes with a call for greater visual literacy and a more consistent consideration of the impact of images in environmental claims that are used to add to a corporation’s reputation.
EUPRERA 2012 Proceedings
This study deals with corporate advertising as a public relations tool and questions how automotive brands, claiming to be sustainable, use corporate ads in order to create a sustainable corporate image. 7 ads belonging to Audi, Honda Motor, Toyota (2 ads), Volkswagen (2 ads) and Volvo brands are taken in order to analyze. The reflections of sustainability with its triple bottomline -economical, social and environmental dimensions- as they are visible in their corporate print advertisements are scrutinized. The study employs semiotics as a critical theoretical research perspective to understand the micro-level of tactical messages given in the corporate advertisements. These tactical messages are extensions of macro-level organizational processes -such as identity construction- and they reflect the sustainability ideologies of the corporations, as well.
2015
This study deals with corporate advertising as a public relations tool and questions how automotive brands, claiming to be sustainable, use corporate ads (advertisements) as to create sustainable corporate images. Seven ads belonging to global automotive brands are taken in order to analyze. The reflections of sustainability with its triple bottomline-economical, social and environmental dimensions-as they are visible in their corporate print advertisements are scrutinized. The study employs semiotics as a critical theoretical research perspective to understand the micro-level of tactical messages given in the corporate advertisements. The methodology of the study is based on the work of Saussure (1916/1983) and Jacobson and Halle (1956). The originality of this paper is that it contributes to the academic literature by dealing with semiotics as a critical method to be utilized in the PR field where corporate advertising is taken as a PR tool to create an image that reflects a compa...