Where Online Hate Speech Can Bring the Police to Your Door (original) (raw)
Technology|Where Online Hate Speech Can Bring the Police to Your Door
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/23/technology/germany-internet-speech-arrest.html
You have a preview view of this article while we are checking your access. When we have confirmed access, the full article content will load.
Case files belonging to a special team in Germany that investigates online speech-related crimes.Credit...Felix Schmitt for The New York Times
Battling far-right extremism, Germany has gone further than any other Western democracy to prosecute individuals for what they say online, testing the limits of free speech on the internet.
Case files belonging to a special team in Germany that investigates online speech-related crimes.Credit...Felix Schmitt for The New York Times
Adam Satariano and Christopher F. Schuetze
Adam Satariano and Christopher F. Schuetze reported this article from Berlin, Augsburg and Göttingen, Germany, interviewing prosecutors, government officials and victims of online attacks.
- Published Sept. 23, 2022Updated Jan. 21, 2023
When the police pounded the door before dawn at a home in northwest Germany, a bleary-eyed young man in his boxer shorts answered. The officers asked for his father, who was at work.
They told him that his 51-year-old father was accused of violating laws against online hate speech, insults and misinformation. He had shared an image on Facebook with an inflammatory statement about immigration falsely attributed to a German politician. “Just because someone rapes, robs or is a serious criminal is not a reason for deportation,” the fake remark said.
The police then scoured the home for about 30 minutes, seizing a laptop and tablet as evidence, prosecutors said.
At that exact moment in March, a similar scene was playing out at about 100 other homes across Germany, part of a coordinated nationwide crackdown that continues to this day. After sharing images circulating on Facebook that carried a fake statement, the perpetrators had devices confiscated and some were fined.
“We are making it clear that anyone who posts hate messages must expect the police to be at the front door afterward,” Holger Münch, the head of the Federal Criminal Police Office, said after the March raids.
Hate speech, extremism, misogyny and misinformation are well-known byproducts of the internet. But the people behind the most toxic online behavior typically avoid any personal major real-world consequences. Most Western democracies like the United States have avoided policing the internet because of free speech rights, leaving a sea of slurs, targeted harassment and tweets telling public figures they’d be better off dead. At most, Facebook, YouTube or Twitter remove a post or suspend their account.
Thank you for your patience while we verify access. If you are in Reader mode please exit and log into your Times account, or subscribe for all of The Times.
Thank you for your patience while we verify access.
Already a subscriber? Log in.
Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Advertisement