Clare Burke | University of York (original) (raw)

Neolithic and Bronze Age Greece by Clare Burke

Research paper thumbnail of Alram-Stern, E., Burke, C., Demakopoulou, K. and Day, P. M. The Late-Final Neolithic and Early Helladic I Pottery from Midea in the Argolid: Continuity and Change

The Wider Island of Pelops: Studies on Prehistoric Aegean Pottery in Honour of Professor Christopher Mee, 2023

This chapter discusses the Neolithic-Early Bronze Age pottery analysed from the site if Midea in ... more This chapter discusses the Neolithic-Early Bronze Age pottery analysed from the site if Midea in the Arpolid of NE Peloponnese, Greece. The paper presents pottery shapes and some of the petrographic and SEM results which show aspects of continuity and change, with notable technological changes related to the use of grog.

Research paper thumbnail of Strategies for success: Early Helladic pottery production in Corinth, Greece

Journal of Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences, 2023

ONLINE ACCESS HERE https://rdcu.be/dbRb4 This paper presents the analysis of Early Helladic II ... more ONLINE ACCESS HERE https://rdcu.be/dbRb4

This paper presents the analysis of Early Helladic II (EH II) pottery from Keramidaki (Ancient Corinth) and the nearby settlement of Korakou. Based on macroscopic, petrographic and SEM-EDS data, the work builds on pioneering chemical research by Michael Attas who demonstrated the limited circulation of finewares in the region and posited the existence of a workshop in the area of the Corinthian Plain. The current research adds substantial detail to Attas' insights by characterising the varied range of pottery fabrics encompassed within his chemical groups, differences in raw material choice and manipulation, and the presence of both oxidation and reduction firing regimes to achieve different surface finishes. It is suggested that the area hosted a number of potters during this period, some making a broad range of pottery types to satisfy daily consumption needs of the local community, whilst others produced a more restricted repertoire.

Research paper thumbnail of The Chaîne Opératoire of pottery traditions at Pheneos, Peloponnese, mainland Greece

Journal of Archaeological Science Reports, 2021

This paper will present the results of an integrated programme of analysis that combines typologi... more This paper will present the results of an integrated programme of analysis that combines typological, macro-scopic, petrographic, and microstructural techniques, with experimental analysis, to examine and reconstruct the chaîne opératoire of production used to make Bronze Age ceramics from the site of Pheneos, Peloponnese, mainland Greece. The results demonstrate the prevalence of local production using a narrow range of raw materials and specific sequence of forming techniques that were applied to make a wide variety of vessel types from the Early through to the Late Bronze Age. This domination of local production is accompanied by the presence of a small number of high quality imports from key centres of production during the Middle and Late Bronze Age.
Free access for 50 days - https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352409X2030451X?dgcid=author

Research paper thumbnail of Archaia Pheneos pottery: Provenance and production technology.

TΟ ΑΡΧΑΙΟΛΟΓΙΚΟ ΕΡΓΟ ΣΤΗΝ ΠΕΛΟΠΟΝΝΗΣΟ 2 (ΑΕΠΕΛ2) Πρακτικά της Β ́ Επιστημονικής Συνάντησης Καλαμάτα, 1-4 Νοεμβρίου 2017, 2021

A short report on preliminary macroscopic and petrographic analysis of EHIII-LHII ceramics from A... more A short report on preliminary macroscopic and petrographic analysis of EHIII-LHII ceramics from Archaia Pheneos, Greece. (For detailed publication of Pheneos results see Burke, C., Zavadil, M., and Kordatzaki, G. 2021 The chaîne opératoire of pottery traditions at Pheneos, Mainland Greece, Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports 35)

Research paper thumbnail of Early Helladic I and Talioti Pottery: Is it just a phase we're going through? Pre-print- full article available on request

Oxford Journal of Archaeology , 2020

This paper discusses the analysis of Early Bronze Age ‘Talioti’ style ceramics found at sites acr... more This paper discusses the analysis of Early Bronze Age ‘Talioti’ style ceramics found at sites across Corinthia and the Argolid, in the NE Peloponnese of mainland Greece. Forming part of a broader programme of analysis, it presents the results of an integrated methodology to address questions relating to the potential sources of raw materials, the identification of potting practices, and the nature of vessel movement during the EBA period. The objective of the work has been to place site-based results within a broader spatial and temporal context, specifically examining how this characteristic ceramic assemblage has been used as a chronological and cultural marker for the Early Bronze Age 1 (EBI) period in the NE Peloponnese of Greece, and the implications of analysis for our understanding of its chronological and spatial distribution.

Research paper thumbnail of Crafting and Consumption Choices: Neolithic – Early Helladic II Ceramic Production and Distribution, Midea and Tiryns, Mainland Greece

Pottery technologies and sociocultural connections Between the Aegean and Anatolia during the 3 rd Millennium BC , 2018

This paper will discuss some of the key results of petrographic analysis undertaken on LN–EH II c... more This paper will discuss some of the key results of petrographic analysis undertaken on LN–EH II ceramic material from the site of Midea. Through examination of the petrological and technological variability present at Midea, our results suggest both continuity and significant changes in technological practice, distribution trends and consumption
choices over time. Key amongst our results has been the identification of a fabric characterised by sandstone and low-grade metamorphic rocks, thought to originate in the area of the Talioti Valley, and indicating the presence of a major centre of production in the Argolid. Other fabrics testify to shared technological traditions and raw material choices across the northeastern Peloponnese, which have a very long history of use. Significant changes are presented, not only in specific technological choices, but also in the distribution of vessels from particular production centres. These reflect increased interaction between communities in the Argolid and Corinthia over time.

