Ancient Near Eastern Religions Research Papers (original) (raw)
Most scholars in the late 20th and early 21st century believed that cultic activity in the kingdoms of Israel and Judah was practiced in various temples that were scattered throughout the kingdoms. Still, a detailed study of the... more
Most scholars in the late 20th and early 21st century believed that cultic activity in the kingdoms of Israel and Judah was practiced in various temples that were scattered throughout the kingdoms. Still, a detailed study of the archaeological evidence on Israelite cult reveals that Israelite cultic buildings were extremely rare, both in absolute terms and when compared to other ancient Near Eastern societies, suggesting that cultic activity in temples was the exception rather than the norm and that typical Israelite cult was practiced in the household and in other, non-temple settings. Hence, the evidence suggests that rather than viewing temples, like the one in Arad, as exemplifying typical cultic activity, they should be viewed as exceptions that require a special explanation. The first part of the article develops and updates the suggestion, first raised about ten years ago, that Israelite temples were indeed extremely rare. Given the ancient Near Eastern context, however, such practices seems to be exceptional, and the second part of the article will therefore explain why was such a unique pattern not identified in the past, and will suggest a possible explanation as to how was such an outstanding practice developed and adopted.
This paper examines the demons Pazuzu and Lamaštu from a cognitive science perspective. As hybrid creatures, the iconography of these demons combines an array of anthropomorphic and zoomorphic properties, and is therefore marked by a high... more
This paper examines the demons Pazuzu and Lamaštu from a cognitive science perspective. As hybrid creatures, the iconography of these demons combines an array of anthropomorphic and zoomorphic properties, and is therefore marked by a high degree of conceptual complexity. In a technical sense, they are what cognitive researchers refer to as radically "counterintuitive " representations. However, highly complex religious concepts are difficult in terms of cognitive processing, memory, and transmission , and, as a result, are prone to being spontaneously simplified in structure. Accordingly, there is reason to expect that the material images of Pazuzu and Lamaštu differed from the corresponding mental images of these demons. Specifically, it is argued here that in ancient cognition and memory, the demons would have been represented in a more cognitively optimal manner. This hypothesis is further supported by a detailed consideration of the full repertoire of iconographic and textual sources.
In this study, I argue that the literary depictions and iconographic images of wings on various hybrid creatures are a means of depicting that creature’s association with wind and the cardinal directions, and that recognizing this... more
In this study, I argue that the literary depictions and iconographic images of wings on various hybrid creatures are a means of depicting that creature’s association with wind and the cardinal directions, and that recognizing this correlation offers greater insight into the function and meaning of these creatures in the written and iconographic records generally. As such, I intend to add to our increasing awareness of the close relationship between textual and iconographic motifs in the ancient Near East. Furthermore, I contend that attention to the number of wings a creature possesses informs our understanding of the entity’s perceived cosmological abilities.
For about 150 years, scholars have attempted to identify the language of the world’s first alphabetic script, and to translate some of the inscriptions that use it. Until now, their attempts have accomplished little more than identifying... more
For about 150 years, scholars have attempted to identify the language of the world’s first alphabetic script, and to translate some of the inscriptions that use it. Until now, their attempts have accomplished little more than identifying most of the pictographic letters and translating a few of the Semitic words. With the publication of The World’s Oldest Alphabet, a new day has dawned. All of the disputed letters have been resolved, while the language has been identified conclusively as Hebrew, allowing for the translation of 16 inscriptions that date from 1842–1446 BC. These inscriptions expressly name 3 biblical figures and greatly illuminate the earliest Israelite history in a way that no other book has achieved, apart from the Bible.
A Safaitic inscription accompanied by seven dots (NE Jordan). Photo: A. Al-Jallad 86 Rock art depicting a Demogorgon-like figure (NE Jordan). Photo: A. Al-Jallad 86 bess19 1 102 Location of bess19 1 near the bend in the wadi 102 Team... more
A Safaitic inscription accompanied by seven dots (NE Jordan). Photo: A. Al-Jallad 86 Rock art depicting a Demogorgon-like figure (NE Jordan). Photo: A. Al-Jallad 86 bess19 1 102 Location of bess19 1 near the bend in the wadi 102 Team surveying the site of bess19 2 103 bess19 2a 104 bess19 2b 114 Overview of the nfs site looking southwest 115 View of the nfs site looking northeast 115 Enclosure South 116 Enclosure North 116 bess19 9-10 in context between the stone enclosures 117 bess19 3 118 bess19 4 119 bess19 5 120 bess19 6 120
- by Réka Esztári and +1
- •
- Assyriology, History of Religion, Divination, Ancient Near East
- by John C Franklin and +2
- •
- Philology, Religion, Ancient Egyptian Religion, Sumerian Religion
A Critical Research Involving the form and Content of Hittite Treaties and its similarities as Archaeological Evidence for the Structures Found in Biblical Covenants throughout the Old Testament. The Influence of Pagan Legality which... more
A Critical Research Involving the form and Content of Hittite Treaties and its similarities as Archaeological Evidence for the Structures Found in Biblical Covenants throughout the Old Testament. The Influence of Pagan Legality which influenced Hebrew Religious Culture as demonstrated in Old Testament Studies.
