Mandating immunity in the Ottoman Empire: A history of public health education and compulsory vaccination (original) (raw)
Related papers
Erciyes Medical Journal , 2021
This historical review examined the onset of the vaccination method during the Ottoman Empire. Inoculation was performed in the regions of Thessaly, Macedonia, and Thrace using folk medicine as a measure against the spread of smallpox/variola infection. Greek physicians Emmanuel Timonis (1669–1720) and Jacobus Pylarinos (1659–1718) as well as several other Ottoman scientists of the Greek or Turkish descent pioneered the use and dissemination of variolation and the development of vaccination before or concurrently with Edward Jenner (1749–1823). During the 19th century in the Adrianople (Edirne) region and much earlier in Constantinople (İstanbul), vaccination programs used to be implemented as evidenced by various certificates distributed at that time. Ottoman vaccination documents from the early 20th century and the letter of Lady Mary Wortley Montagu (1689–1762), dated 1719, have been analyzed, which confirms the extensive use of the vaccination method. Smallpox was the first disease to have been treated with vaccination method. The difference between the Greek and Ottoman physicians and Edward Jenner lies in the fact that while the Greek and Ottoman physicians removed fluid from pustules of an infected person to perform inoculation, Edward Jenner removed fluid from pustules of infected cows, which is why Edward Jenner’s method was coined vaccination (derived from the Latin word “vacca” meaning “cow”). Further, Turkish physicians Mustafa Behçet Efendi (1774–1834) and Sanizade Mehmed Ataullah Efendi (1771–1826) recommended the variolation method. It thus appears that the Ottomans provided care to all ethnicities of their Empire. Vaccines were initially used against smallpox, but the immunization program was eventually extended to other diseases.
Vaccination Practices in Ottoman Schools Osmanlı'da Okullarda Aşı Uygulamaları
The primary target of compulsory smallpox vaccination in the Ottoman Empire was children. As a matter of fact, the official announcement about the vaccine published in Takvîm-i Vekāyi dated March 21, 1847 begins with the statement that the vaccine protects children from smallpox, and for this reason, a fatwa was issued in accordance with Sharia. Subsequently, within the scope of the practice of free vaccination, various locations in İstanbul were identified and physicians and officers were appointed by Mekteb-i Tıbbiye, and while the state made all-out efforts, the fact that the disease was still effective was attributed to parents not paying enough attention. For this reason, it was announced that it was now decided that children who went to school and had not yet developed smallpox and had not been vaccinated would be vaccinated by appointing a physician, those who did not go to school would be vaccinated in vaccination shops in their neighborhoods, and the births of not only boys but also girls would be reported to the official authorities by imams and mukhtars (1). 1 From 1885 and onwards, the issues mentioned here were more thoroughly covered in the Vaccination Regulation 2 and Instructions 3 and the increasing control of the state could be
Disease and Public Health in the Ottoman Empire during WWI
infectious diseases, such as typhus, recurrent fever, dysentery, malaria, etc., took advantage of the social disruption caused by a world at war. More Ottoman soldiers perished from the deadly effects of microbes and bacteria than from bullets and bombs. By outlining the causes, geographical distribution, and mortalities from the most prevalent infectious diseases in the Ottoman context, this article highlights not only the destructive effects of infectious diseases, but also their formative consequences in terms of the state's responses to improve public health and sanitation for soldiers and civilians alike.
Al-Madaniyya: Keio Bulletin of Middle Eastern and Asian Urban History, 2024
This study focuses on municipal doctors and examines the emergence of "state medicine" in the modern Ottoman Empire. The establishment of local medical and sanitary organizations proceeded as an inseparable part of the reorganization of the new provincial system. Municipalities established in each administrative unit became the center of public health measures, and doctors trained at the new civilian medical school (1867) were appointed to each municipality. The percentage of municipal doctors employed in each region of Aydın Province gradually increased, from 40% in 1880 to 50% in 1890, and then to 80% in 1900. Hence, the turn of the 20th century signaled a time of change in the spread of state medicine in the modern Ottoman Empire. When the number of municipal doctors began to increase in the 1890s, significant efforts to improve the local sanitation administration also accelerated. These included the development of laws related to smallpox vaccination and food hygiene, employment and training of auxiliary personnel such as vaccinators and chemical inspectors, production of domestic vaccines, and development of chemical testing facilities.
Female Physicians and Patrons: The Formation of Public Health in the 17-18th century Ottoman Empire
2022
The aim of this dissertation is to reexamine the dominant trend in the history of Ottoman medicine that has dismissed the instrumental role of Ottoman female physicians and patrons in the formation of 17-18 th century public health. Although women were indispensable to administering healthcare in the empire prior to the nineteenth-century institutionalised conception of the term, they are often relegated to a secondary or non-existent role. Thus, I will examine three different paths towards public health that women were central figures in; firstly, as physicians in the Sultan's seraglio; as patrons of medical establishments in the empire; and lastly, as conduits for medical progress in the practice of inoculation which subsequently made its way to Europe. In this dissertation, the long-held misconception in Ottoman medical scholarship that women were inconsequential to the emergence of modern public health will be overturned through a re-conceptualisation of what constituted medicine in the early modern period.
Health as a Social Agent in Ottoman Patronage and Authority
Ottoman society and its medical system of the early modern period and the 19th century demonstrate the marriage of medicine and power. I present the view from the imperial center and focus on the aims and wishes of the Ottoman elite and imperial authorities in ‹stanbul as they were embodied in state activities, such as formal decrees and policies meant to be implemented all over the empire. For the Ottoman elite, medicine was always a significant imperial tool, but it was neither the only tool of control, nor the most important one. The extent to which the Ottoman elite used medicine in its social policies changed over time. A comparison between the Ottoman use and distribution of health and food from the early modern period until the 19th century illustrates this point. It was especially during the 19th century that medicine was intentionally–and successfully–implemented as a mechanism of control in the Ottoman Empire.
Osmanlı Medeniyeti Araştırmaları Dergisi, 2024
Foreign specialists were employed in the Ottoman Empire's health services, particularly during the 18th century onwards. The Ottomans required international cooperation to implement reforms to combat epidemics during the global epidemics of the 19th century. As a result, many foreign physicians joined the Ottoman medicine service. Therefore, numerous foreign physicians began serving with the central health organization in Istanbul and the quarantine units established in the provinces. Some physicians made significant contributions to the Ottoman sanitary administration through their positions, time in Ottoman service, and activities. Dr Bartoletti, who was born in Istanbul in 1808, was one of these specialists. After medical education in Italy, he started his Ottoman service as a quarantine doctor and became a member of the Sanitary Council. He also represented the Ottoman Empire at the international medical conferences held in Paris, Istanbul and Vienna and performed important duties in Ottoman sanitary affairs during his forty-four years of service. By examining Dr Bartoletti's activities between 1840 and 1888, this study aims to contribute to the existing literature on this field.
İzmir Demokrasi Üniversitesi II. Uluslararası Beşerî Bilimler Kongresi: Sosyal Bilimler Perspektifinden Salgın Hastalıklar ve Toplumsal Dönüşüm (19-21 Kasım 2021), Tam Metin Bildiri Kitabı, 2021
This study aims at outlining the transformation of the healthcare system and the emergence of the public health in relation to the making of modern state in a long-term historical context from the classical age to the end of the 19th century in the Ottoman Empire. Inspired by the statist-institutionalist approach, it suggests that there is a direct correlation between the emergence of the healthcare system for the general population and the making of the modern state during the reformation age in the empire. However, the study argues that in the late 19th century, the Ottoman State still lacked sufficient capacity for enforcing its new medical policy in its countryside.