Research paper thumbnail of The Contribution of Petrography to Understanding the Production and Consumption of Early Helladic Ceramics from Nemea, Mainland Greece

Integrative Approaches in Ceramic Petrography Edited by Mary F. Ownby, Isabelle C. Druc, and Maria A. Masucci, 2017

Research paper thumbnail of Colour images for Burke et al. 2017 The Contribution of Petrography to Understanding the Production and Consumption of Early Helladic Ceramics

Neolithic Serbia by Clare Burke

Research paper thumbnail of New Multi-disciplinary Data from the Neolithic in Serbia

Archaeologia Austriaca , 2022

The excavations at Svinjarička Čuka in the South Morava Valley in Serbia are presented with new p... more The excavations at Svinjarička Čuka in the South Morava Valley in Serbia are presented with new primary data from the field and related material and scientific analyses. Newly recovered architectural remains from the classical Starčevo period revealed a variety of domestic features, so far belonging to an earlier and later occupation phase at the river terrace dating between 5700/5600 and 5500 BC. Details of the stratigraphy and certain materials are presented for selected domestic contexts, including one potential ‘Starčevo house’. Archaeological and scientific analyses are discussed and contextualised within the Neolithisation process in the chapters on new radiocarbon data and their Bayesian modelling, pottery studies, chipped stones and their raw material analyses, grinding kits, animal remains, archaeobotanical results and charcoal analysis. The later occupation at the site is presented with new results for the Middle and Late Bronze Age and the Early Iron Age, including domestic contexts, radiocarbon data and materials.

Research paper thumbnail of Pottery Made to be Used: Starčevo Ceramics from the site of Svinjarička Čuka, Serbia. In J. Vuković and V. Bikić (Eds.) Pottery Function and Use: A Diachronic Perspective. Belgrade: University of Belgrade, Institute of Archaeology

Pots in context: Vessels' use, function, and consumption, research strategies and methodology, 2022

Full book available from BECAP Academia Page

Research paper thumbnail of POTTING LINKS: THE STARČEVO CERAMIC REPERTOIRE OF SVINJARIČKA ČUKA, SERBIA

Archaeology in Macedonia , 2022

This paper briefly summarises preliminary observations about the production and consumption of th... more This paper briefly summarises preliminary observations about the production and consumption of the Starčevo ceramic assemblage from the new site of Svinjarička Čuka as part of the NEOTECH project. Through integrating typological and technological approaches, it is already possible to see at the macroscopic level strong links to other sites, particularly in the surrounding region, not only in terms of ideas about what a vessel should look like but also in terms of how it should be made, including some potential ancestral links to Anatolian potting traditions.

Research paper thumbnail of M. Gavranovic - B. Horejs (eds.), Visualising the Unknown Balkans

The visualization of the archaeological heritage from the Balkans turns the spotlight on the huma... more The visualization of the archaeological heritage from the Balkans turns the spotlight on the human past in this region that is in many ways essential for our understanding of European history in general. Southeast Europe represents one of the key areas for analysing the human past, where most of the major cultural developments started that had a long-lasting impact on the continent. This specific culmination of cultural and social dynamics over millennia took place in the highly diverse, but connected landscapes of the Balkans. These distinct characteristics form the backbone of one of the most exciting and challenging areas for archaeology on the globe. Visualizing the Unknown Balkans offers an overview of ongoing interdisciplinary fieldwork in Bosnia and Herzegovina and in Serbia covering a time span of about six millennia. The results, in the form of maps, plans, geophysical screenings and digital reconstructions, open up new perspectives for potential future investigations and set the course for the broader
public and scientific perception of archaeological research in the region.

Research paper thumbnail of New Insights into the Later Stage of the Neolithisation Process of the Central Balkans. First Excavations at Svinjarička Čuka 2018

Archaeologia Austriaca, 2019

This article discusses recent findings from the newly identified archaeological site of Svinjarič... more This article discusses recent findings from the newly identified archaeological site of Svinjarička Čuka, situated next to the Southern Morava River in southern Serbia. We will present the latest results from the excavation, material studies, bioarchaeological analyses and contextualised radiocarbon data, focusing on the Starčevo Neolith-ic horizon within the context of the new NEOTECH project. The interdisciplinary approach aims to shed light on the Neolithisation process of the region along one of the main communication routes between the Aegean and the Danube by the Axios-Vardar-Morava river system. The work so far has uncovered remains of Early to Middle Neolithic features dating around 5600 calBC, with analyses of faunal remains, ceramics and lithics contributing new insights into animal exploitation, raw materials and technological practices during this important time of socioeconomic transition.

Neolithic Anatolia by Clare Burke

Research paper thumbnail of NEOLITHIC POTTING TRADITIONS AT ÇUKURIÇI HÖYÜK

R. Özbal, M. Erdalkıran, Y. Tonoike (eds.). Neolithic Pottery from the Near East: Production, Distribution and Use. Proceedings of the 2019 Third International Workshop (Antalya, Turkey). Koç University AKMED Publications: Istanbul, 2022

This paper discusses the Neolithic ceramics from the important site of Çukuriçi Höyük, Western Tu... more This paper discusses the Neolithic ceramics from the important site of Çukuriçi Höyük, Western Turkey, detailing typological and technological elements. The results of the pottery analysis undertaken at the site so far, have highlighted the use of a range of different forming techniques, often in combination. It has also highlighted the use of multiple raw material types to make a varied range of shapes, all of which testify to long held potting traditions, as well as demonstrating the high degree of knowledge and skill used to make these durable and well-finished pottery types. We discuss our results within the contexts of those from other sites, in terms of typological affinities, key technical elements related to vessel forming, and potential pottery use.

Pottery Technology and Theory by Clare Burke

Research paper thumbnail of Epilogue: The Future of Craft Research.

Crafting in the World: Materiality in the Making, 2018

This chapter summarises the key themes addressed by the various case studies in the book, discuss... more This chapter summarises the key themes addressed by the various case studies in the book, discussing, gender, identity, the role of choice, nostalgia, psychology and the importance of the cultural context in which crafting takes place.

Research paper thumbnail of Introduction to Crafting in the World. In Burke, C and Spencer-Wood, S (eds.) Crafting in the World: Materiality in the Making Springer: New York

Crafting in the World: Materiality in the Making Springer: New York, 2018

This chapter provides a summary background to the study of technology and craft in archaeology an... more This chapter provides a summary background to the study of technology and craft in archaeology and anthropology, advocating for interdisciplinary research and more cross over between academic study and physical practice.

It summarises the approach of the book and the case studies within in it.

Research paper thumbnail of Crafting in the World: Materiality in the Making (PDF papers available on request)

The volume expands understandings of crafting practices, which in the past was the major relation... more The volume expands understandings of crafting practices, which in the past was the major relational interaction between the social agency of materials, technology, and people, in co-creating an emergent ever-changing world. The chapters discuss different ways that crafting in the present is useful in understanding crafting experiences and methods in the past, including experiments to reproduce ancient excavated objects, historical accounts of crafting methods and experiences, craft revivals, and teaching historical crafts at museums and schools.