- by Lorenzo Verderame and +1
- •
- Sumerian Religion, Egyptology, Assyriology, Hittitology
This thesis explores a specific form of representation from the Syrian Bronze Age: aniconic standing-stones, lacking inscriptions or decorations. These have been mainly studied from the point of view of texts which mention cult activity... more
This thesis explores a specific form of representation from the Syrian Bronze Age: aniconic standing-stones, lacking inscriptions or decorations. These have been mainly studied from the point of view of texts which mention cult activity associated with them, but there has been heretofore no integrated analysis of archaeological finds, analysing architecture and associated material culture in comparison to texts. I will interpret litholatry (the cult of standing-stones) from the point of view of the influence of semi-nomadic pastoralists from the Syrian desert frontier on the culture of urban societies, and of the negotiation of urban/tribal identities of city kings through ritual.
The Hittite text KUB 17.35 i 17'-37' (CTH 525) is part of a tablet belonging to the genre of cult-inventories. 1 Cult inventories are among the numerous tablets regarding the cult, which were found mainly in Ùattu±a, as well as in a few... more
The Hittite text KUB 17.35 i 17'-37' (CTH 525) is part of a tablet belonging to the genre of cult-inventories. 1 Cult inventories are among the numerous tablets regarding the cult, which were found mainly in Ùattu±a, as well as in a few other sites outside the capital. Most of the tablets were brought together by Laroche in the CTH under numbers 501-530. KUB 17.35 is one of the inventory texts from the time of TudÒaliya IV, dating to the end of the 13th century. The texts record materials for the cult (such as offerings, and cult objects) and temple personnel, and include descriptions of temple functions, especially festivals. The inventory texts therefore include important information about the cult and its institutions. The aim of this paper is to offer an interpretation of the rite described in the Hittite text KUB 17.35 i 17'-37' under the name EZEN 4 pula±. By relating it to other Hittite texts and by comparing it with the installation text of a priestess in Emar, to which it reveals striking correspondences, it may be interpreted as the rites surrounding the appointment and installation of a new priest. * This article is based on part of my PhD dissertation, being written under the guidance of Prof. Avigdor (Victor) Hurowitz of Ben Gurion University and Prof. Theo van den Hout of the University of Chicago.
On se propose ici de présenter un intéressant objet en plomb, inédit jusqu'à présent, qui a été trouvé au cours des années 80 dans les alentours de la ville d'Ibiza, parait-il, non pas loin du site de Puig d'en Valls, qui est aussi très... more
On se propose ici de présenter un intéressant objet en plomb, inédit jusqu'à présent, qui a été trouvé au cours des années 80 dans les alentours de la ville d'Ibiza, parait-il, non pas loin du site de Puig d'en Valls, qui est aussi très connu dans la bibliographie phénicienne punique. La trouvaille a été faite lors de recherches, hors de contrôle officiel, à l'aide de détecteurs de métaux. Cette pièce, qui reste encore en mains privées, a pu tout de même être documentée et l'endroit de sa trouvaille, malgré sans d'autres précisions, située à peu de kilomètres au N de la ville d'Ibiza, dans des champs où on y pratiquait traditionnellement la culture.
Proceedings of the second seminar, entitled "Gods at the Borders" (fall 2018), of the ERC Advanced Grant “Mapping Ancient Polytheisms – Cult Epithets as an Interface between Religious Systems and Human Agency”. Fabio Porzia & Sylvain... more
Proceedings of the second seminar, entitled "Gods at the Borders" (fall 2018), of the ERC Advanced Grant “Mapping Ancient Polytheisms – Cult Epithets as an Interface between Religious Systems and Human Agency”.
