Challenges and Prospects of Implementation of ISO 9001:2015 in TVET Institutions: The Case of Nkabune Technical Training Institute (original) (raw)
Related papers
The new management system ISO 21001:2018: What and whyeducational organizations should adopt it
2018
The International Organization for Standardization (ISO) recently published a new management system standard ISO 21001:2018. This standard outlines the requirements for educational organizations and is intended for such organizations than the more commonly used ISO 9001:2015 quality management system. This paper aims to compare both standards and study their similarities and differences to evaluate whether the new standard is more suitable for educational organizations. After employing qualitative analysis to directly compare the two standards in terms of breadth, depth and terminologies, it was found that while both standards use the same high-level structure, ISO 21001:2018 is broader and deeper than ISO 9001:2015 with more lower-level clauses. The terms used in the new standard are also very specific for education such as learner, curriculum, courses, learning outcomes, assessment, grades, etc. In addition, it also acknowledges that the customers of education are actively involve...
Critical Analysis of the Applicability of the ISO 9001 Standard in Higher Education Institutions
International Journal of African Higher Education
This paper analyses the applicability of the ISO 9001 standard in higher education institutions (HEIs). The ISO 9001standard, initially developed for application in industry, sets the requirements for implementing a quality management system (QMS) in an organisation. Over the years, the standard has been adapted to the higher education (HE) sector as a model for quality assurance and enhancement. In this study, the standard is analysed based on a framework with the following variables; 1) Importance of the philosophy of the standard in HE, 2) Suitability to HE, 3) Ease of implementation, 4) Effect on quality assurance and enhancement and 5) Effect on quality culture. The mechanisms of how the standard affects quality management are also presented. The analysis shows that ISO 9001 is based on a philosophy that resonates with general approaches to quality assurance in HEIs. The seven principles of the standard provide a good base for an effective QMS. The standard is suitable to HEIs ...
Iso 9001 in Educational Organizations: International Implementation Experiences
INTED2016 Proceedings, 2016
The ISO 9001 standards were developed to achieve the customer satisfaction. The ISO 9001standard is the most popular standard of quality management system around the world wide organizations. The purpose of this research study is to evaluate the diverse barriers that impede implementation of ISO 9001 within service and manufacturing industries in Pakistan through an empirical study. To conduct this study a long literature review was carried out and relevant information has been collected to collect the data. In order to conduct this study a questionnaire was the main research instrument. This research has been starting with a questionnaire which is same for service and manufacturing industries and designed on online "Google form application software". This questionnaire was distributed in service and manufacturing industries within Pakistan. Systematically the result of response were collected from Google drive sheet and analysis of the survey revealed that main barriers for implementing ISO 9001 are an absence of understanding the advantages of ISO 9001 confirmation, lack of involvement and empowerment of employees, lack of reward and motivation system, ineffective performance measurement system, lack of focus to implement PDCA (Plan/Do/Check/Act) cycle for continuous improvement, and lack of decision making on the base of collected data while the average of average responses shows that the most critical principle of quality management system are leadership and involvement of people.
Awareness and Challenges of ISO 9001:2015 Implementation in Higher Education
International Journal of Academe and Industry Research, 2022
This study assessed the awareness on the implementation of International Organization Standardization (ISO) 9001: 2015 in a university and the challenges encountered by the key stakeholders. It also tested the correlation of respondents' demographic profile to the level of awareness and challenges. The study used a descriptive research design and convenience sampling technique with a total of 100 survey participants from senior officials, professors, faculty, and non-faculty personnel. To collect responses, the study used structured survey questionnaire distributed through Google Forms. Descriptive statistics such as frequency count, percentage, and weighted mean as well as Spearman were used for data analysis. The results of the study showed that employees are 'Fully Aware' and 'Aware' on the implementation of ISO 9001:2015, particularly in terms of the quality mission, vision, and objectives. However, employees "Disagree" with the various challenges in the implementation of ISO 9001: 2015. In addition, there was no significant relationship among the respondents' profile, awareness and challenges in the implementation of ISO 9001: 2015 at the university. The study found that while university employees are usually aware of the quality management system's fundamental objectives, they normally disagree on the challenges of putting it into practice. For this, information dissemination should be done on a regular basis while the employees are obliged to also internalize the university's quality management system's vision, mission, and objectives.
Handbook of Research on Quality Assurance and Value Management in Higher Education
It is clear that ISO 9000 Quality Management System and Total Quality Management have an extensive literature. However, it is observed that the literature principally focuses on implementation consequences of them. In this study, ISO 9000 Quality Management System certification process in a faculty of a Turkish public university is taken into consideration. However, the study focuses on not only consequences of taking this certification but also its' triggers and processes. To examine these triggers, processes and consequences, data collection methods of the study were semi-structured interviews and unstructured participative observation. In addition, extensive amount of document was used to make triangulation.