The volume is unique in the diversity of its theoretical and multidisciplinary approaches to researching crafting, not just as a set of techniques for producing functional objects, but as social practices and technical choices embodying cultural ideas, knowledge, and multiple interwoven social networks. Crafting expresses and constitutes mental schemas, identities, ideologies, and cultures. The multiple meanings and significances of crafting are explored from a great variety of disciplinary perspectives, including anthropology, archaeology, sociology, education, psychology, women’s studies, and ethnic studies.

Reports by Clare Burke

Research paper thumbnail of OREA Annual Report 2018

by Barbara Horejs, Christoph Schwall, Katharina Rebay-Salisbury, Roderick B . Salisbury, Roman Gundacker, Felix Höflmayer, Bettina Bader, Vera Müller, Teresa Bürge, Laura Burkhardt, Reinhard Jung, Elina Kardamaki, Birgitta Eder, Mario Gavranovic, Benedikt Biederer, Michael brandl, Clare Burke, and Holger Kockelmann

OREA Annual Report 2018, 2019

Research results and reports from the Institute for Oriental and European Archaeology of the Aust... more Research results and reports from the Institute for Oriental and European Archaeology of the Austrian Academy of Sciences of the year 2018 including outreach activities, excavations, surveys, analyses, material studies and current publications from all research groups and labs working in 17 countries.

Research paper thumbnail of 8 Years OREA and Annual Report 2020

by Barbara Horejs, Christoph Schwall, Roman Gundacker, Felix Höflmayer, Bettina Bader, Uroš Matić, Natasha Ayers, Reinhard Jung, Birgitta Eder, Mario Gavranovic, Michael brandl, Clare Burke, and Michaela Zavadil

8 Years of OREA, Annual Report, 2020

This special issue of the annual report includes an overview of the 8-year history of the Institu... more This special issue of the annual report includes an overview of the 8-year history of the Institute for Oriental and European Archaeology of the Austrian Academy of Sciences with research highlights from the Palaeolithic to the early Iron Age. The research results and reports from the year 2020 are summarizing outreach activities, excavations, surveys, analyses, material studies and current publications from all groups and labs working in 17 countries. All publications of 8 years OREA institute are additionally listed at the end of the report.

Book Reviews by Clare Burke

Research paper thumbnail of Review - Dries Daems, Social Complexity and Complex Systems in Archaeology (Routledge, Oxon 2021)

Archaeologia Austriaca, 2021

Research paper thumbnail of Alram-Stern, E., Burke, C., Demakopoulou, K. and Day, P. M. The Late-Final Neolithic and Early Helladic I Pottery from Midea in the Argolid: Continuity and Change

The Wider Island of Pelops: Studies on Prehistoric Aegean Pottery in Honour of Professor Christopher Mee, 2023

This chapter discusses the Neolithic-Early Bronze Age pottery analysed from the site if Midea in ... more This chapter discusses the Neolithic-Early Bronze Age pottery analysed from the site if Midea in the Arpolid of NE Peloponnese, Greece. The paper presents pottery shapes and some of the petrographic and SEM results which show aspects of continuity and change, with notable technological changes related to the use of grog.

Research paper thumbnail of Strategies for success: Early Helladic pottery production in Corinth, Greece

Journal of Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences, 2023

ONLINE ACCESS HERE https://rdcu.be/dbRb4 This paper presents the analysis of Early Helladic II ... more ONLINE ACCESS HERE https://rdcu.be/dbRb4

This paper presents the analysis of Early Helladic II (EH II) pottery from Keramidaki (Ancient Corinth) and the nearby settlement of Korakou. Based on macroscopic, petrographic and SEM-EDS data, the work builds on pioneering chemical research by Michael Attas who demonstrated the limited circulation of finewares in the region and posited the existence of a workshop in the area of the Corinthian Plain. The current research adds substantial detail to Attas' insights by characterising the varied range of pottery fabrics encompassed within his chemical groups, differences in raw material choice and manipulation, and the presence of both oxidation and reduction firing regimes to achieve different surface finishes. It is suggested that the area hosted a number of potters during this period, some making a broad range of pottery types to satisfy daily consumption needs of the local community, whilst others produced a more restricted repertoire.

Research paper thumbnail of The Chaîne Opératoire of pottery traditions at Pheneos, Peloponnese, mainland Greece

Journal of Archaeological Science Reports, 2021

This paper will present the results of an integrated programme of analysis that combines typologi... more This paper will present the results of an integrated programme of analysis that combines typological, macro-scopic, petrographic, and microstructural techniques, with experimental analysis, to examine and reconstruct the chaîne opératoire of production used to make Bronze Age ceramics from the site of Pheneos, Peloponnese, mainland Greece. The results demonstrate the prevalence of local production using a narrow range of raw materials and specific sequence of forming techniques that were applied to make a wide variety of vessel types from the Early through to the Late Bronze Age. This domination of local production is accompanied by the presence of a small number of high quality imports from key centres of production during the Middle and Late Bronze Age.
Free access for 50 days - https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352409X2030451X?dgcid=author

Research paper thumbnail of Archaia Pheneos pottery: Provenance and production technology.

TΟ ΑΡΧΑΙΟΛΟΓΙΚΟ ΕΡΓΟ ΣΤΗΝ ΠΕΛΟΠΟΝΝΗΣΟ 2 (ΑΕΠΕΛ2) Πρακτικά της Β ́ Επιστημονικής Συνάντησης Καλαμάτα, 1-4 Νοεμβρίου 2017, 2021

A short report on preliminary macroscopic and petrographic analysis of EHIII-LHII ceramics from A... more A short report on preliminary macroscopic and petrographic analysis of EHIII-LHII ceramics from Archaia Pheneos, Greece. (For detailed publication of Pheneos results see Burke, C., Zavadil, M., and Kordatzaki, G. 2021 The chaîne opératoire of pottery traditions at Pheneos, Mainland Greece, Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports 35)

Research paper thumbnail of Early Helladic I and Talioti Pottery: Is it just a phase we're going through? Pre-print- full article available on request

Oxford Journal of Archaeology , 2020

This paper discusses the analysis of Early Bronze Age ‘Talioti’ style ceramics found at sites acr... more This paper discusses the analysis of Early Bronze Age ‘Talioti’ style ceramics found at sites across Corinthia and the Argolid, in the NE Peloponnese of mainland Greece. Forming part of a broader programme of analysis, it presents the results of an integrated methodology to address questions relating to the potential sources of raw materials, the identification of potting practices, and the nature of vessel movement during the EBA period. The objective of the work has been to place site-based results within a broader spatial and temporal context, specifically examining how this characteristic ceramic assemblage has been used as a chronological and cultural marker for the Early Bronze Age 1 (EBI) period in the NE Peloponnese of Greece, and the implications of analysis for our understanding of its chronological and spatial distribution.