Fabio Porzia & Sylvain Lebreton, "“Noms de dieux!” Gods at the borders" (p. 221-224); Alice Mouton, "Nommer les dieux hittites : au sujet de quelques épithètes divines" (p. 225-243); Gian Franco Chiai, "Le culte de Zeus Brontôn : l’espace et la morphologie du dieu de l’orage dans la Phrygie d’époque romaine" (p. 245-275); Françoise Van Haeperen, "Séquences onomastiques divines à Ostie-Portus" (p. 277-308).
Tra i grandi momenti storici che hanno conferito alla nostra civiltà la sua configurazione attuale, sono soprattutto da segnalare le due grandi fasi designate con il nome di "rivoluzione": la "rivoluzione neolitica" e la "rivoluzione... more
Tra i grandi momenti storici che hanno conferito alla nostra civiltà la sua configurazione attuale, sono soprattutto da segnalare le due grandi fasi designate con il nome di "rivoluzione": la "rivoluzione neolitica" e la "rivoluzione urbana".
Das Pittei-Ritual KUB 44.4 + KBo 13.241 Rs. mit dem Titel o'wenn (eine Frau) mit einem Kind schwanger geht" (man ouut-an armaizzi) gehórt ohne Zweifel zl den sprachlich und inhaltlich interessantesten Texten der altanatolischen magischen... more
Das Pittei-Ritual KUB 44.4 + KBo 13.241 Rs. mit dem Titel o'wenn (eine Frau) mit einem Kind schwanger geht" (man ouut-an armaizzi) gehórt ohne Zweifel zl den sprachlich und inhaltlich interessantesten Texten der altanatolischen magischen Literaturr. Der Text, der auf der Rùckseite einer groBen, einkolumnigen Tafel steht und nach palàographischen und sprachlichen Kriterien ins 13. Jh. v. Chr. gehórt2, ist stark verderbt und von Luwismen durchsetzt3, die an mehreren Stellen sein Verstàndnis erschweren. Er besteht aus zwei Beschwórungen (Rs. 2-17 bzw. Rs. 22-34), die durch einen Paragraphenstrich getrennt sind. Im folgenden móchte ich nach einer ausfiihrlichen philologischen Analyse des Textes auf die Frage nach Struktur und Inhalt der zwei Beschwórungen eingehen, eine neue Deutung des Inhalts der ersten vorschlagen, und am Ende das Problem eines móglichen Verhàltnisses zwischen beiden Bestandteilen des Textes kurz besprechen. Von KUB 44.4 + KBo 13.241Rs. liegen bereits zwei ausgezeichnete Umschriften vora. Ich biete daher hier nur eine neue Ùbersetzungs und einen Kommentar, in dem ich besonders die Stellen erórtere, an denen meine Interpretation von jener G. Beckmans und anderer Forscher abweicht. Úbersetzung '[FolgendermaBen (spricht]) Pittei: Wenn (eine Frau) mit einem Kind schwanger geht -'zDer [Him]mel bekleidete sich. mit schwarzen (Kleidem), mit duwija'1(-KIeidem) bekleid(ete) er sich, und der Mond bekleid(ete sich) mit blutfarbigen (Kleiì Textbearbeitung: G. Beckman, StBoT 29 (Wiesbaden 1983) L76-I99;Transkription und ìnhaltliche Bemerkungen: F. Starke, StBoT 30 (Wiesbaden 1985) 208 ff.,233-236. '?Vgl. Beckman, StBoT 29, 180. 3 Der Text ist zwar hethitisch abgefafJt, enthàlt aber viele luwische Formen, so daB eine Herkunft aus dem Luwischen wahrscheinlich ist (vgl. Beckman, StBoT 29, 180). Deswegen hat F. Starke ihn in sein Corpus der keilschrift-luwischen Texte aufgenommen. a Beckman, StBoT 29, 176 ff.; Starke, StBoT 30, 233 ff. 5 Die vielen Textemendationen habe ich durch spitze Klammem gekennzeichnet. Orientalia -35
In the Epic of Gilgamesh, Gilgamesh interacts with three goddesses: Ninsun, his mother and a goddess renowned for her wisdom, Ishtar, the goddess of love and sexuality, and Siduri, a minor goddess of wisdom. This article will investigate... more
In the Epic of Gilgamesh, Gilgamesh interacts with three goddesses: Ninsun, his mother and a goddess renowned for her wisdom, Ishtar, the goddess of love and sexuality, and Siduri, a minor goddess of wisdom. This article will investigate Gilgamesh's interactions and relations with these goddesses. How do these goddesses reveal or present themselves to Gilgamesh? How do the goddesses communicate with Gilgamesh, and how does he interact with them? The manner in which these interactions take place in the Standard Version of the Epic will be compared to the same episodes in the earlier Old Babylonian Version of the Epic and the Sumerian narratives in order to identify changes across time. Finally, how do these interactions differ from the way in which Gilgamesh interacts with male gods in the Epic of Gilgamesh? These various interactions will be compared and analysed to reveal not only similarities and differences in the way Gilgamesh communicates with the goddesses in the Epic of Gilgamesh, but also crucial differences in the manner in which male and female deities reveal themselves and communicate with Gilgamesh.