Nowadays, in order to satisfy the ISO 9001: 2015 requirements, organizations access to information from web sites, consultant guides, Internet forums, books, and courses, as a first approximation, however, the quality, reliability, validity, and accuracy of the information content in these is limited. The research topic of this study is the use of theoretical methodological tools, whose implementation supports the organizations in the fulfillment of requirement 4 of ISO 9001: 2015, adapting it to their particular needs, minimizing rework in the documentation, increasing the motivation of the personnel involved and promoting well-being within the work environment. Some theoretical methodological tools were implemented in the case of Engineering laboratories of the Faculty of Higher Studies Aragón, that support and complement the teaching-learning process in the theoretical-practical subjects of the curricula of the engineering bachelor's degrees, providing students with practical training in the use of equipment, devices, and tools, as well as extracurricular courses. In the study participated the stakeholders of laboratories. From the results, it was observed that the time for the documentation of the quality management system was reduced using the theoretical tools proposed in this study. In conclusion, this study will thus be useful as a starting point in using formal tools for the implementation of ISO 9001: 2015 standard.
Nuninger, W. and Chatelet, J. (Ed.) (2016). Handbook of Research on Quality Assurance and Value Management in Higher Education , 2016
It is clear that ISO 9000 Quality Management System and Total Quality Management have an extensive literature. However, it is observed that the literature principally focuses on implementation consequences of them. In this study, ISO 9000 Quality Management System certification process in a faculty of a Turkish public university is taken into consideration. However, the study focuses on not only consequences of taking this certification but also its' triggers and processes. To examine these triggers, processes and consequences, data collection methods of the study were semi-structured interviews and unstructured participative observation. In addition, extensive amount of document was used to make triangulation.
Advantages of Implementig Quality Management System in Higher Education
Researchers World : Journal of Arts, Science and Commerce, 2017
The Quality Management System "QMS" has become a common choice of strategic management tools in the higher education setting. Consequently, implementation of QMS is critical in confirming the effective and efficient implementation of work process and procedures to achieve the college goal to provide the educational services to various stakeholders. The main purpose is to study the implementation of ISO and the benefits that the department has gained from implementing the system. Consequently to help colleges/universities in implementing QMS. Finally, to examine implementation of QMS as a real time solution to maintain accurate documentation and records. This paper presents description of the process of implementing quality management system according to ISO 9001: 2008 standard, which has the noteworthy impact on improving the quality of delivery of education. This research presents the reasons that necessitate a system for standardization of the processes within any educational department and the steps taken in the implementation of a quality server for distribution, monitoring and collecting documents and guidelines. In this study, descriptive approach was used through field survey that was associated with a guided and quick collection, analysis and interpretation of observation. The results of this research provided valued insight into the potential application of ISO 9001:2000 to our college and other educational organizations as a methodology for continuous improvement of student satisfaction of the delivered services. Results showed increase in students' satisfaction with business department management and delivery of education by faculty. Faculties in the business department adopted the QMS and utilize the system in areas of communicating effectively with higher management, standardizing the course delivery, and documentation of needed resources of each course regularly. The implementation of quality management systems requires continuous effort, sustained leadership, and the long term commitment of resources and regular auditing of performance. It also provides significant implications for practitioners and academics to facilitate the implementation of ISO 9000. This study adds to the body of knowledge concerning implementation of ISO 9000 in an educational institution. It also contributes to the development of the literature by providing a set of motivation factors and of critical success factors that can assist practitioners to effectively implement the standard.
2017
This study sought to determine the quality management system of the Northern Negros State College of Science and Technology (NONESCOST) as basis for International Organization for Standardization (ISO) Certification. The descriptive method of research was used in this study. It utilized the ISO 9001:2008 Quality Management System Requirements Checklist and the Questionnaires on the Attitudes towards ISO 9001. The study utilized a descriptive research design.. Findings revealed that the attitude of administrators, teaching personnel and administrative staff’ towards ISO 9001 in terms of benefits, challenges, recommendations and standards did not differ significantly. Findings further revealed that the employees have mostly positive perceptions of ISO 9001, resulting in positive attitudes in the workplace. Findings also revealed that the extent of conformance to the ISO 9001:2008 (QMS) Requirements in the areas of Quality Management System, Management Responsibility, Resource Manageme...
Int'l Journal of Management Innovation Systems, 2018
In this study, the ISO Quality Management System and the benefits of the standards of this system to the education sector are exemplified through two high schools. These standards are used in the first high school in the article which examines the benefits of ISO 9001 applications to educational institutions, but not in the other. The general purpose of the study is to explain the benefits and effects of the ISO 9001: 2015 Quality Management System standards to all ISO certified training institutions in the world. In the article, a comparative study has been carried out over 2 different high schools affiliated to the Ronaki Duhok Education Company and the compliance of the standards and the benefits are provided to the readers. According to the results of the analysis, it has been revealed with examples that ISO 9001: 2015 contributes to education institutions in many positive ways.