Analytic Network Process (Anp) and Visualization of Spatial Data: The Use of Dynamic Maps in Territorial Transformation Processes (original) (raw)
Related papers
EURO Journal on Decision Processes, 2014
Large freight or passenger transport projects are problematic and controversial because many financial, technical, environmental and social aspects need to be considered. Indeed, the interface between the transport project and territorial planning domains is generally the focus of considerable heated debates, which often develop into conflicting decision contexts characterized by a high level of complexity. This paper presents a possible response to these difficulties through an innovative approach that integrates the analytic network process and the interactive visualization tool. The approach is intended to be deployed as problem structuring method, with a view to creating a common language for the actors involved and a shared basis for generating fruitful discussions. The proposed approach was applied in the context of the German section of the Genoa-Rotterdam railway corridor within the Interreg IVB NWE Project ''Code24''. The reported application shows how the combination of visualization and real-time interaction with spatial data provided effective decision support to a multinational stakeholder group. More generally, the application presented in this paper aims to demonstrate the potential
2016
Territorial planning is the focus of considerable debates, which often develop into uncertain and vulnerable decision contexts. Numbers and quantitative information in fact often dominate the process of decision-making but they are not easily comprehensible through quick and simple reasoning. Nonetheless, the huge quantities of data that describe our cities and regions could provide excellent bases to analyze spatial data in order to assess territories and simulate future development scenarios. The application of innovative digital tools in the analysis of urban issues offers new advantages and opportunities for the improvement of communication values in policies and decision-making processes, concurring to overcome conventional approaches to territorial management. The paper describes the application of the Interactive Visualization Tool (InViTo), a web tool based on maps and visual analysis allowing data to be filtered, explored, interconnected and compared on a visual interface. ...
Collaborative Decision Support for Spatial Planning Applications
For complex spatial decision problems a combination of software tools for group decision support, individual decision support and geographic analysis is required. The paper describes a respective approach and the integration of tools that were originally developed independently in two teams of Fraunhofer AIS. The first software system, Zeno, is a Java application for the World Wide Web designed to facilitate on-line structured discourses. It allows individuals to classify their contribution into meaningful categories, according to their topic, objectives and group. Groups must be able to evolve their discourse structure as a collaborative undertaking, and be able to modify it as an integral part of the discussion process. The second software system, CommonGIS, provides Java-based web-enabled services for interactive, explorative generation and analysis of thematic maps, particularly including innovative tools for multicriteria decision making. It will be utilized and extended within the new EC-funded project GIMMI (Geographic Information and Mathematical Models Inter-operability), which will provide a web portal for the analysis of pesticide applications regarding implications to water and soil. Through the integrated application of Zeno and CommonGIS, the entire decision process can be supported: In the early phases qualitative goals, options and constraints are discussed; they are then elaborated into alternative, more formal models. Different variants can be computed and visualized interactively in order to investigate different assumptions or to test the stability and quality of a solution. The entire process with all important alternatives and decisions is explicitly documented in a design rationale so that it can be reconstructed or resumed under modified constraints at any time.
Dynamic maps for supporting spatial decision processes
2013
The research here described aims at supporting decision making processes related to large scale and long term spatial questions. It proposes a method for sharing information and conveying reasoning by the use of dynamic maps. Through the visual localization of costs and benefits, the participants to the spatial decision processes are led to evaluate methods and objectives for a lot of alternative development options. The system has been used in different case studies showing its effectiveness in creating awareness on spatial problems and enabling discussions
Decision support and geographical information systems
1990
Central to IIASA's function as an institute of applied systems analysis is the requirement to provide the tools, information, and advice needed by those who face and must respond to real world issues, problems, and opportunities. Many of these issues, problems, and opportunities have a spatial dimension, and it is the interface and integration of decision support tools and geographical information systems that this report addresses. Spatially distributed information, problems, and solutions, require special tools of analysis. The research described in this report results from a series of research and development projects, carried out by IIASA's Advanced Computer Applications group. The examples presented range from work done for the Commission of the European Communities' Joint Research Centre and the Dutch Ministry for Housing, Physical Planning and the Environment in the area of technological and environmental risk analysis; the US Bureau of Reclamation in a project on groundwater management; the French Transportation research Institute INRETS, in a project on hazardous goods transportation risk analysis; and the State Science and Technology Commission of the People's Republic of China in a project on regional development planning. Using computer graphics for the visualization of information, problems, and solutions and as the basis for easy-to-use software tools, the research results discussed in this report demonstrate the role and potential of customized results of general systems analysis and modeling-which, by its usefulness and relevance, emphasizes IIASA's growing utility to a widening constituency.