The Harappan seals contain several linguistic symbols which have not been properly understood so far.Through my works especially- Indus script decipherment breakthrough, PaNameTa-the troy tower weight and measure system of Harappa, The... more
The Harappan seals contain several linguistic symbols which have not been properly understood so far.Through my works especially- Indus script decipherment breakthrough, PaNameTa-the troy tower weight and measure system of Harappa, The Harappan Symbol Of
Man+ Trident And Its Relation To Kausika Visvamitra And The Kalinga Malla MeTas( Tower Weights), The Harappan Unicorn And The Kalinga Malla MeTas(Tower Weights) , The Harappan Symbol Of Intersecting Circles And Its Relation To Kausika Visvamitra And The Kalinga Malla MeTas( Tower weights), The Harappan Contest Motif Of Nude Man With Six Locks Of Hair Fighting Two Tigers And Its Relation To The Kalinga Malla MeTas( Tower Weights), The Harappan symbols of Roots, Nuts And Cocks And Their Relation To Kausika Visvamitra And The Kalinga Malla MeTas( Tower weights), Identification Of KaNva In The Indus Script, Identification Of Troy In The Indus script,Identification Of Barley And Mustard In The Indus Script, Krishna’s Mathura And Dvaraka In The Indus Script, The Pinna In The Indus Script, The Identity Of Vedic Sarasvati And The Location Of Krishna’s Dvaraka, Identification Of Vedic Bharadvaja In The Indus Script, Krishna’s Dvaraka In The Indus Script, One Symbol Of Indus Script Can Tell A Lot About The Indus Valley Civilisation, The Identity Of Kasyapa In The Indus Valley And Sumeria, Kusa -The Son Of Rama-In Mesopotamia(Sumer),Indus -Sumer Trade, A Few “Copper” Names In The Indus Script, Janaka-King Of Mithila-In The Indus Script,The Vedic Asvins, Yama And Kartikeya In The Indus Script, The Goddess Sarasvati And The Origin Of Brahmi And Kharoshthi, The Origin Of The Roman Aes Grave From The Indus Valley Money, A Solution To The Mystery Of The Gundestrup Cauldron, The Eternal Soma Of The Vedas, Vedic Roots Of Ancient Egyptian Religion -
I have shown that several seals contain vedic metrological terms,names of vedic ornaments,names of people, places and gods etc. My perception is that only a comprehensive study of ancient vedic metrology can decipher the script symbols satisfactorily. A significant find herein is the existence of the Kalinga malla mana system during Harappan times challenging the common perception of its origin from the later Kalinga kingdom(Orissa).The unicorn is identified as the pala/nishka.Intersecting circles, fish , crab,bud,tower signs also have the same indications.The six locks of hair indicate the paNameTa weight of six barley grains.Roots and nuts indicate viira bhadra/ Drupada/ varaha/pala.We have located Lord Krishna’s Mathura and Dvaraka in the Indus valley scripts.
We have confirmed Mohenjodaro as the first Dvaraka
on the basis of the inscription on the copperplate B7C2 from there and textual evidences from the Rgveda, Mahabharata etc.We have located PadmakuuTa,one of the
palaces of Krishna there.Also we have identified the Sindhu(Indus) as the Vedic Sarasvati river.We have gone through the symbols identifying the Bharadvajas,the clan of composers of the earliest vedic texts.In Krishna’s Dvaraka we gathered more details from the script on Lord Krishna’s Dvaraka and Sindhu/Sarasvati. We have looked into the
indications of the Harappan jar symbol with three forks on each edge.We have located the Kasyapas in Hastinapura
trading with Sumeria.We have decoded the Mari Standard,went deeper into the meanings of several Sumerian images and confirmed Meluhha as Vedic Harappa/Indus valley. We have located Janaka,the king of Mithila,father-in-law of Rama, in the Indus script.We have identified the names of copper in the Indus script and located the Asvins,Yama and Skanda in the Indus script.In A Model For Indus Script Decipherment
we have identified the deity in the seal M-1181 and built a model for complete decipherment of the Indus script.