Research paper thumbnail of Crafting and Consumption Choices: Neolithic – Early Helladic II Ceramic Production and Distribution, Midea and Tiryns, Mainland Greece

Pottery technologies and sociocultural connections Between the Aegean and Anatolia during the 3 rd Millennium BC , 2018

This paper will discuss some of the key results of petrographic analysis undertaken on LN–EH II c... more This paper will discuss some of the key results of petrographic analysis undertaken on LN–EH II ceramic material from the site of Midea. Through examination of the petrological and technological variability present at Midea, our results suggest both continuity and significant changes in technological practice, distribution trends and consumption
choices over time. Key amongst our results has been the identification of a fabric characterised by sandstone and low-grade metamorphic rocks, thought to originate in the area of the Talioti Valley, and indicating the presence of a major centre of production in the Argolid. Other fabrics testify to shared technological traditions and raw material choices across the northeastern Peloponnese, which have a very long history of use. Significant changes are presented, not only in specific technological choices, but also in the distribution of vessels from particular production centres. These reflect increased interaction between communities in the Argolid and Corinthia over time.

Research paper thumbnail of The Contribution of Petrography to Understanding the Production and Consumption of Early Helladic Ceramics from Nemea, Mainland Greece

Integrative Approaches in Ceramic Petrography Edited by Mary F. Ownby, Isabelle C. Druc, and Maria A. Masucci, 2017

Research paper thumbnail of Colour images for Burke et al. 2017 The Contribution of Petrography to Understanding the Production and Consumption of Early Helladic Ceramics

Research paper thumbnail of New Multi-disciplinary Data from the Neolithic in Serbia

Archaeologia Austriaca , 2022

The excavations at Svinjarička Čuka in the South Morava Valley in Serbia are presented with new p... more The excavations at Svinjarička Čuka in the South Morava Valley in Serbia are presented with new primary data from the field and related material and scientific analyses. Newly recovered architectural remains from the classical Starčevo period revealed a variety of domestic features, so far belonging to an earlier and later occupation phase at the river terrace dating between 5700/5600 and 5500 BC. Details of the stratigraphy and certain materials are presented for selected domestic contexts, including one potential ‘Starčevo house’. Archaeological and scientific analyses are discussed and contextualised within the Neolithisation process in the chapters on new radiocarbon data and their Bayesian modelling, pottery studies, chipped stones and their raw material analyses, grinding kits, animal remains, archaeobotanical results and charcoal analysis. The later occupation at the site is presented with new results for the Middle and Late Bronze Age and the Early Iron Age, including domestic contexts, radiocarbon data and materials.

Research paper thumbnail of Pottery Made to be Used: Starčevo Ceramics from the site of Svinjarička Čuka, Serbia. In J. Vuković and V. Bikić (Eds.) Pottery Function and Use: A Diachronic Perspective. Belgrade: University of Belgrade, Institute of Archaeology

Pots in context: Vessels' use, function, and consumption, research strategies and methodology, 2022

Full book available from BECAP Academia Page

Research paper thumbnail of POTTING LINKS: THE STARČEVO CERAMIC REPERTOIRE OF SVINJARIČKA ČUKA, SERBIA

Archaeology in Macedonia , 2022

This paper briefly summarises preliminary observations about the production and consumption of th... more This paper briefly summarises preliminary observations about the production and consumption of the Starčevo ceramic assemblage from the new site of Svinjarička Čuka as part of the NEOTECH project. Through integrating typological and technological approaches, it is already possible to see at the macroscopic level strong links to other sites, particularly in the surrounding region, not only in terms of ideas about what a vessel should look like but also in terms of how it should be made, including some potential ancestral links to Anatolian potting traditions.

Research paper thumbnail of M. Gavranovic - B. Horejs (eds.), Visualising the Unknown Balkans

The visualization of the archaeological heritage from the Balkans turns the spotlight on the huma... more The visualization of the archaeological heritage from the Balkans turns the spotlight on the human past in this region that is in many ways essential for our understanding of European history in general. Southeast Europe represents one of the key areas for analysing the human past, where most of the major cultural developments started that had a long-lasting impact on the continent. This specific culmination of cultural and social dynamics over millennia took place in the highly diverse, but connected landscapes of the Balkans. These distinct characteristics form the backbone of one of the most exciting and challenging areas for archaeology on the globe. Visualizing the Unknown Balkans offers an overview of ongoing interdisciplinary fieldwork in Bosnia and Herzegovina and in Serbia covering a time span of about six millennia. The results, in the form of maps, plans, geophysical screenings and digital reconstructions, open up new perspectives for potential future investigations and set the course for the broader
public and scientific perception of archaeological research in the region.

Research paper thumbnail of New Insights into the Later Stage of the Neolithisation Process of the Central Balkans. First Excavations at Svinjarička Čuka 2018

Archaeologia Austriaca, 2019

This article discusses recent findings from the newly identified archaeological site of Svinjarič... more This article discusses recent findings from the newly identified archaeological site of Svinjarička Čuka, situated next to the Southern Morava River in southern Serbia. We will present the latest results from the excavation, material studies, bioarchaeological analyses and contextualised radiocarbon data, focusing on the Starčevo Neolith-ic horizon within the context of the new NEOTECH project. The interdisciplinary approach aims to shed light on the Neolithisation process of the region along one of the main communication routes between the Aegean and the Danube by the Axios-Vardar-Morava river system. The work so far has uncovered remains of Early to Middle Neolithic features dating around 5600 calBC, with analyses of faunal remains, ceramics and lithics contributing new insights into animal exploitation, raw materials and technological practices during this important time of socioeconomic transition.

