Estimation of Signal Parameters in the Frequency Domain in the Presence of Harmonic Interference: A Comparative Analysis (original) (raw)
Related papers
Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 2005
A high-accuracy, wide-range frequency estimation algorithm for the non-sinusoidal signals with white Gaussian noises basing on a numerical differentiation and central Lagrange interpolation is proposed in this paper. The proposed algorithm needs 7 sample points for frequency estimation of the signals with 3 order harmonics. The sample frequency is not restricted by the real value of the frequency of the nonsinusoidal signal and the mean of the noises. Under conditions with white noise, the frequency of the signal is estimated at an error of 0.001% over 1 Hz to 1000 kHz with the amplitudes of 1st, 2nd and 3rd of the non-sinusoidal signal varying from 1 to 320 V and the phase angle of 1st, 2nd and 3rd of the non-sinusoidal signal varying from 0 to 360 in at most half cycle. Using Matlab software, the simulation results of the test example are satisfactory. r
A Controlled Filtering Method for Estimating Harmonics of Off-Nominal Frequencies
IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, 2012
The increasing use of power electronics in power systems causes a high injection of harmonic components which can in turn interfere with utility equipment and customer loads. Therefore, the correct estimation and measurement of harmonics have become an important issue. If the power frequency of the signal is steady and near the nominal value, the discrete Fourier transform (DFT) can be used and good estimation performance is achieved. However, there are considerable power frequency variations on isolated systems such as shipboard power systems, micro-grids and smart-grids. When these variations occur there may be significant errors in the estimates using the DFT. In order to deal with this problem, this work presents a novel technique based on demodulation of the power line signal and subsequent filtering for harmonics estimation. The main features of the proposed harmonic estimation technique are: precise and accurate estimation of harmonics of off-nominal frequencies and fast estimation of harmonics (about two cycles of the fundamental component). Simulation results show that the proposed technique performs well in comparison with the DFT and can be a good candidate to replace it in cases where the power frequency is subject to considerable variations. Index Terms-Controlled FIR filter, harmonics estimation, offnominal frequency. I. INTRODUCTION T HE increasing use of power electronic devices in power systems has been producing significant higher harmonic distortions, what can cause problems to computers and microprocessor-based devices, thermal stresses to electric equipments, harmonic resonances, as well as aging and derating to electrical machines and power transformers [1]-[4]. One of the most important problems that have been reported in the literature concerns the difficulty of the frequency control within the micro-grids and the increase of the total harmonic distortion. These two factors may negatively impact on the protection system, power quality analysis and other intelligent electronic devices (IEDs), in which digital algorithms assume that the fundamental frequency is constant. Based on this fact,
IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement, 2000
This paper focuses on estimating the amplitude of harmonic components of a harmonically distorted sine wave by the interpolated discrete Fourier transform (IpDFT) method with maximum sidelobe decay windows. The expression of the maximum of the interference error caused by the fundamental sine-wave component on the amplitude estimation of harmonic components is derived. In addition, for a signal corrupted by stationary white noise, the statistical efficiency of the IpDFT method is investigated with respect to the single-tone unbiased Cramér-Rao lower bound (CRLB). Based on the derived expressions, a constraint is derived ensuring that interference from the fundamental component could practically be neglected. Finally, the performance of the IpDFT method is compared with that of the energy-based method on the basis of theoretical, simulation, and experimental results and with that of a state-of-the-art method according to simulation and experimental results.
Frequency and parameter estimation of multi-sinusoidal signal
Measurement Science Review, 2012
Estimating the fundamental frequency and harmonic parameters is basic for signal modeling in a power supply system. This paper presents a complexity-reduced algorithm for signal reconstruction in the time domain from irregularly spaced sampling values. Differing from the existing parameter estimation algorithms, either in power quality monitoring or in harmonic compensation, the proposed algorithm enables a simultaneous estimation of the fundamental frequency, the amplitudes and phases of harmonic waves. The reduction in complexity is achieved owing to completely new analytical and summarized expressions that enable a quick estimation at a low numerical error. It is proved that the estimation performance of the proposed algorithm can attain Cramer-Rao lower bound (CRLB) for sufficiently high signal-to-noise ratios. The proposed algorithm can be applied in signal reconstruction, spectral estimation, system identification, as well as in other important signal processing problems. The simulation and experimental results verify the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm.