We have seen how Brahmi and Kharoshthi evolved from the Indus Script and how the Indus script was in use along with Brahmi/Kharoshthi even into the first centuries CE.We have seen how the coins of the ancient world,including the Roman coins evolved from the Indus valley money.
We have looked for and located a Rosetta Stone for the Indus script, in the varaha/gadyanaka coin form.
We have gone into the relation of the Druids to the Indus valley civilisation and the role of their Gundestrup cauldron
in the evolution of Christianity.
We have explored the relation of the Anau seal to the Indus Valley Civilisation.
We have studied the vedic soma and its importance in the life of the Harappans.
We have gone into the relationship of the Egyptian and Harappan deities.
In this article we are looking into a story from the New Testament which will help us understand the nature of the Indus symbols even better.
ABSTRACT: The following 83 questions follow the documentary (no.7), National Geographic, Quest for the Phoenicians (55 minutes). It is a good documentary detailing diverse aspects of the heritage and achievements of the Phoenicians: WEB... more
ABSTRACT: The following 83 questions follow the documentary (no.7), National Geographic, Quest for the Phoenicians (55 minutes). It is a good documentary detailing diverse aspects of the heritage and achievements of the Phoenicians: WEB LINK: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uBObLQZdeq8. The question sheet aids in furnishing a summary of the documentary's coverage and sequence of specific topics. The documentary introduces the Phoenicians' Canaanite background, geographic dispersal and trading network, and legacy via mostly hostile and biased Greek and Roman accounts. The film's focus includes and interweaves (1) R. Ballard's past-current maritime investigation of known and sought after Phoenician shipwrecks (e.g., SW coast of the southern Levant; the Malta-Carthage trade route), (2) two geneticists' --(i.e., Pierre Zalloua and Spencer Wells)-- study of modern DNA from residents in modern Carthage, Tyre, and elsewhere (in comparison to samples from a tooth from a Phoenician royal burial of King Tabnit), (3) Paco Giles' excavations of a Phoenician cultic deposit in Gorham's Cave at Gibraltar, (4) Claude Dumet Sirhal's five seasons of excavations of a Phoenician cemetery and other Canaanite remains at Sidon, and (5) a Lebanese ship builders's reconstruction and sailing of a replica Phoenician ship. The documentary incorporates various discussions by other specialists, Larry Stager, Glenn Markoe, and Ian Morris, plus coverage of the biblical traditions regarding the Phoenicians, Herodotus' references to Phoenician voyages, the sites of Carthage and the Temple of Eshmun, and other aspects about Phoenician ships, navigation, trade, and rivalries with Rome.
Amidst various methodologies for the comparative study of the Hebrew Bible, at times the opportunity arises to improve on a method recently introduced into the field. In YHWH is King, Flynn uses the anthropological method of cultural... more
Amidst various methodologies for the comparative study of the Hebrew Bible, at times the opportunity arises to improve on a method recently introduced into the field. In YHWH is King, Flynn uses the anthropological method of cultural translation to study diachronic change in YHWH's kingship. Here, such change is compared to a similar Babylonian development to Marduk's kingship. Based on that comparison and informed by cultural translation, Flynn discovers that Judahite scribes suppressed the earlier YHWH warrior king and promoted a creator/universal king in order to combat the increasing threat of Neo-Assyrian imperialism. Flynn thus opens the possibility, that Judahite scribes engaged in a cultural translation of Marduk to YHWH, in order to respond to the mounting Neo-Assyrian presence.
The Hebrew Bible contains a variety of traditions concerning which meat cuts from animal sacrifices comprised the "priestly portion. " The variant textual traditions invite questions related to the historical situations that gave rise to... more
The Hebrew Bible contains a variety of traditions concerning which meat cuts from animal sacrifices comprised the "priestly portion. " The variant textual traditions invite questions related to the historical situations that gave rise to these traditions and fostered their incorporation in the present form of the Pentateuch. This article identifies these traditions and explores questions of priority and provenance, first, from text-critical and source-critical perspectives, and, second, by considering the traditions in light of textual, iconographic, and zooarchaeo-logical data from the broader ancient Near Eastern world. Text-critical and source-critical approaches highlight the complexity of the issue and affirm two dominant systems: one assigning the hindlimb to the priests and another the forelimb, presumably from the right side of the animal in both cases. Ancient Near Eastern texts, iconography, and archaeology suggest that the origins of both traditions stretch deep into the Late Bronze and Iron Ages, the forelimb tradition perhaps the earlier of the two and rooted in southern regions, and the hindlimb tradition rooted in northern regions. A point of coalescence is identified geographically in the southern Levant and chronologically in the Iron Age II, con-comitant with the rise of the kingdoms of Israel and Judah. In this light, any assumption that Priestly cultic literature is a unified, postexilic, Jerusalem-centered corpus may need to be reexamined. An important aspect of the Israelite sacrificial system, as described in the Hebrew Bible, was the provision of the "priestly portion. " As in other societies in which sacrifice was a fundamental aspect of the cult, this allowance-a portion of the meat, grain, or other offered substance-served to maintain the sacrificial JBL 138, no. 2 (2019): 263-284 doi: http://dx.