Research paper thumbnail of NEOLITHIC POTTING TRADITIONS AT ÇUKURIÇI HÖYÜK

R. Özbal, M. Erdalkıran, Y. Tonoike (eds.). Neolithic Pottery from the Near East: Production, Distribution and Use. Proceedings of the 2019 Third International Workshop (Antalya, Turkey). Koç University AKMED Publications: Istanbul, 2022

This paper discusses the Neolithic ceramics from the important site of Çukuriçi Höyük, Western Tu... more This paper discusses the Neolithic ceramics from the important site of Çukuriçi Höyük, Western Turkey, detailing typological and technological elements. The results of the pottery analysis undertaken at the site so far, have highlighted the use of a range of different forming techniques, often in combination. It has also highlighted the use of multiple raw material types to make a varied range of shapes, all of which testify to long held potting traditions, as well as demonstrating the high degree of knowledge and skill used to make these durable and well-finished pottery types. We discuss our results within the contexts of those from other sites, in terms of typological affinities, key technical elements related to vessel forming, and potential pottery use.

Research paper thumbnail of Epilogue: The Future of Craft Research.

Crafting in the World: Materiality in the Making, 2018

This chapter summarises the key themes addressed by the various case studies in the book, discuss... more This chapter summarises the key themes addressed by the various case studies in the book, discussing, gender, identity, the role of choice, nostalgia, psychology and the importance of the cultural context in which crafting takes place.

Research paper thumbnail of Introduction to Crafting in the World. In Burke, C and Spencer-Wood, S (eds.) Crafting in the World: Materiality in the Making Springer: New York

Crafting in the World: Materiality in the Making Springer: New York, 2018

This chapter provides a summary background to the study of technology and craft in archaeology an... more This chapter provides a summary background to the study of technology and craft in archaeology and anthropology, advocating for interdisciplinary research and more cross over between academic study and physical practice.

It summarises the approach of the book and the case studies within in it.

Research paper thumbnail of Crafting in the World: Materiality in the Making (PDF papers available on request)

The volume expands understandings of crafting practices, which in the past was the major relation... more The volume expands understandings of crafting practices, which in the past was the major relational interaction between the social agency of materials, technology, and people, in co-creating an emergent ever-changing world. The chapters discuss different ways that crafting in the present is useful in understanding crafting experiences and methods in the past, including experiments to reproduce ancient excavated objects, historical accounts of crafting methods and experiences, craft revivals, and teaching historical crafts at museums and schools.

The volume is unique in the diversity of its theoretical and multidisciplinary approaches to researching crafting, not just as a set of techniques for producing functional objects, but as social practices and technical choices embodying cultural ideas, knowledge, and multiple interwoven social networks. Crafting expresses and constitutes mental schemas, identities, ideologies, and cultures. The multiple meanings and significances of crafting are explored from a great variety of disciplinary perspectives, including anthropology, archaeology, sociology, education, psychology, women’s studies, and ethnic studies.

Research paper thumbnail of OREA Annual Report 2018

by Barbara Horejs, Christoph Schwall, Katharina Rebay-Salisbury, Roderick B . Salisbury, Roman Gundacker, Felix Höflmayer, Bettina Bader, Vera Müller, Teresa Bürge, Laura Burkhardt, Reinhard Jung, Elina Kardamaki, Birgitta Eder, Mario Gavranovic, Benedikt Biederer, Michael brandl, Clare Burke, and Holger Kockelmann

OREA Annual Report 2018, 2019

Research results and reports from the Institute for Oriental and European Archaeology of the Aust... more Research results and reports from the Institute for Oriental and European Archaeology of the Austrian Academy of Sciences of the year 2018 including outreach activities, excavations, surveys, analyses, material studies and current publications from all research groups and labs working in 17 countries.

Research paper thumbnail of 8 Years OREA and Annual Report 2020

by Barbara Horejs, Christoph Schwall, Roman Gundacker, Felix Höflmayer, Bettina Bader, Uroš Matić, Natasha Ayers, Reinhard Jung, Birgitta Eder, Mario Gavranovic, Michael brandl, Clare Burke, and Michaela Zavadil

8 Years of OREA, Annual Report, 2020

This special issue of the annual report includes an overview of the 8-year history of the Institu... more This special issue of the annual report includes an overview of the 8-year history of the Institute for Oriental and European Archaeology of the Austrian Academy of Sciences with research highlights from the Palaeolithic to the early Iron Age. The research results and reports from the year 2020 are summarizing outreach activities, excavations, surveys, analyses, material studies and current publications from all groups and labs working in 17 countries. All publications of 8 years OREA institute are additionally listed at the end of the report.

Research paper thumbnail of Review - Dries Daems, Social Complexity and Complex Systems in Archaeology (Routledge, Oxon 2021)

Archaeologia Austriaca, 2021

Research paper thumbnail of Book Review. Valentine Roux, in collaboration with Courty M.-A. Ceramics and Society: A Technological Approach to Archaeological Assemblages.

European Journal of Archaeology, 2020

Research paper thumbnail of Call for Papers -Session 351 Between Style and Function: The Technology of Neolithic Pottery Finishes in SE Europe

During the Neolithic in SE Europe we see the widescale adoption of ceramic production and consump... more During the Neolithic in SE Europe we see the widescale adoption of ceramic production and consumption, as ceramics begin to play a larger role in the daily material lives of communities. This increasing importance of pottery is also paralleled by the technological advances displayed through the use and development of various surface treatments and pigments, which show the remarkable skill and knowledge obtained and shared by Neolithic craftspeople across the region. Whilst there exists excellent and thorough typological and stylistic research which has provided the foundation for the various chronological and cultural schemes developed in SE Europe, the technological "know-how" behind such developments still lacks systematic and detailed investigation. Importantly, there is a great need to bring typo-stylistic and technological approaches together as it is only through the integration of different methods to the study of pottery that we will be able to build narratives around interaction, innovation, and knowledge exchange. With this in mind the session aims to bring together a broad range of expertise from archaeology, experimental work and the natural sciences, to present research on various approaches to, and understandings of, Neolithic slips, pigments and surface treatments in SE Europe. A key goal of the session is to develop an interdisciplinary conceptual and methodological approach to the study of Neolithic pottery surface finishes in this region that goes beyond the traditional binary narratives of functional vs. decorative. It will also bridge the dichotomy between typo-stylistic and archaeometric approaches to better understand and explain characteristic finishes from a technological and functional point of view, and to examine their role in the wider chaîne opératoire of pottery production and consumption more broadly. Key themes will be the raw materials and technologies used for paints and slips, ideas around skeuomorphism and the imitation of other materials (e.g. metal or basketry), and the function and meaning of different pottery styles and treatments including elements such as residue analysis and formal stylistic approaches. Deadline: 11 February 2021 23.59 CET Details of how to submit an abstract can be found here: https://eaa.klinkhamergroup.com/eaa2021 and here https://bit.ly/38oN6F2 Due to the current world pandemic the event is planned as a hybrid meeting (in person and on-line).