An Intelligent FFT Analyzer With Harmonic Interference Effect Correction and Uncertainty Evaluation
IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement, 2004
This paper discusses the problem of correcting the effects of harmonic interference on fast Fourier transform (FFT) results. A procedure to evaluate and correct these effects is proposed and implemented on an intelligent FFT analyzer, which is also capable of indicating result uncertainties. Index Terms-Digital signal processing (DSP), fast Fourier transform (FFT), frequency domain, harmonic interference, uncertainty evaluation.
Digital Signal Processing, 2014
The parameters of a sine-wave are often estimated by means of the classical Interpolated Discrete Fourier Transform (IpDFTc) method based on cosine windows since this method provides high accuracy while requiring low computational effort. When the number of acquired sine-wave cycles is small, estimation accuracy is heavily affected by the interference due to spectral leakage from both the sine-wave image component and other disturbance tones such as signal harmonics. To reduce both these detrimental effects new cosine windows are proposed in this paper. Their spectra exhibit a deep null close to the image component interfering frequency and the highest allowed sidelobe decay rate, so assuring minimization of long range spectral leakage. These windows are called Maximum Image interference Rejection windows with Rapid Sidelobe Decay rate (RSD) or simply, MIR-RSD windows. The analytical expressions of the sine-wave parameter estimators provided by the IpDFTc method based on the H-term MIR-RSD window (H ≥ 2) are also derived. To assess the effectiveness of the MIR-RSD windows in rejecting the spectral interference when analyzing noisy or harmonically distorted sine-waves, the accuracy of the proposed frequency estimator is compared with those provided by other IpDFT frequency estimators through simulation and experimental results.
Accurate Estimation of Harmonic Components of Power Signal
2005
The present study proposes a novel technique of detecting and estimating the harmonic components of a signal under the influence of significant noise. The proposed method combines the advantages of both singular value decomposition (SVD) and orthogonal least squares (OLS) algorithm. By introducing an error reduction ratio (ERR) test, the algorithm detects the correct frequency component present in the signal. The other parameters of the signal are computed using SVD. The performance of the method has been demonstrated considering a power signal at different levels of noise and has been found to be satisfactory.
Applications of parametric spectral estimation methods on detection of power system harmonics
Electric Power Systems Research, 2008
Harmonics are the major power quality problems in industrial and commercial power systems. Several methods for detection of power system harmonics have been investigated by engineers due to increasing harmonic pollution. Since the non-integer multiple harmonics (inter and subharmonics) become wide spread, the importance of harmonic detection has increased for sensitive filtration. This paper suggests parametric spectral estimation methods for the detection of harmonics, inter-harmonics and sub-harmonics. Yule Walker, Burg, Covariance and Modified Covariance methods are applied to generate cases. Not only integer multiple harmonics but also non-integer multiple harmonics are successfully determined in the computer simulations. Further, performances of proposed methods are compared with each other in terms of frequency resolution.
A method to evaluate harmonic model-based estimations under non-white measured noise
2011
Automatic extracting information from powersystem event recordings requires applications of signal-processing estimation techniques whose performance has been verified under white noise. This paper proposes a method to test these techniques under real power-system noise, which is very different from white noise, to evaluate their application feasibility. The first part of the paper describes the evaluation method used to evaluate the techniques in a statistical sense and a method to extract noise from measured power-system recordings. The second part of the paper focuses on the evaluation of a number of harmonic model-based techniques under non-white noise, including: Kalman filter, MUSIC, ESPRIT, and segmentation algorithms. The paper shows that for the Kalman filter, a very high order with high computational burden is necessary only if high frequency components are of interest. The application of MUSIC, ESPRIT, and the segmentation algorithms under natural power-system noise is shown to be feasible.
A time-domain model-based method for the identification of multi-frequency signal parameters
Discrete Fourier Transform (DFT) is frequently used to determine parameters like frequency, amplitude, and phase; however, the finite length of data being used often leads to errors. Modeling a signal process in time-domain and estimating model parameters from observed data will provide a prediction about the data outside the sampled window and thus may lead to a better estimation of the signal spectrum. Many models were developed in literature for this purpose. While these models can provide better spectrum estimation than DFT, they may not be the best option because the parameter estimation is only suboptimal of least squares or the methods have very narrow convergence area. In this paper, the traditional nonlinear separable estimation has been modified and a new time-domain least-squares method was developed for the identification of multi-frequency signal parameters. Algorithm convergence was analyzed and improved through segmentation of data. Simulations and an experiment were provided to validate the effectiveness of the developed method.