This entry focuses on the religions in the northern Hejaz and neighboring regions during the Late Bronze and Iron Ages and later (ca. 1500-300 BCE), the first time when there is firm archaeological and epigraphic evidence of local cultic... more
This entry focuses on the religions in the northern Hejaz and neighboring regions during the Late Bronze and Iron Ages and later (ca. 1500-300 BCE), the first time when there is firm archaeological and epigraphic evidence of local cultic practices.
The presented master’s thesis deals with the Epic of Zimrī-Lîm, a text from the ancient city of Mari from the beginning of the 18th century BC. The text of the epic is included in transliteration (based on the edition by Michaël Guichard... more
The presented master’s thesis deals with the Epic of Zimrī-Lîm, a text from the ancient city of Mari from the beginning of the 18th century BC. The text of the epic is included in transliteration (based on the edition by Michaël Guichard from 2014) and in English translation. The epic has also been published online as the first entry of NERE (Near Eastern Royal Epics) project on ORACC (Open Richly Annotated Cuneiform Corpus). In addition to the text itself, the thesis includes a broader historical-cultural commentary. There, selected elements of the ancient text are portraited as well-set within the lived cultural-political environment of the ancient Near East, with particular attention to the time of Zimrī-Lîm. Most of the space is devoted to the religious aspect of the work, especially the role of the deities. Last but not least, the composition is discussed within the context of other royal epics of the ancient Near East.
This paper deals with the possibility of retracing the monumental setting of ancient contexts now lost and not documented directly by the study of indirect sources that describe them, literally or visually. The assumption is that... more
This paper deals with the possibility of retracing the monumental setting of ancient contexts now lost and not documented directly by the study of indirect sources that describe them, literally or visually. The assumption is that monuments that did not come down to the present day can nonetheless be studied and contextualized thanks to what is echoed in literary or epigraphic sources and to their depiction in other media.
Here, the possibility that one or more now-lost statues representing the mušḫuššu, the serpo-dragon of Marduk, were erected at Babylon at least since the Late Babylonian period is discussed on the basis of both epigraphic and iconographic evidence.
The article approaches the mythical epic Inūma ilū awīlum with respect to its narrative structure and procedure. Within this framework, it investigates the ideas pertaining to the nature of violence that is communicated through the... more
The article approaches the mythical epic Inūma ilū awīlum with respect to its narrative structure and procedure. Within this framework, it investigates the ideas pertaining to the nature of violence that is communicated through the sequence of events within the poem. The mode chosen to inform the epic’s reader is understood as narrative exemplification, being an equivalent to the demonstration of general principles through representative examples that can often be found in other epistemic contexts in ancient Mesopotamia, e. g. in mathematics or divination. Thus, the paper not only reconstructs a specific concept of violence but also elaborates on the more general question of whether and how these intellectual means might represent some form of a Babylonian philosophy.
Much ink has been spilled on the examination of Mesopotamian conceptions of the divine in the past, and the topic has received renewed attention in the present. The following article offers yet another synthetic analysis of the... more
Much ink has been spilled on the examination of Mesopotamian conceptions of the divine in the past, and the topic has received renewed attention in the present. The following article offers yet another synthetic analysis of the Mesopotamian divine sphere, amassing in one place a vast array of data and the scholarly assessments of that data. More particularly, after examining what constitutes a god in ancient Mesopotamia and the essential and characteristic qualities of Mesopotamian deities, the article attempts to sort the divine sphere, focusing on the relationship between the various beings that populate the divine world and between a single deity and its various aspects. However, although synthetic, the present contribution offers several new insights. Most prominently, it posits the concept of divine constellations as a model for understanding Mesopotamian deities, in which the major Mesopotamian deities are presented as a constellation of aspects that may be treated as (semi-)independent beings or as a unity depending on the context.