Research paper thumbnail of Crafting-in-the-World CFP TAG 2012 session (deadline 27/06/12)

Please find below a call for papers for a proposed TAG session, ‘Crafting-in-the-World: the tempo... more Please find below a call for papers for a proposed TAG session, ‘Crafting-in-the-World: the temporal and spatial dynamics of craft and its practitioners’. The 34th Annual Meeting of the Theoretical Archaeology Group will be held at the University of Liverpool, United Kingdom, from the 17th-19th of December 2012. You can view the conference website at: http://www.liv.ac.uk/sace/livetag/index.htm

Abstract: Crafting-in-the-World: the temporal and spatial dynamics of craft and its practitioners.
Whilst the last two decades have witnessed a prolific interest in craft studies, which have increasingly acknowledged the sociality of craft, the role of choice, and the importance of the body in the development and transmission of craft traditions, there remains an uncomfortable dichotomy between the temporal and spatial understandings of craft practice. The abundance of existing research has traditionally focused on either describing production processes or attempted to theorise how the finished products of craft acquire meaning. The separation of object from process has resulted in the products of craft looming un-tethered to practice, devoid of spatial and temporal understandings of craft practice.
In addition and despite claims to the contrary to this, there has been little coherent collaboration between academic specialisms, which has only served to heighten the fragmented nature of craft study and impeded our understanding of the subject as a whole. In an attempt to address these issues this session will encourage multidisciplinary engagement with the topic of craft, focusing on the temporal and spatial embeddedness of craft activities; what we term Crafting-in-the-World.
We are seeking contributions that will discuss the acts and arenas of production and the reunification of products with their formative processes to embrace a holistic approach to the study of innovation, production, and consumption. To complement this we invite papers that examine the intrinsic relationship between practice and space, exploring the ways in which practice is manifested in the landscape through time, looking at both the physical remains of production and the expression of crafting traditions. Contributions addressing experimental work are particularly welcome.

Papers for the session could address the following themes:
• Reconciling continuity and change: redundancy, innovation and change (every innovation involves loss and gain); re-contextualisation of innovations; why some things change and others don’t (i.e., there is no such thing as progress).
• Spatial articulation of craft: technological ‘features’ as architecture; space shaping practices and practices shaping space; compartmentalization of space and time geographies.
• Tangled web of technological practice: communities of practice; Complementing, referencing, incorporating aspects of other crafts; mobile crafts (i.e., itinerant crafts people).

If you wish to submit to the session, please email j.slater@shef.ac.uk by the 27th of June with the following:
• Paper title (maximum of 20 words)
• Paper abstract (150 words max)
• Your name, affiliation and contact details

If you have any queries or problems, please feel free to contact us.

Clare Burke Davies & Jessica Slater
PhD candidates
Department of Archaeology, University of Sheffield

Research paper thumbnail of Tradition and Adaptation: The Potting Technology of Middle Helladic Archaia Pheneos Presented at EMAC 2019 Barcelona

Often seen as a period of cultural stagnation, the Greek Middle Bronze Age (c. 2000-1500BC) has o... more Often seen as a period of cultural stagnation, the Greek Middle Bronze Age (c. 2000-1500BC) has often been overlooked in favour of more 'exciting' periods associated with 'complex' society and social stratification. This has been particularly true for ceramic studies which have heavily relied on typological analysis and distribution patterns in order to investigate production and consumption, resulting in long held debates the locations of production, technological development and importance of particular forms and decorative styles seen to typify the period such as Grey Minyan ware. This paper will discuss the results of an integrated raw material and technological study of Middle Bronze Age pottery from the site of Archaia Pheneos, Arcadia, Mainland Greece. Using macroscopic analysis, thin section petrography and scanning electron microscopy it has been possible to identify a number of local paste recipes in use at the site, utilising a variety of clay preparation techniques, such as mixing and tempering. The results suggest the presence of multiple potters supplying the community who produced a wide range of vessel types and finishes from plain coarsewares to fine grey burnished goblets and pattern painted jars. The presence of these fabrics in samples from the Early Bronze Age and the Late Bronze Age, indicates the area sustained long held potting traditions whereby potters maintained the same basic paste recipes but adapted their chaîne opératoire in relation to the production of new shapes and styles. Importantly, this paper will also discuss the relationship between different pastes and finishing techniques to the firing conditions employed by potters, who made specific choices in relation to the surface finish/decorative style they aimed to produce. Significantly, this is a much under studied topic for Middle Helladic pottery despite the perceived importance of particular pottery classes.

Research paper thumbnail of Scale and Diversity: Examining Early Helladic Ceramic Production and Distribution in the NE Peloponnese, Greece. Paper presented at ΟΞΥΔΕΡΚΕΙΝ at Korakou: A centennial celebration of C.W. Blegen’s 1915-1916 excavations. American School of Classical Studies Athens. 4-6 September 2015.

Burke, C., Day, P.M., Hein, A. and Kilikoglou, V Immediately preceding the foundation of the Pal... more Burke, C., Day, P.M., Hein, A. and Kilikoglou, V

Immediately preceding the foundation of the Palaces of Bronze Age Greece, the third Millennium BC has received considerable attention. A key aspect of this research has been the nature of ceramic technology and its changes over time. Such work has attempted to detail and understand pottery production and its patterns of consumption, relating trends to wider discussions of societal organization and development in this formative period.

Forming part of a broader programme of analysis of Early Bronze Age ceramics from Corinthia and the Argolid, this paper will examine the results of macroscopic, petrographic and chemical analysis of Early Helladic material from several sites within the NE Peloponnese. Examining and building on our current understanding of the nature and organisation of Early Helladic production and exchange in Corinthia based upon NAA work undertaken in the 1970s (Attas 1981; Attas et al. 1987) our results have revealed significant new detail about the scale and diversity of production across the NE Peloponnese.

Of particular interest is the evidence for both localized small-scale production and exchange, alongside centres with larger scale production whose products appear to have had a broad distribution. Through detailing such technological traditions and spheres of interaction with the surrounding region, these results provide significant insights into the varied character of EH production between sites in the Corinthia and the consumption practices of small-scale communities.