2005
Decision support systems should help decision-makers at any organizational level in government, local communities and development organizations. The challenge of supporting sustainable development is to take into account a variety of decision makers as well as the complex natural, social and economic background over time. How can this be solved by the use of new technology for information and communication? Which are the requirements for such systems? After a review of possible solutions for spatial decision support techniques this paper proposes a technical approach which combines geospatial mapping with multidimensional analysis methods using the business intelligence capabilities of datawarehouses. The goal is a tool which can handle complex, structured data and information and which can be integrated into the decision processes of various groups of users. One task to fulfill concerns navigation through spatio-temporal data and the interactive recomputation of visualizations and analysis results when the hierarchical level or the dimensional view is changed. The other task is to the provide the information through an easy to use medium integrating existing informational and functional services. The approach in this paper will be illustrated with its application in real projects for the Nicaragua Development Gateway niDG.
Visualization and Decision Support Tools in Urban Planning
Communications in Computer and Information Science, 2012
Cities are rapidly growing. There is an assumption that 90% of global population growth will be in cities between now and 2030. Therefore, infrastructures and the environment have to be adapted to the changing demands. Moreover, new urban development strategies have to be elaborated. In 2007, the first international Visualization Summit of more than 100 international researchers and practitioners stated a jointly developed research goal for the year 2010, namely 'Visualizing Future Cities'. Therefore in this chapter we provide an overview about visualization methods, decision support tools in architecture, urban and regional planning, stakeholder participation and collaborative environments. Also, new decision support tools for the visualization of future cities will be introduced.
Spatial visualisation of stakeholders based on cartographic methodology in management systems
Economic Annals-ХХI, 2019
This study presents a model of a tool for spatial visualization of processes occurring in the stakeholder environment concerning relationship management according to the ISO standards for management systems. Spatial visualization is based on cartographic methodology extended with technological capabilities used in GIS (Geographic Information Systems) systems. Thanks to the method, different types of issues using environment maps can be presented. This paper proposes a model of a tool enabling multi-criteria spatial visualization of states, phenomena, processes and plans taking place in the discussed environment. The proposed model of visualization is to be used in the future to present the results of research in the discussed field. They concern stakeholder relationship management according to the ISO management systems. Appropriate technology is required for the application of the model. The study is part of a stream of works aimed at using the concept of space to describe various sections of reality. It may have both theoretical implications (visualizations based on spatial models), as well as practical ones related to popularizing the use of various types of space to describe phenomena and planning. The originality of this study is that the present model-based visualization features selected stakeholders within the ISO standards. As part of the visualization example, heuristic spaces were defined, on which objects representing different types of stakeholders were placed, their significance as part of the ISO standard being determined according to each of the features: power, interest and predictability. The data was obtained in a branch of an international corporation operating in the packaging industry.
Revista Brasileira de Cartografia, v. 69, n. 8,, 2018
Planning for the new urban development areas has always been a very contentious issue in local planning in Brazil, as it concentrates important interest conflicts from a diversity of involved stakeholders. Thematic cartography and multiple criteria analytical methods have been widely used as Planning Support Systems, especially with regards to the evaluation of carrying capacity of the territory to guide the location of these areas. However, data and technical information communication to communities is still a barrier to the extension of participatory decision making processes, which has enhanced the importance of geovisualization tools. This paper discusses the results of a simulated collaborative planning process at an academic workshop when Geodesign framework (STEINITZ, 2012) and geovisualization resources have been used to provide simultaneous information sharing, knowledge leveraging and establishment of preconditions for defining areas for urban growth. The outcomes showed the broad analytical and communication possibilities provided by the applied methods, which can be replicated in similar situations, involving non technical individuals with no specific knowledge for traditional cartography reading skills.
The primary objective of this study is to test the multicriteria analysis application in favor of a selection process among alternative transformations of an urban area in the city of Palermo. The choice is referred to as a strategyoriented one aiming to create “new urban centralities” able to redraw all urban structures that start to activate renewal processes within the existing city. The application of multicriteria analysis technique, such as the Analytic Network Process (ANP) – BOCR model, is due to the need to represent the complexity of the decision problem characterized by interrelations among several elements described by many indicators from different levels. The case study is also an opportunity to verify how the multicriteria analysis can contribute to the decision in the presence of mixed information, such as quantitative and qualitative ones. The application of the sensitivity analysis allows knowing and considering the conditions that can modify the earlier ranking of alternatives.