ºðºì²Ü îºÔ²Üì²Ü ̲ ¶Ø²Ü Þàôðae ²ñÙ»Ý ä»ïñáëÛ³Ý (Ðݳ·ÇïáõÃÛ³Ý ¨ ³½·³·ñáõÃÛ³Ý ÇÝëïÇïáõï) 1) ºñ¨³Ý ³Ýí³ÝáõÙÁ ѳÛÏ³Ï³Ý Ñ³Ù³ï»ùëïáõÙ Ùdzݷ³Ù³ÛÝ Ã³÷³ÝóÇÏ Ï³éáõóí³Íù áõÝÇ: ÐÝáõÙ »ñ¨³Ý (Û»ñ¨³Ý, Û»ñ¨³ÝÇ ï³ñµ»ñ³ÏÝ»ñáí) Ýß³Ý³Ï»É ¿` §»ñ¨áõÙÝ ¨... more
ºðºì²Ü îºÔ²Üì²Ü ̲ ¶Ø²Ü Þàôðae ²ñÙ»Ý ä»ïñáëÛ³Ý (Ðݳ·ÇïáõÃÛ³Ý ¨ ³½·³·ñáõÃÛ³Ý ÇÝëïÇïáõï) 1) ºñ¨³Ý ³Ýí³ÝáõÙÁ ѳÛÏ³Ï³Ý Ñ³Ù³ï»ùëïáõÙ Ùdzݷ³Ù³ÛÝ Ã³÷³ÝóÇÏ Ï³éáõóí³Íù áõÝÇ: ÐÝáõÙ »ñ¨³Ý (Û»ñ¨³Ý, Û»ñ¨³ÝÇ ï³ñµ»ñ³ÏÝ»ñáí) Ýß³Ý³Ï»É ¿` §»ñ¨áõÙÝ ¨ »ñ¨»ÉÇ. Û³Ûï. Û³ÛïÝǦ. »ñ¨³Ý ·³É, »ñ¨³Ý Ñ³Ý»É §Ç Û³Ûï ·³É, »ñ¨ÇÉ, Û³Ûïݻɦ 1 : ²ñ¹Ç ѳۻñ»ÝáõÙ ³ñ˳ǽ٠¿, áñÁ ÏÇñ³éíáõÙ ¿ áñå»ë ѳñ³¹ñáõÃÛáõÝÝ»-ñÇ µ³Õ³¹ñÇã` »ñ¨³Ý µ»ñ»É, »ñ¨³Ý ·³É, »ñ¨³Ý Ñ³Ý»É ³ñï³Ñ³ÛïáõÃÛáõÝÝ»ñáõÙ 2 : ¸»ñç³ÝÇó ѳÛïÝÇ ¿ ºñ¨³Ýë ·ÛáõÕÁ 3 , ³ÏÝѳÛïáñ»Ý, ÝáõÛÝ³Ï³Ý ºñ¨³ÝÇÝ, Ñá·Ý³ÏÇ Ñ³Ûó³Ï³Ý ÑáÉáí³Ó¨áí, ³ÛëÇÝùÝ` ³Û¹ µ³éÇ ï»Õ³Ýí³Ý³Ï³Ý ÏÇñ³éáõÃÛáõÝÁ ÙdzÏÁ ã¿: ºñ»õ-³ñÙ³ïÁ µÝÇÏ Ñ³ÛÏ³Ï³Ý ¿ 4 , áñÁ ѳݹ»ë ¿ ·³ÉÇë ݳ¨ ³ÛÉ Ñ³ÛÏ³Ï³Ý ï»Õ³ÝáõÝÝ»ñáõÙ` ºñ»õ»³É, ºñ»õ³ñ: ÄáÕáíñ¹³Ï³Ý ³í³Ý¹áõÃÛáõÝÁ Ù»ç ºñ¨³ÝÁ ϳåíáõÙ ¿ ÜáÛÇ ³Ýí³Ý Ñ»ï` ǵñ ÜáÛÝ ¿ ³Û¹å»ë Ïáã»É ³é³çÇÝ çñѻջÕÇó Ñ»ïá »ñ¨³óáÕ ³Ýçáõñ í³ÛñÁ 5 : ²ÛëåÇëáí, ºñ¨³Ý ï»Õ³ÝáõÝÁ Ùdzݷ³Ù³ÛÝ µÝ³Ï³Ý Ï»ñåáí ϳåí»É ¿ ѳٳÑáõÝã µ³éÇÝ:
This article examines the gender image of the Mesopotamian cult attendant known as gala (Sumerian) / kalû (Akkadian) against the background of the theory of hegemonic masculinity, putting an emphasis on visual representations as sources... more
This article examines the gender image of the Mesopotamian cult attendant known as gala (Sumerian) / kalû (Akkadian) against the background of the theory of hegemonic masculinity, putting an emphasis on visual representations as sources of information. The gala/kalû was a performer in funerals, and later a professional lamenter in the cult of Inanna/Ištar. His gender identity has long been considered to have possessed ambiguous elements: effeminate, homoerotic, and the like. A more nuanced approach is offered here, whereby the gala/kalû’s gender image is analyzed as a social construct of a non-hegemonic type of masculinity. To this end, visual representations are considered in addition to textual evidence.