Research paper thumbnail of The Final Neolithic and Early Helladic I pottery from Midea in the Argolid: Continuity and Change

Presented at The Wider Island of Pelops: A Workshop on Prehistoric Pottery in Memory of Professor Christopher Mee. The British School Athens Monday, September 18, 2017 to Tuesday, September 19, 2017

this paper discusses the Final Neolithic and Early Helladic I ceramic finds from an area of the U... more this paper discusses the Final Neolithic and Early Helladic I ceramic finds from an area of the Upper Acropolis at the site of Midea, in the NE Peloponnese, excavated by Katie Demakopoulou from 2004 till 2006. Typological analysis and radiocarbon dating has suggested that this area was in use since the late 5 th millennium BC, and the Neolithic and Early Bronze Age pottery comes from key features, specifically a Late/Final Neolithic grave, an Early Helladic I floor level, and an Early Helladic II strong wall connected with a possible feasting assemblage. This paper will provide an overview of the Neolithic and Early Helladic ceramics recovered from the site, focusing on key forms in particular, such as cheese pots, askoi and fruitstands. It will discuss the results of an integrated programme of analysis combining typological and macroscopic details of the assemblage, with analysis of raw materials (using thin section petrography) and firing technology (using SEM). This integrated approach has provided important new information about production and consumption practices over time and across the NE Peloponnese. Key amongst these results has been evidence for a move away from grog tempering between the Neolithic and Early Helladic periods, the identification of key centres of production in the region, and evidence for both shared and more localised technological practices in relation to both the choice of raw materials and firing practices.

Research paper thumbnail of Crafting Practices and Consumption Choices: Neolithic – Early Helladic II Ceramic Production and Distribution, Midea, Mainland Greece.

Forming part of a broader programme of macroscopic, petrographic, SEM, and NAA analysis of cera... more Forming part of a broader programme of macroscopic,
petrographic, SEM, and NAA analysis of ceramics from Mainland
Greece, this paper focuses on the Late Neolithic to Early Bronze II
sequence at the site of Midea in the Argolid.

Through investigating the technological variability present at
Midea, our results suggest significant differences, and continuity,
in technological choices over time. Most notable is the decline of
grog temper between the Final Neolithic and Early Bronze Age
periods. This is accompanied by the increased dominance of a
sandstone-low grade metamorphic fabric believed to originate in
the area around Asine but which appears to have been widely
distributed throughout the NE Peloponnese.

These results indicate a fundamental shift in the way potters
approached their craft between the end of the Neolithic and the
early stages of the Bronze Age. Significant changes not only in
specific technological choices but also in the scale of production
and exchange, suggest the emergence of particular production
areas and increased interaction between communities over time.

Research paper thumbnail of Settlement Scale, Pottery Production and Patterns of Consumption in Early Helladic Korinthia and the Argolid.

The third millennium BC in the Aegean has received considerable attention in attempts to explain ... more The third millennium BC in the Aegean has received considerable attention in attempts to explain the rise of palatial centers, which emerged during the second millennium, focusing on changes in craft technology and specialization as an impetus for societal change.
However, this narrative of change has been constructed at the expense of a coherent picture of the character of Early Bronze Age crafting practices and the degree of interaction between communities. The present project examines ceramic material culture in Early Bronze Age of Mainland Greece. In work which integrates macroscopic, petrographic, chemical and SEM analysis of Early Helladic II ceramics from Korinthia and the Argolid, it examines the varied ceramic landscape of these areas, relating new understandings of provenance and technology to issues of scale, both in terms of settlement size and craft production.
Building on previous work by NAA, undertaken by Michael Attas, we suggest instances of localized small-scale production and juxtapose these with evidence of larger scale production in some centres, whose products have a broad distribution.

Research paper thumbnail of Crafting Choices: Early Helladic Ceramic Production and Consumption in Corinthia and the Argolid, Greece

A key aspect for research in Early Bronze Age Greece has been the nature of ceramic technology an... more A key aspect for research in Early Bronze Age Greece has been the nature of ceramic technology and its changes over time. Such work has attempted to detail and understand pottery production and its patterns of consumption, relating trends to wider discussions of societal organization and development in this formative period.

Forming part of a broader program of analysis of EBA pottery from the Corinthia and Argolid, this paper examines the results of macroscopic and petrographic analysis of ceramics from Early Helladic Tsoungiza, Nemea, a large fill in Ancient Corinth, the Sanctuary of Apollo Maleatas at Epidauros, and finally the sites of Delpriza and Agios Pandeleimon in the Southern Argolid. This analysis builds on previous chemical analyses by Michael Attas in these regions and has enabled the reconstruction of EH technological choices and practices, thus revealing important information about the development of craft practices in these areas.

EH pottery production is shown to have taken place in the vicinity of all the sites under consideration and to have been characterized by specific fabric recipes of each site. Some locations demonstrate clear change between EHI and II, while both Tsoungiza give a flavour of the substantial changes in ceramic technology by the EHIII period.

Of great interest are the scale and diversity of production within each community, which appear to have differed considerably. This is exemplified through different trajectories of technological development and exchange. Some sites, such as Tsoungiza, in EHII move to rather homogeneous crafting practices with a limited number of producers, but contain regional and supra-regional imports (most notably from Aegina). Others, such as Ancient Corinth, appear to be characterized by a number of variant paste recipes, which derive from local sources and may reflect a larger number of workshops or a greater scale of production.

These trends are cross-cut by evidence for shared technological behaviors such as the mixing of calcareous and non-calcareous clays, particularly for Urfirnis ware, and the wide appearance of products of particular recipe tradition or workshops across sites, such as the use of siltstone-based fabrics. Through detailing such technological traditions, their diachronic alteration and spheres of interaction with the surrounding region, these results provide insights into the varied character of EH production between sites in the Corinthia and Argolid and the consumption practices of small-scale communities.

Research paper thumbnail of The Early Helladic Ceramics of Korinthia: An Integrated Approach

Forming part of a broader programme of analysis of Early Bronze Age ceramics from Korinthia and t... more Forming part of a broader programme of analysis of Early Bronze Age ceramics from Korinthia and the Argolid, this paper will examine the results of macroscopic, petrographic and SEM analysis of samples from sites within Korinthia, mainland Greece. It will discuss our current understanding of the nature and organisation of Early Helladic production and exchange based upon NAA work undertaken in the 1970s (Attas 1981; Attas et al. 1987) and the contribution that the present integrated analytical programme can make to discussions of ceramic technology and patterns of consumption.