This paper is an illustrated version of the 2016 paper by the same name.
Within a literary ontology, YHWH in the Hebrew Bible is technically also a fictional entity or object. In Hebrew Bible scholarship, a variety of philosophical issues surrounding fiction have received sustained and in-depth attention.... more
Within a literary ontology, YHWH in the Hebrew Bible is technically also a fictional entity or object. In Hebrew Bible scholarship, a variety of philosophical issues surrounding fiction have received sustained and in-depth attention. However, the mainstream research on these matters tends to focus on the philosophical foundations of or backgrounds to a particular literary theory, rather than on metaphysical puzzles as encountered in the philosophy of fiction proper. To fill this gap, the present article seeks to provide a meta-theoretical overview of the main contemporary philosophical perspectives on the metaphysics of fictional objects. Three views (and their sub-currents) are discussed, namely possibilism, (neo-)Meinongianism and (literary) creationism. Each view’s theory is introduced and critically appropriated with reference to what is implied to be an answer to the question of what exactly the biblical character YHWH can meaningfully be said to be in the context of the metaphysics of fictional objects. In this way, the present study also goes beyond the traditional concern with the nature of God in Old Testament theology.
The Triple Moon Goddess of contemporary Pagan and New Age thought is generally assumed to be an invention ex nihilo of the 20th century, with no precursor in classical antiquity, created by the poetic imagination of Robert Graves... more
The Triple Moon Goddess of contemporary Pagan and New Age thought is generally assumed to be an invention ex nihilo of the 20th century, with no precursor in classical antiquity, created by the poetic imagination of Robert Graves (1895-1985), with possible inspiration from the classicist and anthropologist Jane Ellen Harrison (1850-1928). However this hypothesis is incorrect. The Triple Goddess was presented in the 20th century before Graves. In addition, this paper is the first to reveal some astrological and esoteric as well as scholarly writings of the 19th century which presented and discussed a triple moon goddess from the ancient world whose identity would have been familiar to most educated men (and a few women) of the time.
ABSTRACT: This documentary (no. 3) contains mainly a series of hypothetical and chronological reenactments, following a few (fictional) family lineages across centuries and millennia, from early hunter-gatherers ca. 12,000 BP (10,000 BCE)... more
ABSTRACT: This documentary (no. 3) contains mainly a series of hypothetical and chronological reenactments, following a few (fictional) family lineages across centuries and millennia, from early hunter-gatherers ca. 12,000 BP (10,000 BCE) to early sedentary hunter-gatherer folks ca. 9,000 BP (7,000 BCE), tribal societies and chiefdoms (a bit later in the sequence), and early cities ca. 5,500+ BP (3,500 BCE in the documentary: Uruk phase in Mesopotamia). The question sheet aids in furnishing a summary of the documentary's coverage and sequence of specific topics. The reenactments are interwoven with narrative and accompanied by selected interviews with and commentaries by a number of specialists (e.g., Bar-Yosef; George Willcox; Jean Guilaine; Yves Coppens; Ian Hodder; Jean Denis Vigne; Philippe Andrieux; Jean Marie Durand), aiding in following a sequence of archaeological data, theories, and broader extrapolations (and sometimes less convincing scenarios) regarding the rise of agriculture and animal husbandry, the emergence of urban societies, and various other key innovations (e.g., metal working; writing). The documentary is a fairly decent visualization, albeit a major condensation and simplification (with a few technical errors in the narration/film: e.g., chronological misplacement of a chariot scene [presumably drawing upon the much later Ur III wagon depictions, or maybe even 4th millennium BCE+ European carts and wagons]), of the complex mechanisms and processes of change from the Neolithic through rise of early urban societies in the Ancient Near East (Despite some reservations, I'm using it in an introductory, college level survey of the Ancient Near East).