Research paper thumbnail of Archaeometry Poster 2012 Please do not cite without consent

Immediately preceding the founda4on of the palaces of Bronze Age Greece, the third millennium BC ... more Immediately preceding the founda4on of the palaces of Bronze Age Greece, the third millennium BC has received considerable a>en4on. A key aspect of this research has been the intense discussion of the nature of and changes within ceramic technology across the Aegean. Such work has commonly a>empted to detail and understand po>ery produc4on and pa>erns of consump4on in rela4on to wider discussions of societal development and complexity (cf. Renfrew 1972; A>as et al. 1987).

Research paper thumbnail of Introduction to Petrography Short Course September 2016

A call for applications to the petrography short course being held at the University of Sheffield... more A call for applications to the petrography short course being held at the University of Sheffield, Department of Archaeology, rated the 13th best Archaeology department in the world.

Research paper thumbnail of Raw Material Lab 2020

In: B. Horejs (Ed.), 8 years of OREA - Institute for Oriental and European Archaeology Annual Report 2020, 141-148

Research paper thumbnail of Crafting and Consumption Choices: Neolithic – Early Helladic II Ceramic Production and Distribution, Midea and Tiryns, Mainland Greece

Eva Alram-Stern – Barbara Horejs (Eds.) Pottery Technologies and Sociocultural Connections Between the Aegean and Anatolia During the 3rd Millennium BC, 2018

This paper will discuss some of the key results of petrographic analysis undertaken on LN–EH II c... more This paper will discuss some of the key results of petrographic analysis undertaken on LN–EH II ceramic
material from the site of Midea. Through examination of the petrological and technological variability present at Midea, our results suggest both continuity and significant changes in technological practice, distribution trends and consumption choices over time. Key amongst our results has been the identification of a fabric characterised by sandstone and low-grade metamorphic rocks, thought to originate in the area of the Talioti Valley, and indicating the presence of a major centre of production in the Argolid. Other fabrics testify to shared technological traditions and raw material choices across the northeastern Peloponnese, which have a very long history of use. Significant changes are presented, not only in specific technological choices, but also in the distribution of vessels from particular production centres. These reflect increased interaction between communities in the Argolid and Corinthia over time.

Research paper thumbnail of 2018   Clare BURKE, Peter M. Day, Eva Alram-Stern, Katie Demakopoulou and Anno Hein. Crafting and Consumption Choices: Neolithic – Early Helladic II Ceramic Production and Distribution, Midea and Tiryns, Mainland Greece ()

in Alram-Stern, E. and B. Horejs (eds.) Pottery Technologies and Sociocultural Connections Between the Aegean and Anatolia During the 3rd Millennium BC, 2018

This paper discusses some of the key results of petrographic analysis undertaken on LN–EH II cera... more This paper discusses some of the key results of petrographic analysis undertaken on LN–EH II ceramic material from the site of Midea. Through examination of the petrological and technological variability present at Midea, our results suggest both continuity and significant changes in technological practice, distribution trends and consumption choices over time. Key amongst our results has been the identification of a fabric characterised by sandstone and low-grade metamorphic rocks, thought to originate in the area of the Talioti Valley, and indicating the presence of a major centre of production in the Argolid. Other fabrics testify to shared technological traditions and raw material choices across the northeastern Peloponnese, which have a very long history of use. Significant changes are presented, not only in specific technological choices, but also in the distribution of vessels from particular production centres. These reflect increased interaction between communities in the Argolid and Corinthia over time.

Keywords: Neolithic, Early Helladic, petrography, ceramics, technological tradition, northeastern Peloponnese

Research paper thumbnail of 2020   Clare BURKE, Peter M. Day and Angeliki Kossyva 2020. Early Helladic I and Talioti Pottery: is it just a phase we’re going through? Oxford Journal of Archaeology 39 (1) 19-40. ABSTRACT

Burke, Clare, Peter M. Day and Aggeliki Kossyva, 2020

This paper discusses the analysis of Early Bronze Age 'Talioti'-style ceramics found at sites in ... more This paper discusses the analysis of Early Bronze Age 'Talioti'-style ceramics found at sites in the Argolid and Corinthia, in the north-east Peloponnese of mainland Greece. It presents the results of an integrated methodology that addresses questions relating to the potential sources of raw materials, the identification of potting practices, and the exchange of such vessels during the Early Bronze Age period. The work places site-based results within a broader spatial and temporal context, specifically examining how this characteristic ceramic assemblage has been used as a chronological and cultural marker for the Early Bronze Age 1 (EB I) period in the north-east Peloponnese. We argue that 'Talioti' pottery comprises the outcome of specific sets of knowledge, reputation and social practice in both its production and consumption, and that it is the determination of the location and method of production that allows an effective understanding of its chronological and spatial distribution. The case study is used to critically assess cultural and chronological interpretation of typological studies of ceramics, arguing that analytical understandings of provenance and technology are now fundamental to understanding both cultural identity and the passage of time.

Research paper thumbnail of 2016    Clare BURKE et al. The Contribution of Petrography to Understanding the Production and Consumption of Early Helladic Ceramics from Nemea, Mainland Greece

In M. Ownby, S. Kelly, M. Massucci and I. Druc (eds.) Integrative Approaches in Ceramic Petrography. University of Utah Press, Salt Lake City., Oct 2016

Research paper thumbnail of When the ‘package’ hit the mountains: Emergence of Neolithic foodways in the central Balkan highlands

27th EAA Annual Meeting, 2021

Elements of the southwest Asian Neolithic 'package' appeared in the central Balkans at the end of... more Elements of the southwest Asian Neolithic 'package' appeared in the central Balkans at the end of 7th/start of 6th millennium BC. Northeast of the Axios/Vardar course-a corridor of Asia-to-Europe cultural transfers-the package hit the mountains of southern Serbia, the narrow valleys of the Južna (South) Morava river and its tributaries, and a more continental climate. Settling into these environments likely entailed adjustments in the behaviour of humans, domesticates and crops. Perhaps this partly explains why, apparently, only few Neolithic groups initially resided here and, unsurprisingly, near the rivers, where sources of food and raw materials would have been plentiful and sustenance secured even without, or with very limited, farming and herding.